Table. Description of Included Studies.
Study | Date | Design | Setting | Symptoms of Population | Data on Prevalence (% of Patients)a | Scoreb |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Bacteremia-only studies | ||||||
Chiu et al,19 1994 | 1992-1993 | P, C | ED (Taiwan) | Temperature ≥38.0°C; previously healthyc | 0-31 d: All 254 had blood culture, 13 B (5)d | 9 |
Bonsu et al,13 2003 | 1992-1999 | R, C | ED | Rectal temperature ≥38.0°C in ED or home | Study (n = 3961), 151 excluded for missing data, 1353 aged >56 d; 0-28 d: all 950 had blood culture, 14 B (2); 29-56 d: all 1507 had blood culture, 17 B (1) | 7 |
Chiu et al,20 1997 | 1994-1995 | P, C | ED (Taiwan) | Temperature ≥38.0°C; previously healthyc | 0-28 d: All 250 had blood culture, 11 B (4)d | 9 |
Garcia et al,22 2012e | 2003-2010 | R, C | ED (Spain) | Rectal temperature ≥38.0°C in ED or home | 0-28 d: 207 of 307 had blood culture, 8 B (4)d; 29-56 d: 620 of 641 had blood culture, 21 B (3)d | 8 |
No obvious source of fever | ||||||
No respiratory symptoms | ||||||
No diarrhea | ||||||
Meningitis-only studies | ||||||
None | ||||||
Bacteremia and meningitis studies | ||||||
Ferrera et al,18 1997 | 1990-1994 | R, C | ED | Temperature ≥38.0°C in ED or home | 0-28 d: (n = 188), 167 (89) had blood culture and 148 (79) had CSF culture, 6 B (4), 4 M (3); B/M concurrence not reportedf | 8 |
No obvious infectious source | ||||||
Bonadio et al,14 1993 | 1991-2000 | P, C | ED | Rectal temperature ≥38.0°C in ED or home | 28-56 d: All 534 had blood culture and CSF culture, 7 B (1), 4 M (1); no concurrent B/M | 9 |
Bachur and Harper,3 2001e | 1993-1999 | R, C | ED | Rectal temperature ≥38.0°Cc | 0-30 d: (n = 1298), 1215 (94) had blood culture and 1147 (88) had CSF culture, 26 B (2), 10 M (1); B/M concurrence not reported. 31-60 d: (n = 2104), 1866 (89) had blood culture and 1717 (82) had CSF culture, 19 B (1), 4 M (0); B/M concurrence not reported | 8 |
Baker and Bell,15 1999 | 1994-1996 | P, C | ED | Rectal temperature ≥38.0°Cc | 3-28 d: All 254 had blood culture and CSF culture, 8 B (3), 4 M (2); 3 concurrent B/M | 8 |
Herr et al,17 2001 | 1999-2000 | R, C | ED | Temperature ≥38.0°Cc | 0-28 d: (n = 179), 13 excluded for missing data, all remaining 166 had blood culture and CSF culture, 1B (1), 2 M (1); no concurrent B/M; 29-60 d: (n = 285), 17 excluded for missing data, all remaining 268 had blood culture and CSF culture, 6 B (2), 0 M (0) | 8 |
Caviness et al,16 2008 | 2001-2005 | R, C | ED | Rectal temperature ≥38.0°C in ED | 0-28 d: (n = 960), 893 (93) had blood culture and 874 (91) had CSF culture, 30 B (3), 13 M (1)g; B/M concurrence not reported | 6 |
Zarkesh et al,21 2011 | 2004-2009 | R, C | ED (Iran) | Temperature ≥38.5°C in ED | 0-28 d: (n = 253), 51 excluded for incomplete records, all remaining 202 had blood culture and CSF culture, 8 B (4), 1 M (0); 1 concurrent B/M | 8 |
No prior admission | ||||||
Full term | ||||||
No chronic disease | ||||||
No recent antibiotics | ||||||
Ashkenazi-Hoffnung et al,23 2011e | 2005-2009 | P, C | Pediatric department (Israel, unclear if ED or clinic) | Rectal temperature ≥38.0°Cc | Study (n = 1584) of febrile infants aged ≤90 d, but only those aged 0-28 d were consecutive; 0-28 d: all 510 had blood culture and CSF culture, 12 B (2), 0 M (0) | 9 |
No chronic disease | ||||||
Born >34 wk | ||||||
No recent antibiotics |
Abbreviations: B, bacteremia; C, consecutively enrolled patients; CSF, cerebrospinal fluid; ED, emergency department; M, meningitis; P, prospective; R, retrospective.
Percentages are rounded to nearest integer.
Newcastle-Ottawa Scale bias scores range from 1 (worst) to 9 (best).
Unclear whether this status needed to be during evaluation or if it could have been at home as well.
Unable to use CSF culture data owing to inability to identify the total number of CSF cultures obtained or owing to potential selection bias (eg, CSF culture obtained only if clinical suspicion for meningitis).
Additional unpublished data obtained via correspondence with original authors.
There were 724 infants presenting in the ED; 43 incomplete records were excluded; of the remaining 681 infants, 188 had fever without an obvious source, 21 had undocumented blood culture, and 40 had undocumented CSF culture.
There may have been 12 of 874 (1%); unclear owing to rounding in the fluid cultures of the original study.