Table 2.
Surgeons’ experience and operating time
Author | Patients | Number of participating surgeons | Experience | Operation time |
---|---|---|---|---|
Eklund [17] |
n = 665 TEP n = 706 Lichtenstein |
TEP: 11 hospitals, 48 surgeon 22 TEP group 26 Lichtenstein group |
≥ 25 TEP No surgeon did both techniques |
Median: 55 (12–180) min TEP; 55 (20–145) min Lichtenstein; ns |
Lau [26] |
n = 100 TEP; n = 100 Lichtenstein |
– | Specialist surgeons who had experience exceeding 200 corresponding procedures |
50 ± 13,2 min for TEP vs 58 ± 17,6 min for Lichtenstein; p < 0.001 |
Heikkinen [19] |
n = 22 TEP n = 23 Lichtenstein All employed |
1 Surgical resident | Special interesting and fair experience with open and laparoscopic hernia surgery |
Median: 67,5 [72–88] min, range 40–88 min for TEP vs 53 min, range 42–78 min for Lichtenstein; p = 0.001 |
Hamza [39] | n = 25 TEP; n = 25 Lichtenstein | 1 Surgeon performing all operation in a four-arm trial (TEP, TAPP, Lichtenstein, open preperitoneal | – |
77.4 ± 43.21 min for TEP vs 34.21 ± 23.5 for Lichtenstein; p < 0.001 |
Dahlstrand [40] | n = 194 TEP; n = 195 Lichtenstein |
2 Hospitals, 4 Surgeons |
All surgeons were experienced in open and laparoscopic procedures and did not have a preference for either technique |
Median 60 min, range 50–72 min for TEP, 70 min, range 60–80 min for Lichtenstein; p < 0.001 |
Dhankhar [41] | n = 29 TEP; n = 30 Lichtenstein | 2 Hospitals |
75.93 ± 13.68 min for TEP vs 64.77 ± 12.66 min for Lichtenstein; p = 0.002 |
|
Gokalp [18] | n = 61 TEP; n = 62 Lichtenstein | 1 Hospital | – |
62 ± 14 min for TEP vs 46 ± 11 min for Lichtenstein; p < 0.01 |