Skip to main content
. 2019 Jun 1;19(11):2515. doi: 10.3390/s19112515

Table 8.

Detailed results of BOA, FA, PSO, HEHO, and dynsTGA proposed localization—results for BOA, FA, and PSO were taken from [15] (NL = number of localized nodes, EL = localization error, TE = execution time in seconds).

Target Node Anchor Node Trial BOA FA PSO HEHO dynsTGA
NL EL TE NL EL TE NL EL TE NL EL TE NL EL TE
25 10 1 23 0.207908 0.40 19 0.335551 1.44 22 0.807158 0.36 21 0.305502 1.15 25 0.195331 1.36
2 24 0.188224 0.33 20 0.246423 1.44 17 0.728214 0.39 22 0.278037 0.98 23 0.168431 1.22
3 25 0.224510 0.38 21 0.296398 1.70 18 0.797650 0.40 21 0.246762 1.03 25 0.177892 1.39
4 25 0.19963 0.38 20 0.256168 1.65 17 0.739102 0.39 20 0.239952 1.16 24 0.209644 1.16
5 24 0.212247 0.31 19 0.278459 1.57 19 0.799164 0.36 19 0.257405 0.99 25 0.195799 1.41
50 15 1 46 0.235326 0.77 50 0.505511 2.50 48 0.578797 0.74 49 0.395029 1.73 47 0.275583 1.96
2 49 0.260490 0.81 49 0.326980 4.42 50 0.753254 0.85 50 0.365282 1.85 46 0.219592 2.13
3 48 0.361080 0.92 49 0.254824 1.63 47 0.587004 0.75 46 0.449252 1.59 50 0.259765 1.86
4 50 0.323910 0.86 48 0.227842 3.90 46 0.438748 0.76 49 0.269440 1.93 47 0.230059 2.06
5 49 0.351415 0.91 49 0.2476413 4.19 47 0.486784 0.85 50 0.424532 1.66 48 0.295904 2.16
75 20 1 75 0.328310 1.68 74 0.703964 2.97 75 0.67414 1.31 72 0.350875 2.20 73 0.199861 2.62
2 75 0.219680 1.52 75 0.291862 2.73 75 0.720123 1.35 74 0.280843 2.73 75 0.180029 2.99
3 68 0.178960 1.52 72 0.279126 5.84 73 0.771325 1.30 75 0.273232 2.16 75 0.219865 2.70
4 75 0.183942 1.43 71 0.284865 4.70 72 0.798457 1.32 71 0.405024 2.66 72 0.299400 2.56
5 73 0.196781 1.69 73 0.2907846 3.97 73 0.697814 1.31 74 0.301557 2.27 72 0.160293 2.51
100 25 1 100 0.218838 2.29 100 0.779716 5.66 100 0.668227 2.49 100 0.414563 3.03 100 0.225200 3.61
2 100 0.295008 2.27 100 0.299194 6.33 100 0.614843 2.10 99 0.295402 3.52 100 0.260502 3.15
3 100 0.216414 2.32 100 0.385758 3.55 100 0.608155 2.20 99 0.289436 3.89 100 0.194039 4.11
4 100 0.235804 2.37 100 0.589494 4.56 100 0.627197 2.35 99 0.500929 3.16 100 0.246309 3.62
5 100 0.259312 2.45 100 0.513591 4.93 100 0.653258 2.16 100 0.305521 3.44 100 0.205582 4.01
125 30 1 124 0.615712 3.12 122 0.938894 2.707 119 0.600957 3.90 122 0.605331 5.05 125 0.445044 4.82
2 123 0.437651 3.65 123 0.651459 5.995 123 0.662322 3.87 125 0.633079 4.24 125 0.575166 4.95
3 125 0.568754 4.26 123 0.831683 2.709 125 0.593421 4.90 124 0.999975 5.13 124 0.398802 5.75
4 124 0.657499 3.76 125 0.950842 3.11 125 0.608412 3.98 123 0.675226 4.29 125 0.609182 4.52
5 125 0.545789 3.87 125 0.912666 5.894 125 0.744193 4.90 125 0.660022 4.95 124 0.399805 5.55
150 35 1 150 0.743780 5.67 149 0.957818 3.386 149 0.657679 5.03 150 0.655520 6.85 149 0.621203 7.43
2 150 0.887561 4.87 150 0.973891 3.459 149 0.773764 5.16 150 0.893529 5.75 150 0.825276 6.06
3 150 0.765347 5.65 150 0.854096 5.894 150 0.620403 4.22 149 0.698736 6.71 150 0.815900 6.23
4 149 0.665348 4.12 150 0.672451 4.87 150 0.766621 5.21 150 0.851012 5.69 149 0.599972 7.33
5 150 0.787689 4.76 120 0.632727 3.356 150 0.625278 4.43 149 0.889902 6.66 150 0.872217 6.77