Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2020 Apr 9.
Published in final edited form as: J Chem Theory Comput. 2019 Mar 13;15(4):2444–2453. doi: 10.1021/acs.jctc.8b01198

Table 2:

Ion-water binding energies (ΔE in kcal/mol) and optimum distances (d in Å) prior to (Orig11) and after recalibration (vdW*) of vdW parameters against PBE0+TS. The ionwater binding energy is defined as ΔE = EClusterEIonnEW, where ECluster, EIon and EW are the energies of the cluster, ion and water following independent energy optimizations, and n is the number of water molecules in the cluster. d is the distance between the ion and the oxygen atom of water. MAE is an abbreviation for Mean Absolute Error.

Ion # waters PBE0+TS Orig vdW*
ΔE d ΔE d ΔE d
Na+ 1 −24.7 2.23 −23.2 2.23 −25.0 2.17
2 −47.2 2.25 −43.8 2.26 −47.2 2.20
3 −66.1 2.27 −61.2 2.30 −65.6 2.24
4 −81.9 2.30 −75.3 2.34 −80.6 2.28
K+ 1 −18.4 2.63 −17.3 2.60 −18.0 2.57
2 −34.8 2.67 −32.7 2.64 −34.6 2.58
3 −49.4 2.70 −46.4 2.67 −49.1 2.60
4 −62.1 2.72 −58.2 2.70 −61.7 2.63
MAE 6.7% 0.9% 0.7% 2.5%