Skip to main content
. 2019 Apr-Jun;13(2):187–195. doi: 10.1590/1980-57642018dn13-020007

Table 2. Summary of cognitive test results comparing pre and post-intervention for each group, derived from repeated measures GEE.

Test Group Pre-intervention   Post-intervention Ptime Pgroup Pgroup time
Mean Standard error Mean Standard error
CAMCOG
Executive functioning SHAM 113.55 1487   116 1.271 0.709 0.001 0.047
Active 111.17 2130   115.31 2.334      
Constructional praxis SHAM 2.28 0.137   2.69 0.139 0.146 0.609 0.037
Active 2.43 0.132   2.36 0.145      
Total language SHAM 27.45 0.27   27.28 0.344 0.374 0.963 0.116
Active 27.03 0.401   27.66 0.332      
Motor response SHAM 3.86 0.064   3.86 0.064 0.315 0.632 0.315
Active 3.83 0.098   3.97 0.034      
Verbal answer SHAM 2.93 0.047   3 0.049 0.763 0.698 0.362
Active 2.97 0.059   2.93 0.047      
Reading SHAM 2 0   2.03 0.034 0.980 0.096 0.150
Active 1.97 0.034   1.93 0.047      
Settings SHAM 5.62 0.133   5.66 0.132 0.130 0.733 0.215
Active 5.41 0.192   5.76 0.093      
Picture naming SHAM 7.86 0.08   7.76 0.18 0.527 0.519 0.750
Active 7.9 0.057   7.86 0.064      
Verbal fluency SHAM 4.17 0.162   3.9 0.171 0.772 0.876 0.049
Active 3.97 0.192   4.17 0.201      
Memory SHAM 20.59 0.456   21.48 0.432 0.006 0.731 0.766
Active 20.24 0.666   21.34 0.655      
Memory recall SHAM 4 0.213   3.32 0.202 0.303 0.361 0.004
Active 3.28 0.228   3.58 0.186      
Memory recognition SHAM 5.21 0.165   5.41 0.134 0.409 0.394 0.560
Active 5.14 0.181   5.17 0.169      
Remote Memory SHAM 4.31 0.213   4.83 0.176 0.003 0.434 0.345
Active 4.62 0.198   4.9 0.209      
Recent memory SHAM 3.69 0.139   3.79 0.113 0.752 0.151 0.253
Active 3.62 0.124   3.45 0.151      
Fixing address SHAM 3.61 0.234   4.28 0.145 <0.001 0.696 0.881
Active 3.72 0.219   4.34 0.164      
Heads up SHAM 6.17 0.234   6 0.218 0.918 0.621 0.321
Active 5.83 0.32   6.03 0.251      
Calculation SHAM 1.85 0.067   1.83 0.07 0.478 0.939 0.300
Active 1.79 0.075   1.9 0.077      
Praxis SHAM 10.79 0.185   11.14 0.193 0.125 0.157 0.626
Active 10.52 0.252   10.69 0.224      
Ideational praxis SHAM 3.76 0.093   3.76 0.079 0.810 0.584 0.810
Active 3.83 0.07   3.79 0.09      
Constructional praxis SHAM 2.28 0.137   2.69 0.139 0.146 0.609 0.037
Active 2.43 0.132   2.36 0.145      
Ideomotor praxis SHAM 4.76 0.079   4.69 0.11 0.694 0.089 0.269
Active 4.41 0.158   4.55 0.115      
Tactile perception SHAM 2 0   1.97 0.034 0.565 0.556 0.565
Active 1.97 0.034   1.97 0.034      
Visual sense SHAM 7.52 0.143   6.93 0.188 <0.001 0.812 0.908
Active 7.59 0.15   6.97 0.21      
Abstract thinking SHAM 6.1 0.317   6.38 0.332 0.011 0.691 0.156
Active 5.63 0.301   6.59 0.303      
Time orientation SHAM 4.72 0.096   4.86 0.064 0.994 0.510 0.112
Active 4.79 0.075   4.66 0.132      
Spatial orientation SHAM 4.83 0.07   4.9 0.057 0.701 0.905 0.08
Active 4.9 0.057   4.93 0.047      
Total SHAM 113.55 1.487   116 1,271 <0.001 0.536 0.295
Active 111.17 2.130   115.31 2,334      
Final SHAM 93.93 0.979   95.83 0.686 0.001 0.579 0.742
Active 92.83 1.447   95.14 1,602      
Trail Making Test
Version A – time SHAM 0.5697 0.06614   0.6462 0.08633 0.631 0.104 0.09
Active 0.8269 0.11021   0.7707 0.09325      
Version A – errors SHAM 1.13 0.117   1.12 0.122 0.780 0.623 0.765
Active 1.25 0.23   1.29 0.352      
Version B – time SHAM 24.872 0.29003   24,503 0.3288 0.874 0.962 0.929
Active 24.559 0.25994   24,455 0.25501      
Version B – errors SHAM 3 0.403   2.49 0.889 0.497 0.665 0.610
Active 3 1,156   1.84 0.563      
Word List Memory Task
WLMT-A1 SHAM 4.9 0.241   5.05 0.298 0.503 0.404 0.694
Active 4.69 0.244   4.86 0.307      
WLMT-A2 SHAM 6.24 0.222   6.52 0.279 0.061 0.724 0.310
Active 6.1 0.29   6.17 0.289      
WLMT-A3 SHAM 6.79 0.282   7.17 0.285 0.263 0.838 0.524
Active 6.86 0.242   6.97 0.295      
WLMT-recall SHAM 5.85 0.302   5.14 0.361 0.987 0.694 0.007
Active 4.97 0.351   5.66 0.451      
WLMT-recall test: intrusions SHAM 1.28 0.171   1.22 0.139 0.941 0.205 0.851
Active 1.57 0.396   1.6 0.357      
WLMT-recognition test SHAM 9.1 0.171   8.93 0.212 0.412 0.615 0.995
Active 8.97 0.21   8.79 0.343      
WLMT-recognition
test – intrusions
SHAM 1.28 0.176   0.96 0.103 0.395 0.021 0.091
Active 1.65 0.284   1.81 0.363      
WLMT-total SHAM 17.93 0.589   18.59 0.697 0.373 0.593 0.789
Active 17.66 0.66   18 0.801      
Other tests
Semantic Verbal Fluency test
(Animal word version)
SHAM 17.31 0.867   16.86 0.903 0.81 0.874 0.268
Active 16.55 0.972   17.24 0.971      
Mini-Mental State
Examination test
SHAM 27.31 0.369   27.31 0.297 0.751 0.578 0.751
Active 26.93 0.5   27.14 0.48      
Boston Naming test SHAM 13.31 0.342   13.48 0.34 0.179 0.682 0.816
Active 13.1 0.31   13.34 0.273      
Hamilton Depression
Rating Scale
SHAM 8.66 1.003   6.74 0.712 0.033 0.117 0.459
Active 10.31 1.394   9.13 1,259      
Clock Drawing Test SHAM 8.759 0.2881   9,241 0.1883 0.012 0.401 0.743
Active 8.345 0.4059   8,948 0.3957      
N-back SHAM 508 0   508 0 0.312 0.312 0.312
Active 500.48 7.386   508 0      
WAIS III - Code SHAM 39.07 3.225   38.93 3.276 0.7 0.613 0.77
Active 41.76 3.525   40.69 3.129      
WAIS III – Digit span DO SHAM 7.38 0.403   7.45 0.435 0.785 0.734 0.959
Active 7.52 0.337   7.62 0.385      
WAIS III – Digit span IO SHAM 4.17 0.201   3.79 0.277 0.184 0.45 0.595
Active 4.31 0.316   4.14 0.283