Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2020 Jun 1.
Published in final edited form as: Small. 2019 Apr 23;15(24):e1805530. doi: 10.1002/smll.201805530

Table 1.

Various bioinks formulated for engineering skeletal muscle tissue through additive manufacturing technologies.

Bioprinting strategy Bioink composition Myogenic
progenitors
In vitro/In vivo results Reference

FDM/DIW(ITOP) Gelatin/fibrinogen/HA C2C12 • Multi-cellular constructs aimed at mimicking the myotendinous junction (MTJ) were fabricated intercalating hydrogel fibers loaded with C2C12 or NIH/3T3 between PU or PCL fibers
• Zonal cellular organization typical of MTJ was recapitulated
Merceron et al. [82]
Microfluidic/Co-axial bioprinting Alginate/PEG-Fibrinogen C2C12 • Multi-cellular constructs with compartmentalized cell spatial organization
• Anisotropic aligned structures support myoblast 3D organization and differentiation
Costantini et al. [88]
Inkjet printing Suspension of cells in sterile phosphate-buffered saline (PBS) solution C2C12 • High resolution (85 εm) and cell viability (>90%)
• Development of bio-MEMS
• Formation of confluent myotubes after 4 days on cantilevers
Gao et al. [95]
SLA Matrigel/Fibrinogen/Collagen I C2C12 • Maturation of myotubes after electrical stimulation
• Formation of biohybrid robot powered by an antagonistic pair of skeletal muscle tissues
• Inchworm-like crawling locomotion of the structure at 117.8 εm/s
Cvetkovic et al. [96]
SLA Matrigel/Fibrinogen Optogenetic C2C12 • Bio-bots powered by bioactuators controlled by noninvasive light stimuli
• Directional locomotion (310 μm/s or 1.3 body lengths/min) and 2D rotational steering (2°/s)
Raman et al. [98]
SLA Matrigel/Fibrinogen C2C12 • Development of a mesoscale model for studying skeletal muscle physiology in vitro
• Larger active tension forces created in muscle rings (184 ± 20 μN) after 17 days of growth in response to optical stimulation
Raman et al. [99]
FDM/Electrospinning/DIW Alginate/PEO C2C12 • Control of myoblast proliferation and organization by assembling a cell-laden hierarchical scaffold containing additional multi-layered PCL struts and micro/nanofibers Yeo et al. [100], [101]
FDM C2C12 • Aligned scaffolds were fabricated out of PVA/PCL (3:7 ratio). After leaching PVA, samples were coated with collagen
• Micropatterned/fibrous PCL bundles guided C2C12 alignment
Kim et al. [102]
FDM/DIW Muscle-derived ECM C2C12 • Biomimetic matrix supported higher cell viability, increased cell proliferation and myogenic gene expression compared to constructs prepared with collagen bioink.
• Pre-patterning of acetylcholine receptors
Choi et al. [103]
FDM/DIW Gelatin/fibrinogen/HA/Glycerol C2C12 • Myotube formation after 7 days of in vitro culture
• Bioprinted constructs implanted subcutaneously in nude rats showed organized muscle fibers, acetylcholine receptors, nerve contacts, and vascularization
Kang et al. [104]
FDM/DIW(ITOP) Fibrinogen/Gelatin Human muscle progenitor cells (hMCs) isolated from biopsies • Transplantation of the construct in a rat tibialis anterior (TA) muscle defect model
• 82% restoration of the muscle force after 8 weeks post-surgery
• Bioprinted constructs well-integrated with the vascular and neural networks
Kim et al. [105]
3D printing/gel casting Silk fibroin/Collagen I/Matrigel Human primary skeletal myoblasts
(hSKMs)
• Myoblasts can be differentiated in co-culture with NG108–15 and hiNSC-derived motoneuron-like cells in 2D and 2.5 with mature cell-specific phenotypic expression
• 3D neuromuscular co-cultures can be formed with active anisotropic myofiber function.
Dixon et al. [106]