Skip to main content
. 2019 Jun 27;14(6):e0210928. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0210928

Table 1. Errors observed during the curation process and their possible causes.

Causes that should be (mostly) already resolved by the stage a researcher would start checking for specific errors are in parentheses and italicized.

Error Cause Solution
Low call rate and impossible cluster identification Probe binding issues Remove SNP from data set
Unexpected B-allele frequencies (Probe binding issues) (Remove SNP from data set)
  Unexpected ploidy Remove sample from data set
Low sample quality Remove sample from data set
High number P(P)C errors (Probe binding issues) (Remove SNP from data set)
(Low sample quality) (Remove sample from data set)
Incorrect pedigree Adjust pedigree record
Incorrect clustering Manually determine genotype clusters
  Incorrect genotype call(s) not due to cluster issues Adjust genotype call(s) or remove SNP from data set
Low number P(P)C errors (Probe binding issues) (Remove SNP from data set)
(Low sample quality) (Remove sample from data set)
(Incorrect pedigree) (Adjust pedigree record)
Incorrect clustering Manually determine genotype clusters
  Incorrect genotype call(s) not due to cluster issues Adjust genotype call(s)
High number double recombinations (Probe binding issues) (Remove SNP from data set)
(Low sample quality) (Remove sample from data set)
(Incorrect pedigree) (Adjust pedigree record)
(Unexpected ploidy) (Remove sample from data set)
Incorrect clustering Manually determine genotype clusters
Incorrect marker position in map Adjust marker position or remove marker if it cannot be accurately mapped
Incorrect genotype call(s) not due to cluster issues Adjust genotype call(s)
  Incorrect phasing Find responsible individual and make genotype missing
Low number double recombinations (Probe binding issues) (Remove SNP from data set)
(Low sample quality) (Remove sample from data set)
(Incorrect pedigree) (Adjust pedigree record)
(Incorrect clustering) (Manually determine genotype clusters)
Nearby double recombination* Resolve nearby double recombination
Incorrect marker position in map Adjust marker position or remove marker if it cannot be accurately mapped
Incorrect genotype call(s) not due to cluster issues Adjust genotype call(s)
  Incorrect phasing Wait for haploblock analysis to resolve issue
Incorrect haplotype determination (Probe binding issues) (Remove SNP from data set)
(Low sample quality) (Remove sample from data set)
(Incorrect pedigree) (Adjust pedigree record)
(Incorrect clustering) (Manually determine genotype clusters)
(Incorrect marker position in map) (Adjust marker position or remove marker if it cannot be accurately mapped)
(Incorrect genotype call(s) not due to cluster issues) (Adjust genotype call(s))
Incorrect phasing Manually correct phasing (determine correct haplotypes)
  Recombination within haplotype Adjust haploblock borders

*Nearby double recombination can occur for two adjacent markers with many double recombinations and markers with few double recombinations. However, nearby double recombinations rarely lead to a high number of double recombinations for a single marker