1. Exposure and outcome in simulation studies.
Study ID | Exposure | Outcome | |||||||
Agent | Name | Solution | Amount | Additions | Expo method | Detection | Photographs | Measure | |
Bell 2015 | fluorescent | Glogerm, Tide, Bright Dyes Orange Dye | water | 100 mL | oatmeal, chocolate powder, crushed cereal | 100 mL splashed on the front torso of their garment | UV LED black light, chauvet | yes | contaminated yes/no |
Gleser 2019 | fluorescent | Schulke | ? | 5 mL | no | distributed equally on the gloves | UV box | no | hand contamination (yes/no) |
Guo 2014 | fluorescent | Glogerm | oil and water | ? | no | sprayed 3.8 g of the lotion onto the upper body of the subject at a distance of 60 cm from the subject | UV scan | no | number of stains |
Hall 2018 | fluorescent | VIOLET‐tool | water, glycerol | 800 mL (blue UV) | flour, salt | manikin vomited, produced diarrhoea, sweat and cough | UV‐A strip lights | yes | yes/no and location (n = 12) |
Mana 2018 | fluorescent | ? | ? | 0.5 mL | no | rubbed over gloved hands; then contaminated front of the gown | Ultra light UV1 | no | any contamination yes/no |
Strauch 2016 | fluorescent | Glogerm | oil | 25 mL | no | 1.brushed on masks 2. 1 mL on the hands | UV‐A light | yes | contaminated yes/no; intensity of UV light reflection |
Tomas 2016 | fluorescent | ? | ? | 0.5 mL | no | rubbed over gloved hands | Ultra light UV1 | no | contaminated hands/wrist yes/no |
Wong 2004 | fluorescent | ? | water | 100 mL | no | sprayed the exposed part with an atomiser (subjects were blindfolded during this process) | UV scan | yes | number of stains |
Zamora 2006 | fluorescent | Detection Paste | ? | 100 mL | no | paste on forearms and palms of the hands | UV lamp | no | areas measured |
Buianov 2004 | microbes | ? | 10^8 CFU/m3 | ? | ? | ? | ? | ? | ? |
Casanova 2012 | virus | MS2 | 10^5 PFU /5 muL | 25 muL | ? | shoulder, respirator, eye protection, hand 5 drops of 5 muL | swabs of face and hands; extraction gloves, scrubs | na | any contamination yes/no; mean Log10 PFU recovered |
Casanova 2016 | virus | MS2, Phi6 | 10^8 MS2, 10^7 Phi6 / 5 muL | 25 muL | ? | hand, shoulder, face‐shield, boot | swabs of face and hands; extraction gloves, scrubs | na | any contamination yes/no |
Mana 2018 | virus | Phi X174 | 10^8 PFU/0.5 mL | 0.5 mL | ? | rubbed over de gloved hands for 10 sec | swabs of hands and wrist; swabs of neck and chest | na | any contamination yes/no; mean Log10 PFU recovered |
Tomas 2016 | virus | MS2 | 10^10 PFU /0.5 mL | 0.5 mL | ? | gloved hands were inoculated | swabs of hands and wrist | na | contaminated hands/wrist yes/no; mean log10 PFU recovered |
na = not applicable
MS2 = harmless virus
Phi6 = harmless virus
CFU/PFU = colony forming units/ plaque forming units
muL = microliter
mL = milliliter