Skip to main content
. 2019 Jul 1;85(14):e00324-19. doi: 10.1128/AEM.00324-19

TABLE 2.

Advanced analytical techniques used to determine the physicochemical characteristics of aggregatesa

Method Sample size Resolution Limitations Information collected Reference(s)
SANS 150-μm-thick sections 1 nm to 0.8 μm Technique relies on the contrasting agent (D2O/H2O), diffusion of contrasting agent to estimate pore connectivity, requires a long time to collect data, and pore geometry is assumed for when analyzing natural samples Particle size distribution, pore vol, surface roughness, surface area, and interconnected porosity 143
USANS 150-μm-thick sections 60 nm to 20 μm
FIB-T 10 μm3 10 nm to 0.1 μm Small sample volume used in analysis, and the technique is destructive, which limits reproducibility Pore vol, porosity, pore size statistics, and connected and unconnected pore network; also, data can be correlated to elemental composition using EDS 144, 145
ET 100-nm needle <1 nm to 0.05 μm Small sample volume, fixed-needle geometry, and technique relies on image analysis and 3D reconstruction Pore geometry and connectivity; pore data can be cross-correlated with elemental composition using EDS 146
BSEM Thin sections 100 nm to ∼500 μm 2D analysis of a 3D geometry requires sample prep, and technique relies on image analysis to distinguish intra- and intergrain porosity Pore geometry and connectivity; pore data can be cross-correlated with elemental composition using EDS 145
XCT 1 mm by 5-mm cylinders to 10-cm-diam cores 300 nm to 100 μmb Technique relies on image analysis and 3D reconstruction Results allow for full reconstruction of pore network 147
MIP 3.38 cm3 2 nm to 500 μm Technique only measures connected porosity and assumes pore geometry Results provide details on pore vol, pore size distribution, and surface area 148
PGA Powder samples 0.5 nm to 0.2 μm Technique only measures connected porosity and assumes pore geometry Results provide details on pore vol, pore size distribution, and surface area 149
a

SANS, small-angle neutron scattering; USANS, ultrasmall-angle neutron scattering; FIB-T, focused ion beam tomography; ET, electron tomography; BSEM, backscattered scanning electron microscopy; XCT, X-ray computed tomography; MIP, mercury intrusion porosimetry; PGA, physical gas adsorption; EDS, energy dispersive spectroscopy. Table adapted from Zachara et al. (89).

b

Actual detectable pore size resolution will vary depending upon X-ray source, optics, and material.