Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2019 Jun 24.
Published in final edited form as: J Mem Lang. 2018 Dec 1;105:19–42. doi: 10.1016/j.jml.2018.10.003

Table 4. Outcomes of the meta-analysis collapsed across feature match condition on transfer and the feature moderator analysis.

All features
Feature moderator analysis
Intervention effects Heterogeneity



Feature category Transfer feature k N n d SE 95% CI z p Q I2 p R2 p
Stimulus type
Digits 13 22 985 0.619 0.139 0.347–0.892 4.459  < .001 67.416 76.267  < .001 0.490 0.003
Letters 7 19 478 0.306 0.099 0.113–0.500 3.111 0.002 7.774 9.953 0.353 0.000 0.163
Words/nonwords 11 22 597 0.361 0.134 0.098–0.623 2.660 0.007 24.006 58.344 0.008 0.090 0.362
Objects 4 24 221 0.468 0.137 0.200–0.737 3.420 0.001 1.015 0.000 0.908 0.000 0.543
Spatial location 161 36 810 0.516 0.125 0.271–0.761 4.122  < .001 61.205 70.591  < .001 0.020 0.462
Stimulus domain
Verbal 23 62 1185 0.370 0.070 0.232–0.508 5.253  < .001 36.101 33.521 0.054 0.690 0.004
Visuo-spatial 16 51 912 0.531 0.111 0.314–0.748 4.798  < .001 44.425 61.733  < .001 0.090 0.401
Stimulus modality
Auditory 13 27 759 0.416 0.094 0.231–0.601 4.408  < .001 20.478 36.517 0.084 0.400 0.134
Visual
Response modality
Spoken 14 31 738 0.422 0.094 0.238–0.607 4.486  < .001 19.732 34.118 0.102 0.080 0.482
Serial recall
Verbal 14 20 814 0.371 0.093 0.189–0.554 3.985  < .001 22.742 38.439  < .001 0.830 0.044
Visuo-spatial 14 20 826 0.732 0.18 0.380–1.084 4.076  < .001 82.633 81.847  < .001 0.530  < .001
All 16 40 910 0.445 0.081 0.286–0.604 5.471  < .001 95.801 63.466  < .001 0.560  < .001
Complex span
Verbal 12 19 407 0.263 0.117 .034–0.492 2.253 0.024 29.541 55.994 0.005 0.870 0.002
Visuo-spatial 9 20 447 0.390 0.132 0.130–0.650 2.942 0.003 17.892 49.698 0.036 1.000  < .001
All 15 43 859 0.320 0.083 0.157–0.483 3.854  < .001 60.968 55.715  < .001 0.290 0.021
Backward span
Verbal 10 10 559 0.579 0.146 0.294–0.865 3.973  < .001 24.252 62.889 0.004 0.800 0.025
All 11 13 620 0.724 0.146 0.438–1.010 4.961  < .001 44.09 72.783  < .001 0.41 0.026

k = number of studies; N = number of effect sizes; n = number of participants.