Abrahamson 2006 |
Uncontrolled study; one type of training only |
Alraddadi 2016 |
No comparision group |
Beam 2011 |
No control group with an active intervention |
Beam 2014 |
Uncontrolled study; only one type of training in donning and doffing studied with video recordings |
Beam 2016 |
Not an empirical study |
Beam 2016a |
Not an empirical study |
Bearman 2007 |
Trial of universal gloving, not as part of full body PPE |
Belkin 1991 |
Commentary, not a primary study |
Belkin 2000 |
Commentary, not a primary study |
Belkin 2005 |
Description of standards and tests not a primary study |
Biddell 2016 |
Not an empirical study |
Borchert 2007 |
Description of use of PPE in MHF outbreak, not a case control or cohort study |
Bosc 2016 |
Wrong comparator |
Buianov 1991 |
Study compares two types of PPE for highly infectious diseases but does not measure contamination or infection as outcome, only physiological parameters (native speaker assessment AP) |
Bunyan 2013 |
Review not primary study |
Butt 2016 |
Wrong comparator |
Casanova 2008 |
Not a comparative study; only studied one method of doffing |
Castle 2009 |
Outcome only performance with PPE and not infection rate or adherence |
Christian 2004 |
Investigation of cluster of SARS infected HCW; not a case control or cohort study |
Chu 2017 |
Not an empirical study |
Chughtai 2013 |
Overview focusing on mask use only, not part of full body PPE |
Clay 2015 |
Simulation study; military HCWs; no control group |
Coates 2000 |
Outcome performance only not infection rates or adherence |
Coca 2015 |
Wrong type of participants, thermal manikin study |
Colebunders 2004 |
Description of MHF outbreak; not a case control or cohort study |
Cooper 2005 |
Simulation study, but of facial protection only, no full‐body ppe involved |
Delaney 2016 |
No comparision group |
Doll 2017 |
No comparision group |
Doshi 2016 |
No comparision group |
Drew 2016 |
No comparision group |
Dunn 2015 |
Case study of spread of infection in one hospital; used in discussion section |
Elcin 2016 |
No comparision group |
Fischer 2015 |
Not a primary study, literature review |
Fogel 2017 |
Wrong study design |
Foote 2017 |
Wrong intervention |
Franklin 2016 |
Not an emperical study |
Gozel 2013 |
Description of use of PPE among HCW exposed to CCHF; not case‐control or cohort study |
Grélot 2015 |
Measurement of thermal strain, no infection or contamination or compliance measured |
Grélot 2016 |
Measurement of thermal strain, no infection or contamination or compliance measured |
Hendler 2000 |
PPE versus no PPE; outcome performance only |
Herlihey 2016 |
No comparision group |
Herlihey 2017 |
No comparision group |
Hersi 2015 |
Not a primary study, rapid review |
Hildwine 2006 |
Annoucement of breathable virus resistant fabric; not a primary study |
Ho 2003 |
Descriptive study of SARS outbreak and HCWs use of PPE; not a case‐control or cohort study |
Ho 2004 |
Compares consistent versus inconsistent use of PPE, not two different types |
Hon 2008 |
Evaluation of on‐line PPE training; uncontrolled study, no comparison training |
Hormbrey 1996 |
Description of introduction of new clothing; no infection or adherence outcome |
Jaques 2016 |
Report contains no data |
Jeffs 2007 |
Description of control of MHF outbreak; not a case control or cohort study |
Jinadatha 2015 |
Wrong type of participants, investigation of disinfection on different PPE fabrics and components |
Kang 2017 |
Wrong study design |
Kang 2017a |
No comparision group |
Keane 1977 |
Description of risk of HCW only; no evaluation of PPE safety |
Kerstiens 1999 |
Desription of Ebola outbreak; not case control or cohort study |
Kilinc‐Balci 2016 |
Not an emperical study |
Kilinc‐Balci 2015 |
Report contains no data |
Kim 2015 |
No control group, HCWs infected with MERS CoV |
Ko 2004 |
Description of risk of EMT staff; no evaluation of PPE safety |
Kratz 2017 |
Report contains no data |
Kwon 2017 |
No comparision group |
Lai 2005 |
Study of SARS IgG prevalence in HCWs who did not become sick, no PPE use measured |
Lai 2011 |
Simulation study of glove removal, no full‐body PPE tested. |
Lange 2005 |
Letter to the editor; not primary study |
Lau 2004 |
Compares consistent versus inconsistent use of PPE, not two different types |
Le 2004 |
Compares consistent versus inconsistent use of PPE, not two different types |
Lee 2017 |
Report contains no data |
Lindsley 2012 |
Test respiratory protection only; not part of full‐body PPE |
Lindsley 2014 |
Tests respiratory protection only; not part of full‐body PPE |
Liu 2009 |
Compares consistent versus inconsistent use of PPE, not two different types |
Loeb 2004 |
Compares consistent versus inconsistent use of PPE, not two different types |
Low 2005 |
A review of SARS and HCW; not a primary study |
Lowe 2014 |
Description of PPE use only; no adherence or infection outcomes |
Lu 2006 |
Comparison of viral load in patients infected outside and inside hospital; comparison is with no PPE |
Luo 2011 |
Simulation study of one Tyvek® (duPont) suit only, no comparison suit or no comparison doffing method |
Ma 2004 |
Retrospective case‐control study about PPE for SARS, compares consistent versus inconsistent use not two types |
Malik 2006 |
Participants not exposed to highly infectious diseases |
Marklund 2002 |
Description of Ebola patient transportation; not an intervention study |
Matanock 2014 |
Description of risk of infection of HCW compared to general population; no evaluation of PPE |
McLaws 2016 |
Not an emperical study |
Mehtar 2015 |
No control group, two IPC training courses |
Minnich 2003 |
Description of ambulance adaptation for transport of highly infected patients; not evaluation or intervention study |
Mollura 2015 |
Review; EVD within radiology wards and on imaging equipment |
Moore 2005 |
Review not intervention study |
Morgan 2009 |
Review of adverse effects of contact precautions |
Mumma 2018 |
No comparision group |
Muyembe‐Tamfum 1999 |
Description of Ebola outbreak; not case‐control or cohort study |
Nikiforuk 2017 |
wrong patient population |
Nishiura 2005 |
Compares consistent versus inconsistent use of PPE, not two different types |
Northington 2007 |
No comparison group; only one type of education with follow‐up |
Nyenswah 2015 |
Case study of EVD cluster including HCWs, but insufficient information on PPE to draw any conclusions |
Ofner 2003 |
SARS case series only; no healthy controls; not case control or cohort study |
Ofner‐Agostini 2006 |
SARS case series only; no healthy controls; not case control or cohort study |
Ogendo 2008 |
Eye protection only; not part of full‐body PPE |
Ong 2013 |
No exposure to highly infectious diseases |
Park 2004 |
Compares consistent versus inconsistent use of PPE, not two different types |
Pei 2006 |
Compares consistent versus inconsistent use of PPE, not two different types |
Phan 2018 |
Wrong intervention |
Phrampus 2016 |
No comparison group |
Quinn 2018 |
Wrong outcomes |
Ragazzoni 2015 |
No control group, virtual reality simulation training study |
Ransjo 1979 |
No exposure to highly infectious diseases |
Reynolds 2006 |
Case control study evaluating SARS risk in HCWs in Vietnam but no inclusion of PPE use |
Rosenberg 2016 |
Report of another article already included |
Russell 2015 |
No control group, no outcome, before/after summary card |
Scales 2003 |
Compares consistent versus inconsistent use of PPE, not two different types |
Schumacher 2010 |
Comparison is no PPE; outcome is performance time only |
Scott Taylor 2017 |
Wrong outcomes |
Seto 2003 |
Compares consistent versus inconsistent use of PPE, not two different types |
Shao 2015 |
Not a primary study, Chinese review |
Sorensen 2008 |
No exposure to highly infectious diseases |
Su 2017 |
No comparision group |
Tartari 2015 |
No control group, infection control readiness checklist (from 45 countries), no outcome |
Teleman 2004 |
Compares consistent versus inconsistent use of PPE, not two different types |
Tomas 2015 |
No comparison used only description of contamination in a simulation study. |
Tomas 2016a |
Wrong intervention |
Torres 2015 |
Not a primary study, literature review |
West 2014 |
Not a primary study but a commentary |
Xi 2016 |
No comparision group |
Yin 2004 |
Case‐control study of use of PPE for SARS, not comparing two different types of PPE |
Zellmer 2015 |
No control group, checklist for removing PPE |
Zhou 2003 |
Follow‐up of HCWs exposed to SARS and their PPE and protection measures, not comparative study |