Table 1.
Methods | EE Components | Advantages | Limitations | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
REE | TEF | EAT | NEAT | AT | TEE | |||
Whole-room calorimeter | Yes | Yes | Yesa,b | Yesc | Yes | Yes | Accurate (∼5% error), specific parts of TEE can only be measured with this method | Expensive, requires specialized team; not representing free-living conditions |
Hood/canopy (open-circuit) | Yes | Yesb | Yes | No | Yesb | No | Portable, easy to use, available, cheaper | Good accuracy for REE, dependent subject mobility, confined subject |
Doubly labeled water | No | No | No | No | No | Yes | Accurate (<5% error), able to apply long-term free-living conditions | Very expensive, requires expertise, can measure only TEE |
Wearable devices (accelerometers, heart monitors) | No | No | Yes | Yes | No | No | Inexpensive, able to apply long-term free-living conditions | Inaccurate |
Personal logs | No | No | Yesb | No | No | No | Inexpensive, able to apply long- term free-living conditions | Highly inaccurate, subject to recorder bias |
Abbreviations: AT, adaptive thermogenesis; TEF, thermic effect of food.
Chen et al. [31].
Technically challenging.
Requires the use of wearable devices.