Table 1.
Reference | Sample | Drug type | Drug | Route | Dose | Max dose1 | Effect2 | Effect dose3 |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Kornetsky, Humphries, & Evarts, 1957 | 4F/6M | Agonist | Meperidine | PO | 50, 100 mg | low | ... | _ |
Smith, Semke, & Beecher, 1962 (Study 1) | 24M | Agonist | Morphine | SC | 10 mg | high | ↓ | high |
Smith, Semke, & Beecher, 1962 (Study 2) | 24M | Agonist | Heroin | SC | 4 mg | high | ↓ | high |
Agonist | Morphine | SC | 10 mg | high | ↓ | high | ||
Evans & Witt, 1966 | 16M | Agonist | Codeine | PO | 32 mg | low | ↕ | _ |
File & Silverstone, 1981 | 6F/6M | Antagonist | Naloxone | IV | 0.8, 1.6 mg | -low | ... | _ |
Jarvik, Simpson, Guthrie, & Liston, 1981 | 20M | Agonist | Morphine | IM | 10 mg | high | ... | _ |
Redpath & Pleuvry, 1982 | 4F/6M | Agonist | Codeine | PO | 30, 60 mg | low | ... | _ |
Bradley & Nicholson, 1986 | 6F | Agonist | Codeine | PO | 30, 90 mg | med | ... | _ |
Saarialho-Kere, Mattila, & Seppälä, 1986 | 10F/M | Agonist | Codeine | PO | 100 mg | med | ... | _ |
Mixed agonist | Pentazocine | PO | 75 mg | med | ... | _ | ||
Bradley & Nicholson, 1987 | 7F | Mixed agonist | Meptazinol | PO | 100, 200 mg | high | ... | _ |
Mixed agonist | Pentazocine | PO | 0, 25, 50 mg | low | ↓ | low | ||
Saarialho-Kere, Mattila, Paloheimo, & Seppälä, 1987 | 12F/M | Mixed agonist | Buprenorphine | SC | 0.4 mg | high | ↓ | high |
Saarialho-Kere, 1988 | 5F/7M | Mixed agonist | Nalbuphine | IM | 0-10.5 mg | high | ↓ | high |
Saarialho-Kere, Mattila, & Seppälä, 1988 | 11F/M | Mixed agonist | Pentazocine | IM | 30 mg | med | ↓ | med |
MacDonald, Gough, Nicoll, & Dow, 1989 | 12M | Mixed agonist | Buprenorphine | IM | 0.3 mg | high | ↓ | high |
Saarialho-Kere, Mattila, & Seppälä, 1989 | 9F/M | Agonist | Oxycodone | IM | 9.1 mg | high | ... | _ |
Zacny, Lichtor, & de Wit, 1992 | 6M | Agonist | Fentanyl | IV | 0.050 mg | med | ... | _ |
Zacny et al., 1993 | 1F/9M | Agonist | Meperidine | IV | 17.5-70 mg | high | ... | _ |
Oliveto, Bickel, Kamien, Hughes, & Higgins, 1994 | 2F/7M | Agonist | Hydromorphone | PO | 1-6 mg | high | ... | _ |
Veselis et al. 1994 | 1F/2M versus 3F/3M | Agonist | Fentanyl | IV | Continuous infusion: 1, 1.5, 2.5 ng/ml | high | ↓ | med |
Zacny, Coalson, Lichtor, Yajnik, & Thapar, 1994c (Study 1) | 3F/6M | Antagonist | Naloxone | IV | 0, 0.01, 0.1, 1.0 mg | -low | ... | _ |
Zacny, Coalson, Lichtor, Yajnik, & Thapar, 1994a (Study 2) | 3F/5M | Antagonist | Naloxone | IV | 0, 1.0, 3.0, 10 mg | -med | ... | _ |
Zacny, Lichtor, Flemming, Coalson, & Thompson, 1994b | 2F/10M | Agonist | Morphine | IV | 2.5-10 mg | high | ↓ | high |
Zacny, Lichtor, Thapar, et al., 1994c | 5F/7M | Agonist | Morphine | IV | 10 mg | high | ... | _ |
Partial Agonist | Butorphanol | IV | 0.5, 1, 2 mg | high | ↓ | high | ||
Zacny, Lichtor, Klafta, Alessi, & Apfelbaum, 1996a | 3F/7M | Agonist | Codeine | PO | 60 mg Codeine/600 mg Acetaminophen | low | ... | _ |
Mixed agonist | Butorphanol | TN | 1, 2 mg | high | ↓ | high | ||
Zacny, Conley, & Galinkin, 1997a | 5F/11M | Agonist | Morphine | IV | 10 mg | high | ... | _ |
Mixed agonist | Buprenorphine | IV | 0.075, 0.15, 0.3 | high | ↓ | low | ||
Zacny, Conley, & Marks, 1997b | 4F/12M | Agonist | Morphine | IV | 10 mg | high | ... | _ |
Mixed agonist | Nalbuphine | IV | 2.5, 5, 10 mg | high | ↓ | high | ||
Walker & Zacny, 1998 | 3F/9M | Agonist | Codeine | PO | 60, 120 mg | med | ... | _ |
Agonist | Morphine | PO | 20, 40 mg | med | ... | _ | ||
Zacny, Hill, Black, & Sadeghi, 1998 | 15F/2M | Agonist | Hydromorphone | IV | 0.33, 0.65, 1.3 mg | high | ↓ | high |
Agonist | Morphine | IV | 5, 10 mg | high | ... | _ | ||
Black, Hill, & Zacny, 1999 | 2F/8M | Agonist | Alfentanil | IV | 16, 32, 64 ng/ml | high | ↓ | high |
Agonist | Remifentanil | IV | Continuous infusion: 0.75, 1.5, 3 ng/ml | high | ↓ | med | ||
Walker & Zacny, 1999 | 6F/10M | Agonist | Hydromorphone | IV | Cumulative injections of: .33, .65, 1.3 mg | high | ↓ | high |
Agonist | Meperidine | IV | Cumulative injections of: 17.5, 35, 70 mg | high | ↓ | high | ||
Agonist | Morphine | IV | Cumulative injections of: 2.5, 5, 10 mg | high | ... | _ | ||
Hill & Zacny, 2000 | 5F/12M | Agonist | Hydromorphine | IV | Cumulative injections of .33, .65, 1.3 mg | high | ↓ | high |
Agonist | Morphine | IV | Cumulative injections of 5, 10 mg | high | ... | _ | ||
Marsch et al., 2001 | 18M | Agonist | Morphine | IV | Three infusion rates (2 min bolus, 15 min, and 60 min) of 5, 10 mg | high | ↓ | high |
Walker, Zacny, Galva, & Lichtor, 2001 | 5F/10M | Agonist | Morphine | IV | 2.5, 5, 10 mg | high | ↓ | high |
Mixed agonist | Butorphanol | IV | 0.5, 1, 2 mg | med | ↓ | med | ||
Mixed agonist | Nalbuphine | IV | Cumulative injections of 2.5, 5, 10 mg | high | ↓ | high | ||
Mixed agonist | Pentazocine | IV | 7.5, 15 mg | low | ... | _ | ||
Zacny & Gutierrez, 2003 | 9F/9M | Agonist | Morphine | PO | 40 mg | med | ... | _ |
Agonist | Oxycodone | PO | 10 mg, 20 mg, 30 mg | high | ↓ | high | ||
Zacny, 2003 | 9F/9M | Agonist | Hydrocodone | PO | 5 mg Hydrocodone/1.5 mg Homatropine, 10 mg Hydrocodone/3 mg Homatropine, 20 mg Hydrocodone/6 mg Homatropine | med | ↓ | med |
Agonist | Morphine | PO | 40 mg | med | ... | _ | ||
Zacny & Goldman, 2004 | 9F/9M | Agonist | Morphine | PO | 40 mg | med | ... | _ |
Agonist | Propoxyphene napsylate | PO | 50, 100, 200 mg | med | ... | _ | ||
Escher et al., 2007 | 12M | Mixed agonist | Buprenorphine | IV | 0.15 mg | med | ↓ | med |
Zacny & Gutierrez, 2008 | 8F/8M | Agonist | Hydrocodone | PO | 5 mg Hydrocodone/325 mg Acetaminophen, 10 mg Hydrocodone/650 mg Acetaminophen | med | ... | _ |
Agonist | Oxycodone | PO | 5 mg Oxycodone/325 mg Acetaminophen, 10 mg Oxycodone/650 mg Acetaminophen | med | ↓ | med | ||
Zacny & Lichtor, 2008 | 10F/10M | Agonist | Morphine | PO | 30, 60 mg | high | ↓ | high |
Agonist | Oxycodone | PO | 10, 20 mg | high | ↓ | high | ||
Cherrier, Amory, Ersek, Risler, & Shen, 2009 | 40F/31M | Agonist | Oxycodone | PO | 10 mg | med | ↓ | med |
Zacny & Gutierrez, 2009 | 10F/10M | Agonist | Hydrocodone | PO | 15 mg Hydrocodone/487 mg Acetaminophen, 30 mg Hydrocodone/975 mg Acetaminophen | high | ↓ | high |
Agonist | Oxycodone | PO | 10 mg Oxycodone/487 mg Acetaminophen, 20 mg Oxycodone/975 mg Acetaminphen | high | ↓ | med | ||
Zacny & Gutierrez, 2011 | 6F/8M | Agonist | Oxycodone | PO | 10 mg | med | ... | _ |
F = female; M = male participants. Studies used within-subject designs unless otherwise noted.
1Estimated dose for agonists based on morphine equivalent of the maximum dose of in the respective study. For antagonist drugs, the estimated dose is preceded by a minus. See caption of Figure 2 for more details.
2Arrow indicates significantly improved (↑) , impaired (↓), mixed effects (↕) or null-effects (…) on performance relative to a placebo control condition.
3Minimum estimated dose at which the indicated effect is significantly different from placebo.