Skip to main content
. 2019 Jun 25;7:e7143. doi: 10.7717/peerj.7143

Table 2. Results of models evaluating the effects of sex and the interaction of sex and number of false head (FH) components, in addition to number of FH components and collection of origin (MZFC or CNIN), on the probability of symmetrical damage at the species (a) and genus (b) level.

In both models, sex and the interaction between sex and number of FH components were non-significant and therefore were removed from the initial models (a, c), leaving number of FH components and collection of origin as the only variables in the minimum adequate models (b, d). Significant P-values are in bold type.

Fixed Effects β± SEa Za PZa Pχ2b
(a) Species level initial (complete) model
Number of FH components 0.7459 ± 0.2299 3.244 1.18 × 10−3 7.652 × 10−3
Collection (MZFC-CNIN) 0.3989 ± 0.2129 1.874 0.06095 0.055
Sex 1.1220 ± 0.6293 1.783 0.07459 0.8001
Number of FH components * Sex −0.3851 ± 0.2145 −1.795 0.07259 0.0724
Random effects: σspecies2= 0.5674 n = 306 total observations from 105 species
(b) Species level minimum adequate model
Number of FH components 0.4999 ± 0.1827 2.736 6.21 × 10−3
Collection (MZFC-CNIN) 0.3955 ± 0.2126 1.860 0.06282
Random effects: σspecies2= 0.5478 n = 306 total observations from 105 species
c) Genus level initial (complete) model
Number of FH components 0.6274 ± 0.2840 2.209 0.0272 0.0488
Collection (MZFC-CNIN) 0.3999 ± 0.2035 1.966 0.0493 0.0424
Sex 0.6065 ± 0.6769 0.896 0.3703 0.8300
Number of FH components * Sex −0.2165 ± 0.2479 −0.873 0.3825 0.3842
Random effects: σgenus2= 0.4399 n = 150 total observations from 47 genera
(d) Genus level minimum adequate model
Number of FH components 0.4936 0.2415 2.044 0.041
Collection (MZFC-CNIN) 0.3989 0.2035 1.960 0.050
Random effects: σgenus2= 0.4404 n = 150 total observations from 47 genera

Notes.

a

Parameters from model.

b

P-value resulting from χ2 nested model comparisons following removal of each variable during backwards stepwise simplification.