Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2019 Jun 24.
Published in final edited form as: J Mem Lang. 2018 Dec 1;105:19–42. doi: 10.1016/j.jml.2018.10.003

Table 3. Outcomes of the meta-analysis of unmatched features on transfer.

Unmatched feature at training
Intervention effects Heterogeneity


Feature category Transfer feature k N n d SE 95% CI z p Q I2 p
Stimulus type
Digits 10 15 564 0.357 0.136 0.091–0.623 2.631 0.009 21.545 58.228 0.010
Letters 3 9 233 0.337 0.169 0.006–0.668 1.998 0.046 3.019 33.752 0.221
Words/nonwords 8 18 482 0.294 0.159 −0.017 to 0.606 1.855 0.064 19.026 63.209 0.008
Objects 3 22 136 0.403 0.174 0.062–0.744 2.316 0.021 0.571 0.000 0.752
Spatial location 5 10 286 0.360 0.411 −0.446 to 1.166 0.875 0.382 42.027 90.482  < .001
Stimulus domain
Verbal 5 14 246 0.018 0.136 −0.248 to 0.283 0.130 0.897 4.382 8.711 0.357
Visuo-spatial 4 11 257 0.643 0.423 −0.185 to 1.472 1.522 0.128 29.480 89.824  < .001
Stimulus modality
Auditory 2 6 121 0.128 0.288 −0.437 to 0.693 0.443 0.658 2.394 58.236 0.658
Visual
Response modality
Spoken 12 26 672 0.401 0.103 0.199–0.602 3.899 0.000 18.192 39.533 0.077
Manual
Serial recall
Verbal 6 11 305 0.173 0.150 −0.122 to 0.468 1.151 0.250 8.219 39.167 0.145
Visuo-spatial 6 10 279 0.138 0.121 −0.990 to 0.376 1.140 0.254 4.810 0.000 0.440
All 10 21 490 0.158 0.077 0.008–0.308 2.064 0.039 21.254 20.014 0.215
Complex span
Verbal 8 11 416 0.046 0.103 −0.155 to 0.248 0.452 0.652 7.340 4.636 0.394
Visuo-spatial 7 16 379 0.183 0.103 −0.019 to 0.386 1.776 0.076 1.467 0.000 0.962
Cross-domain
All 12 27 649 0.112 0.072 −0.029 to 0.253 1.562 0.118 9.728 0.000 0.782
Backward span
Verbal 3 3 178 0.144 0.153 −0.315 to 0.644 0.673 0.501 5.113 60.885 0.078
Cross-domain
All 4 4 239 0.354 0.258 −0.152 to 0.860 1.372 0.170 11.298 73.446 0.010

k = number of studies; N = number of effect sizes; n = number of participants.