Skip to main content
. 2019 Jun 21;9:510. doi: 10.3389/fonc.2019.00510

Table 2.

Overcoming resistance to endocrine therapy.

Trial/ Phase Intervention Comparison T# # pt Pt characteristics Disease characteristics Previous therapy Survival
Age Menopausal status
Pre meno Post meno HR +ve HER2 –ve Chemo Endocrine OS PFS or TTP CBR ORR
INHIBITORS OF CYCLIN-DEPENDENT KINASES 4 AND 6
Finn et al. (86) Palbociclib + letrozole 1 444 62 0 100 100 100 48 56.1 NR 24.8 84.9 42.1
Phase 3 Placebo + letrozole 222 61 0 100 100 100 49.1 56.8 NR 14.5 70.3 34.7
p <0.001 <0.001 0.06
Cristofanilli et al. (87) Fulvestrant + palbociclib =>2 347 57 21 79 100 100 40 100 34.9 9.5 67 19
Phase 3 Fulvestrant + placebo 174 56 21 79 100 100 43 100 28 4.6 40 9
p 0.09 <0.0001 <0.0001 0.0019
Hortobagyi et al. (88) Ribociclib plus letrozole 1 334 62 0 100 100 100 43.7 52.4 NR 25.3 79.9 42.5
Phase 3 placebo plus letrozole 334 63 0 100 100 100 43.4 51.2 33 16 73.1 28.7
p 9.63 × 10−8 NS 9.18 × 10−5
Slamon et al. (89) Ribociclib + Fulvestrant =>1 484 63 0 100 100 100 A43.2,N13.4∧ 48.8 NR 20.5 70.2 32.4
Phase 3 Placebo + fulvestrant 242 63 0 100 100 100 A41.7,N12.4∧ 45 NR 12.8 62.8 21.5
p <0.001 0.02 <0.001
Tripathy et al. (90) Phase 3 Ribociclib + ET =>1 335 43 100 0 100 100 55 38 NR 23.8 79 41
Placebo + ET 337 45 100 0 100 100 55 42 NR 13 70 30
p <0.0001 0.0020 0.00098
Sledge et al. (91) Abemaciclib + fulvestrant 2 446 59 16.1 83.2 100 100 59.9 100 NR 16.3 72.2 35.2
Phase 3 Placebo + fulvestrant 223 62 18.8 80.7 100 100 60.1 100 NR 9.3 56.1 16.1
p <0.001 <0.001 <0.001
Goetz et al. (92) Abemaciclib + NSAI 1 328 63 0 100 100 100 38.1 45.7 NR NR 78 48.2
Phase 3 Placebo + NSAI 165 63 0 100 100 100 40 49.5 NR 14.7 71.5 34.5
p 0.000021 0.101 0.002
INHIBITORS OF MAMMALIAN TARGET OF RAPAMYCIN
Yardley et al. (93) Everolimus + exemestane 2 485 62 0 100 100 100 69 84 31 7.8 51.3 12.6
Phase 3 Exemestane + placebo 239 61 0 100 100 100 65 84 26.6 3.2 26.4 1.7
p 0.1426 <0.0001 <0.0001 <0.0001
Wolff et al. (94) Letrozole + temsirolimus 1 555 63 0 100 96 40 65 43 NR 8.9 NR 27
Phase 3 Letrozole + placebo 555 63 0 100 95 47 59 40 NR 9 NR 27
p 0.25 NS
Bachelot et al. (95) Tamoxifen + everolimus 2 54 63 0 100 100 98 70 100 NR TTP, 8.6 61 NR
Phase 2 Tamoxifen 57 66 0 100 100 93 82 100 32.9 4.5 42 NR
p <0.05 <0.05 <0.05
PI3K INHIBITORS
Baselga et al. (96) Buparlisib + fulvestrant =>2 576 62 0 100 100 100 24 100 33.2 6.9 43.8 11.8
Phase 3 Placebo + fulvestrant 571 61 0 100 100 100 31 99 30.4 5 42 7.7
p NS 0.00021 NS NS
Baselga et al. (97) Buparlisib plus fulvestrant =>2 289 60 0 100 100 100 36 100 NR 3.9 71 8
Phase 3 Placebo plus fulvestrant 143 62 0 100 100 100 35 100 NR 1.8 22 2
p 0.0003 NS NS
Baselga et al. (98) Taselisib + fulvestrant =>2 417 60 0 100 100 100 NR 100 26.8 7.4 51.5 28
Phase 3 Placebo + fulvestrant 214 61 0 100 100 100 NR 100 23.6 5.4 37.3 11.9
p 0.85 NS 0.0002
André et al. (99) Alpelisib + fulvestrant =>2 NR NR 0 100 100 100 NR 100 NR 11 NR 36
Phase 3 Placebo + fulvestrant NR NR 0 100 100 100 NR 100 NR 5.7 NR 16
p 0.00065 0.0002
HISTONE DEACYTELASE INHIBITORS
Yardley et al. (100) Exemestane + entinostat 2 64 63 0 100 98 92 58 100 28.1 4.28 28.1 6.3
Phase 2 Exemestane + placebo 66 62 0 100 98 89 67 100 19.8 2.27 25.8 4.6
p 0.036 0.055 0.78 0.58
Jiang et al. (101) Chidamide + exemestane 2 244 NR 0 100 100 100 NR 100 NR 7.4 46.7 18.4
Phase 3 placebo + exemestane 122 NR 0 100 100 100 NR 100 NR 3.8 35.5 9.1
p 0.0336 0.034 0.026
ANTI-ANGIOGENIC AGENTS
Gray et al. (102) paclitaxel + bevacizumab 1 368 56 NR NR 60.6 92.5 66.3 90.8 26.7 11.3 NR 48.9
Phase 3 paclitaxel 354 55 NR NR 63 89.9 65.3 89.3 25.2 5.9 NR 22.2
p 0.16 <0.0001 <0.0001
Pivot et al. (103) Phase 3 docetaxel + bevacizumab7.5 1 248 54 NR NR 78 100 65 85 30.8 9 NR 55.2
docetaxel + bevacizumab15 247 55 NR NR 76 100 68 77 30.2 10.1 NR 64.1
docetaxel + placebo 241 55 NR NR 78 100 65 88 31.9 8.2 NR 46.4
p NS 0.12,0.006 0.07,0.001
Martin et al. (104) ET + bevacizumab15 1 190 64 0 100 100 100 43.7 52.6 52.1 19.3 76.8 40.8
Phase 3 ET 184 66 0 100 100 100 47.8 51.6 51.8 14.4 67.4 21.9
p 0.518 0.126 0.041 <0.001
PROTEASOME INHIBITORS
Adelson et al. (105) Fulvestrant alone 2 59 57 0 100 100 100 27 66* NR 2.69 NR NR
Phase 2 Fulvestrant + bortezomib 57 59 0 100 100 100 30 30* NR 2.73 NR NR
p 0.06

T#, Treatment line; # pt, Number of patients; OS, Overall survival; PFS, Progression free survival; TTP, Time to progression; CBR, Clinical benefit rate; ORR, Objective response rate; NR, Not reported; NS, Not significant;

*

Rate of Endocrine therapy used for metastatic disease; A, Adjuvant; N, Neoadjuvant.