Skip to main content
. 2019 Jul 1;2019(7):CD011621. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD011621.pub3

1. Exposure and outcome in simulation studies.

Study ID Exposure Outcome
  Agent Name Solution Amount Additions Expo method Detection Photographs Measure
Bell 2015 fluorescent Glogerm, Tide, Bright Dyes Orange Dye water 100 mL oatmeal, chocolate powder, crushed cereal 100 mL splashed on the front torso of their garment UV LED black light, chauvet yes contaminated yes/no
Gleser 2019 fluorescent Schulke ? 5 mL no distributed equally on the gloves UV box no hand contamination (yes/no)
Guo 2014 fluorescent Glogerm oil and water ? no sprayed 3.8 g of the lotion onto the upper body of the subject at a distance of 60 cm from the subject UV scan no number of stains
Hall 2018 fluorescent VIOLET‐tool water, glycerol 800 mL (blue UV) flour, salt manikin vomited, produced diarrhoea, sweat and cough UV‐A strip lights yes yes/no and location (n = 12)
Mana 2018 fluorescent ? ? 0.5 mL no rubbed over gloved hands; then contaminated front of the gown Ultra light UV1 no any contamination yes/no
Strauch 2016 fluorescent Glogerm oil 25 mL no 1.brushed on masks 2. 1 mL on the hands UV‐A light yes contaminated yes/no; intensity of UV light reflection
Tomas 2016 fluorescent ? ? 0.5 mL no rubbed over gloved hands Ultra light UV1 no contaminated hands/wrist yes/no
Wong 2004 fluorescent ? water 100 mL no sprayed the exposed part with an atomiser (subjects were blindfolded during this process) UV scan yes number of stains
Zamora 2006 fluorescent Detection Paste ? 100 mL no paste on forearms and palms of the hands UV lamp no areas measured
Buianov 2004 microbes ? 10^8 CFU/m3 ? ? ? ? ? ?
Casanova 2012 virus MS2 10^5 PFU /5 muL 25 muL ? shoulder, respirator, eye protection, hand 5 drops of 5 muL swabs of face and hands; extraction gloves, scrubs na any contamination yes/no; mean Log10 PFU recovered
Casanova 2016 virus MS2, Phi6 10^8 MS2, 10^7 Phi6 / 5 muL 25 muL ? hand, shoulder, face‐shield, boot swabs of face and hands; extraction gloves, scrubs na any contamination yes/no
Mana 2018 virus Phi X174 10^8 PFU/0.5 mL 0.5 mL ? rubbed over de gloved hands for 10 sec swabs of hands and wrist; swabs of neck and chest na any contamination yes/no; mean Log10 PFU recovered
Tomas 2016 virus MS2 10^10 PFU /0.5 mL 0.5 mL ? gloved hands were inoculated swabs of hands and wrist na contaminated hands/wrist yes/no; mean log10 PFU recovered

na = not applicable

MS2 = harmless virus

Phi6 = harmless virus

CFU/PFU = colony forming units/ plaque forming units

muL = microliter

mL = milliliter