Table II.
Model | k | Hedges’ g | 95% CI |
Qmoderators | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Lower | Upper | ||||
Treatment Approach | |||||
Intercept (Non-CBT treatments) | 31 | .12 | −.07 | .32 | .04 |
CBT versus Non-CBT Treatments | −.02 | −.24 | .20 | ||
Client age | |||||
Intercept (Youth clients) | 35 | .02 | −.12 | .15 | 2.58 |
Adult versus youth clients | .13 | −.03 | .28 | ||
Client diagnostic category | |||||
Intercept (Mixed internalizing) | 35 | .21*** | .11 | .30 | 8.79* |
Primary anxiety versus mixed internalizing | −.18** | −.30 | −.05 | ||
Primary depression versus mixed internalizing | .00 | −.19 | .19 | ||
Comorbidity | |||||
Intercept (No comorbidity allowed/unknown) | 35 | .08 | −.03 | .20 | .34 |
Comorbidity allowed versus not allowed/unknown | .05 | −.11 | .20 | ||
Supervision | |||||
Intercept (Less supervision) | 33 | .18*** | .10 | .27 | 6.50* |
Equal supervision versus more supervision for less experienced therapists | −.16* | −.28 | −.04 | ||
Randomization | |||||
Intercept (Randomization of clients) | 28 | .24*** | .14 | .34 | 8.19** |
No randomization of clients versus randomization of clients | −.18** | −.30 | −.06 | ||
Treatment manualization | |||||
Intercept (No manualization) | 35 | .19*** | .10 | .29 | 4.71* |
Treatment manualization versus no manualization | −.14* | −.27 | −.01 | ||
Definition of therapist experience | |||||
Intercept (Specific definitions) | 35 | .14* | .01 | .27 | .34 |
Broad definitions versus specific definitions | −.05 | −.21 | .11 | ||
Study year | |||||
Intercept | 33 | −4.08 | −20.15 | 11.99 | .26 |
Moderator | .002 | −.006 | .01 |
Note: CBT: cognitive-behavioral therapy.
p <.05.
p <.01.
p < .001.