Skip to main content
. 2013 Jan 31;2013(1):CD003617. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD003617.pub2
Study Reason for exclusion
Adinolfi 2003 RCT comparing different ribavirin plus interferon regimens.
Aghemo 2012 Editorial review of Lok paper from HALT‐C trial
Akham 2011 Uncontrolled trial.
Alaimo 2006 RCT comparing different ribavirin plus interferon regimens.
Alberti 1997 Meta‐analysis.
Almasio 1999 Previously included but moved because only RCTs comparing IFN to no treatment with clinical data now being considered.
Andreone 1999 RCT comparing interferon versus interferon and ribavirin regimen.
Andreone 2000 RCT comparing interferon versus interferon and ribavirin regimen.
Arase 1994 Previously included but moved because only RCTs comparing IFN to no treatment with clinical data now being considered.
Arase 2003 Previously included but moved because only RCTs comparing IFN to no treatment with clinical data now being considered.
August‐Jörg 2003 RCT comparing different ribavirin plus interferon regimens.
Azzaroli 2004 RCT comparing combination therapy to no treatment in treatment naive patients.
Bapin 2004 RCT comparing different ribavirin plus interferon regimens.
Barbaro 1998 RCT comparing interferon versus interferon and ribavirin regimen.
Barbaro 1999 RCT comparing interferon versus interferon and ribavirin regimen.
Barbaro 1999 b RCT comparing interferon versus interferon and ribavirin regimen.
Bekkering 1998 Uncontrolled study.
Bell 1999 RCT comparing interferon versus interferon and ribavirin regimen.
Bellobuono 1997 RCT comparing interferon versus interferon and ribavirin regimen.
Berg 2006 RCT comparing interferon plus ribavirin in treatment‐naive patients.
Bergmann 2007 RCT comparing different ribavirin plus interferon regimens.
Bernardinello 1999 RCT comparing beta‐interferon to no therapy.
Bonkovsky 1996 Previously included but moved because only RCTs comparing IFN to no treatment with clinical data now being considered.
Bresci 2000 RCT comparing interferon versus interferon and ribavirin regimen.
Bresci 2000b RCT comparing interferon versus interferon and ribavirin regimen.
Brillanti 1994 RCT comparing interferon versus interferon and ribavirin regimen.
Brillanti 1995 RCT comparing interferon versus interferon and ribavirin regimen.
Buti 2000 RCT comparing different ribavirin plus interferon regimens.
Böcher 2006 RCT comparing different ribavirin plus interferon regimen.
Cagnoni 1999 Uncontrolled study.
Carr 2007 Two RCTs comparing different ribavirin plus interferon regimens.
Carrara 1998 Uncontrolled study.
Cavalletto 2000 RCT comparing interferon versus interferon and ribavirin regimen.
Chapman 2001 RCT comparing interferon versus interferon and ribavirin regimen.
Chemello 1997 Previously included but moved because only RCTs comparing IFN to no treatment with clinical data now being considered.
Chousterman 2003 RCT comparing different ribavirin plus interferon regimen.
COPILOT 2008 COPILOT RCT; however, control group received colchicine, not no therapy or placebo
Cornberg 2006 RCT comparing different ribavirin plus interferon regimens.
Cotler 1997 Observational study.
Cuccorese 2000 Uncontrolled study.
Davis 1998 RCT comparing interferon versus interferon and ribavirin regimen.
Davis 1999 Selected subpopulation of patients randomized (only complete and partial responders to a repeat course of interferon were randomized; nonresponders were not randomized).
Di Biceglie 2000 RCT comparing interferon plus iron reduction versus interferon.
Di Bisceglie 2001 RCT comparing different ribavirin plus interferon regimens.
Di Marco 2000 RCT comparing different ribavirin plus interferon regimens.
Diago 2007 RCT comparing different ribavirin plus interferon regimens.
Dollinger 2005 RCT comparing different ribavirin plus interferon regimens.
Enriquez 2000 RCT comparing different ribavirin plus interferon regimens.
Erdem 2002 RCT comparing different ribavirin plus interferon regimens.
Fargion 2006 RCT comparing different ribavirin and amantadine plus interferon regimens.
Fartoux 2007 RCT comparing IFN to no treatment, but not all patients were being retreated and unable to obtain information regarding data just for retreated ones.
Fattovich 2003 RCT comparing different ribavirin plus interferon regimens.
Ferenci 1996 Previously included but moved because only RCTs comparing IFN to no treatment with clinical data now being considered.
Fong 2000 Insufficient data for inclusion. The dose and duration of previous interferon therapy is not described. Also, only 12‐week response rates are reported, but no end of treatment (48‐week) data are available.
Fontagnes 2007 Non‐randomized trial.
Gaeta 1997 Previously included but moved because only RCTs comparing IFN to no treatment with clinical data now being considered.
Gerken 1995 Uncontrolled study.
Getachew 2004 RCT comparing different ribavirin plus interferon regimens.
Giudici‐Cipriani 1993 Non‐randomized study.
Gross 1999 Previously included but moved because only RCTs comparing IFN to no treatment with clinical data now being considered.
Guerret 1999 Observational study.
Hadziyannis 1997 Insufficient data for inclusion. The dose and duration of previous interferon therapy are not described, nor is the number of patients in each intervention group.
Hasan 2001 Uncontrolled study.
Hass 2005 Uncontrolled study.
Heathcote 1998 Previously included but moved because only RCTs comparing IFN to no treatment with clinical data now being considered.
Horiike 1994 Non‐randomized study.
Iino 2002 RCT including both naive patients and patients who had previously received interferon.
Ikeda 1998 Not all patients were being retreated and unable to obtain information regarding data just for retreated ones.
Ikeda 2000 RCT including both naive and relapsers.
Imai 1997 Randomized trial of treatment‐naive patients only.
Iyoda 2000 Uncontrolled study.
Jensen 2009 Randomized trial comparing different regimens of peginterferon.
Kakumu 1994 Non‐randomized study.
Katayama 2001 Uncontrolled study.
Kishihara 1995 Non‐randomized trial.
Kumar 2001 RCT comparing different ribavirin plus interferon regimens.
Le 1996 Uncontrolled study.
Leroy 2001 RCT comparing different ribavirin plus interferon regimens.
Lindsay 1996 Previously included but moved because only RCTs comparing IFN to no treatment with clinical data now being considered.
Lodato 2005 RCT comparing different ribavirin plus interferon regimens.
Mangia 2005 RCT comparing different ribavirin and amantadine plus interferon regimens.
Mangia 2008 Trial compared interferon plus ribavirin.
Marcellin 1994 Uncontrolled study.
Marco 2000 RCT comparing different ribavirin plus interferon regimens.
Marriott 1992 Uncontrolled study.
Mathew 2006 RCT comparing different ribavirin plus interferon regimens.
Milella 1999 RCT comparing interferon versus interferon and ribavirin regimen.
Min 2001 RCT comparing different ribavirin plus interferon regimens.
Moreno‐Otero 2003 RCT comparing different ribavirin plus interferon regimens.
Mura 1999 RCT comparing interferon to no treatment, but not stated if patients treatment‐naive or previously treated or both; communication with Dr. Realdi indicated that records were not available so information could not be retrieved.
Neuman Manuela 2010 Different does of peg‐interferon compared; no untreated control group.
Nevens 2005 RCT comparing different ribavirin plus interferon regimens.
Nishiguchi 1995 Probably non‐randomized trial, did not necessarily include previously treated patients only, and subgroups could not be differentiated.
Nomura 2004 Previously included but moved because only RCTs comparing IFN to no treatment with clinical data now being considered.
Pardo 1994 Uncontrolled study.
Payen 1998 Previously included but moved because only RCTs comparing IFN to no treatment with clinical data now being considered.
Perasso 1999 Uncontrolled study.
Picciotto 1997 Non‐randomized study.
Planas 2002 Prior treatment was reason for exclusion
Pockros 2007 RCT of gamma‐interferon.
Pol 1999 RCT comparing interferon versus interferon and ribavirin regimen.
Portal 2003 RCT comparing different ribavirin plus interferon regimens.
Poynard 1999 Previously included but moved because only RCTs comparing IFN to no treatment with clinical data now being considered.
Poynard 2003 RCT comparing different ribavirin plus interferon regimens.
Puoti 2001 RCT comparing different ribavirin plus interferon regimens.
Qu 2012 Meta‐analysis of trials comparing interferon to no therapy and describing HCC outcome; not all trials in this meta‐analysis included retreated patients and one of the trials was probably not even randomized.
Reichard 1994 Observational study.
Rodriguez‐Torres 2011 Trial compares interferon lambda to interferon alfa in treatment naive individuals.
Rolachon 1997 Previously included but moved because only RCTs comparing IFN to no treatment with clinical data now being considered.
Romero‐Gomez 2012 Meta‐analysis of trials comparing interferon alfa2a to alfa2b; unclear if patients treatment naive or previously treated.
Rustgi 2005 RCT comparing different ribavirin plus interferon regimens.
Salmeron 1999 RCT comparing interferon versus interferon and ribavirin regimen.
Saracco 1994 Uncontrolled study.
Saracco 2001 RCT comparing different ribavirin plus interferon regimens.
Saracco 2002 RCT comparing different ribavirin plus interferon regimens.
Sarrazin 2007 RCT comparing different SCH 503034 plus interferon regimen.
Scotto 1996 RCT comparing interferon versus interferon and ribavirin regimen.
Scotto 1998 Previously included but moved because only RCTs comparing IFN to no treatment with clinical data now being considered.
Shiffman 2000 RCT comparing different ribavirin plus interferon regimens.
Singal 2010 Meta‐analysis.
Soza 2005 Trial of gamma interferon.
Sporea 2006 Quasi‐randomized trial comparing different ribavirin plus interferon regimens.
Steindl‐Munda 2003 RCT comparing different ribavirin plus interferon regimens.
Suzuki 2001 RCT including naive patients and patients who had received interferon previously.
Tassopoulos 2003 RCT comparing different ribavirin plus interferon regimens.
Toyota 2002 RCT comparing interferon versus interferon and ribavirin regimen.
Valla 1999 Randomized trial comparing interferon to no interferon, but unclear if patients previously treated or not; further information requested from Dr. Valla via email (dominique.valla@bjn.ap‐hop‐paris.fr) on 4/22/12. Received response on April 24, 2012 indicating that all of the patients in the trial were treatment‐naive, so trial excluded.
Wartelle 1997 Insufficient data for inclusion. The dose and duration of previous interferon therapy are not described.
Weiland 1993 Uncontrolled study.
Yao 1997 RCT comparing consensus interferon to alfa‐interferon; unclear if patients were previously treated or not.
Zeuzem 2000 Trial compared different regimens of interferon; no untreated control group.
Zeuzem 2005 RCT comparing different ribavirin plus interferon regimens.

RCT = randomized controlled trial.