Table 4.
Reference | Index | Theoretical basis | Country and target group | Components | Scoring system | Evaluationa |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
ASIA | ||||||
Nishimura et al (2015)96 | Food-based diet quality score for Japanese | Japanese food guide Spinning Top (2005) | Japan; adults | Grain dishes, vegetable dishes, fish and meat, milk, fruits, snacks and alcoholic beverages | 6 components, servings or energy, range 0–60 | Sociodemographic factors, nutrient intakes, metabolic risk factors, BMI, anthropometrics |
Kuriyama et al (2016)81 | Modified food-based diet quality score for Japanese | Japanese food guide Spinning Top (2005) | Japan; adults | Grain dishes, vegetable dishes, fish and meat, milk, fruits, snacks and alcoholic beverages, seasonings | 7 components, servings or energy, range 0–70 | Sociodemographic factors, nutrient intakes, food groups, original food-based diet quality score for Japanese |
Lee et al (2008)84 | Overall Dietary Index Revised (ODI-R) | Taiwanese Dietary Recommendations | Taiwan; adults | Grains/starchy tubers (whole grains), vegetables, fruits, eggs/soy/fish/meat (soybean, fish), dairy products, K/Na ratio, cholesterol, dietary moderation (refined sugars, Na, alcohol), dietary diversity. | 9 components, score based on servings, E%, or amounts consumed, range 0–100 | Nutrient intakes, other DQ score (ODI) |
NORTH AMERICA | ||||||
Jessri et al (2017)75 | Healthy Eating Index–Canada 2010 (HEI-C 2010) | HEI-2010 and Canada’s Food Guide (CFG) 2007 | Canada; children, adolescents, adults | Total fruit and vegetables, whole fruit, greens and beans, whole grains, dairy, total protein foods, seafood and plant proteins, FAs, refined grains, Na, empty calories | 11 components, amount intake per 1000 kcal and E%, range 0–100 | Sociodemographic factors, nutrient intakes, food groups, reliability, BMI |
Woodruff and Hanning (2010)117 | Canadian Healthy Eating Index (HEIC-2009) | Canada’s Food Guide recommendations (HEIC-2009) | Canada; children, adolescents | Grains, vegetables/fruits, milk, meat, other, total fat, saturated fat, cholesterol, dietary variety | 9 components, score based on servings and E%, range 0–100 | Other DQ index (HEI-C) |
Sharafi et al (2015)105 | Healthy Eating Preference Index (HEPI) | Dietary Guidelines for Americans 2010 | USA; preschool children | High-fat/sweet/salty foods, fruits and vegetables, variety score | 6 components, score based on liking scores, range −250 to 250 | Sociodemographic factors, BMI, biomarker, other DQ score (HEI 2010), reliability |
Anderson et al (2015)59 | Healthy score and unhealthy score | Not specified | USA; preschool children | Healthy: fruits, vegetables, milk Unhealthy: SSB, fast food, sweets, salty snacks | Healthy/unhealthy score: 3 components / 4 components, both scores based on frequency, range 0–18/range 0–24 | Food groups |
Vadiveloo et al (2014)109 | US Healthy Food Diversity (HFD) Index | 2010 Dietary Guidelines for Americans and German algorithm | USA; adults | 26 food groups, not specified | 26 components, score based on proportion of the food eaten and a health factor, range 0–1 | Sociodemographic factors, food groups, (mean) probability of nutrient adequacy, other DQ score (DASH diet score) |
Guenther et al (2013)71 | Healthy Eating Index (HEI) 2010 | 2010 Dietary Guidelines for Americans | USA; children, adolescents, adults | Total fruit, whole fruit, total vegetables, greens and beans, whole grains, dairy, total protein foods, seafood and plant proteins, FAs, refined grains, Na, empty calories | 12 components, amount intake per 1000 kcal and E%, range 0–100 | Not described in this publication but for evaluation, see, for example, Guenther et al20 and Anic et al21 |
Lipsky et al (2012)87 | Whole Plant Foods (WPF) | MyPyramid and Center for Nutrition Policy and Promotion of Fruit and Fruit Juice | USA; children, adolescents, adults | Whole fruit, vegetables, whole grains, legumes, nuts, seeds | 6 compounds, score based on amounts, or proportion of intake | Biomarker, biomarkers for CVD, diabetes, and inflammation, other DQ score (HEI-2005) |
Rumawas et al (2009)103 | Mediterranean-Style Dietary Pattern Score (MSDPS) | Mediterranean diet pyramid | USA; adults | Whole-grain cereals, fruits, vegetables, dairy, wine, fish, poultry, olives/ legumes, nuts/potatoes, eggs, sweets, meats, olive oil | 13 components, score based on servings, range 1–100 | Sociodemographic factors, anthropometrics, nutrient intakes, food groups |
Falciglia et al (2009)65 | Dietary variety score | US MyPyramid (2005) | USA; children | Number of foods and beverages consumed in 1 day based on servings | All foods and drinks consumed, score based on prediction equation | Reproducibility (3-day recall vs 15-day recall) |
Guenther et al (2008)72 | Healthy Eating Index–2005 (HEI-2005) | Dietary Guidelines for Americans 2005 | USA; children, adolescents, adults (not pregnant) | Total fruit, whole fruit, total vegetables, dark green and orange vegetables and legumes, total grains, whole grains, milk, meat and beans, oils, saturated fat, Na, calories from solid fats/alcoholic beverages/added sugars | 12 components, score based on amounts consumed /1000 kcal, range 0–100 | Not described in this article but for evaluation see, for example, Guenther et al18 and Grimstvedt et al19 |
Fung et al (2008)67 | DASH-style diet | DASH diet | USA; women | Fruits, vegetables, whole grains, nuts and legumes, low-fat dairy, red and processed meats, sweetened beverages, and Na | 8 components, score based on quintiles of intake, range 8–40 | Sociodemographic factors, nutrient intakes, food group, CHD, stroke, BMI |
AUSTRALIA/NEW ZEALAND | ||||||
Gasser et al (2017)68 | Dietary score | Australian Dietary Guidelines 2013 | Australia; children | Fruits, vegetables, water, fatty foods, sugary foods, SSB, milk products or alternatives | 7 components, frequency, range 0–14 | Dietary patterns, change of food group trajectories over age |
Roy et al (2016)101 | Healthy Eating Index for Australian Adults (HEIF-2013) | Australian Dietary Guidelines 2013 | Australia; young adults | Adequacy: vegetables, fruits, grain (cereal) foods, milk and milk alternatives, meat and protein food alternatives, water | 11 components, score based on servings, range 0–100 | Nutrient intakes, food groups, relative validity |
Limitation: discretionary foods high in saturated fat or added sugars, added salt, alcohol | ||||||
Thorpe et al (2016)108 | Dietary Guideline Index 3013 (DGI-2013) | Australian Dietary Guidelines 2013 | Australia; adults | Adequacy: Food variety, vegetables, fruits, grain (cereal) foods, lean meat and poultry/fish/eggs/nuts/seeds/legumes/beans, milk/yogurt/cheese and alternatives, water | 13 components, score based on servings or type of product, range 0–130 | Sociodemographic factors, health behaviors, BMI |
Limitation: foods containing SFA/salt/sugars/alcohol, foods high in SFA, fatty foods, salty foods, sugary foods, alcohol | ||||||
Taylor et al (2015)107 | Healthy trolley index (HETI) | Australian Guide to Healthy Eating | Australia; adults | Grains/cereals, meat and alternatives, dairy foods and alternatives, fruit, vegetables, discretionary (eg, savory snacks, confectionery, SSB, alcohol, processed meat, baked goods) | 6 components, score based on monthly food expenditure, range 0–100 | Sociodemographic factors, foods/food groups, overweight/obesity |
Zarrin et al (2013)118 | Aussie_DQI | National dietary guidelines linked to the Australia National Health Priority Areas | Australia; adults | Vegetables, fruit, dairy products, meat and alternatives, cereals, E% SFA, E% sugar, alcohol, processed meat, added salt/Na, dietary variety (vegetables, fruits, wholegrain, fish) | 11 components, score based on servings, E%, and amounts, range 0–120 | Sociodemographic factors, nutrient intakes, food groups, BP, all-cause and cancer mortality, overweight, obesity |
Spence et al (2013)106 | Obesity Protective Dietary Index (OPDI) | Based on the intended trial outcomes | Australia; toddlers | Fruits, vegetables, noncore foods | 3 components, score based on grams and KJ, range 0–30 | Nutrient intakes, intervention vs control group of intervention |
Scott et al (2012)104 | Fruit and Vegetable Variety Score (FVVS) | Australian Guide to Healthy Eating | Australia; children | Vegetables, fruits | 16 components, score based on consumption, range 0–16 | Sociodemographic factors, breastfeeding |
Scott et al (2012)104 | Core Food Variety Score (CFVS) | Australian Guide to Healthy Eating | Australia; children | Milk/dairy, grains and grain products, vegetables, fruits, meat or other nondairy protein sources | 34 components, score based on consumption, range 0–34 | Sociodemographic factors, breastfeeding |
Marshall et al (2012)93 | Australian Child and Adolescent Recommended Food Score (ACARFS) | Dietary Guidelines for Children and Adolescents in Australia and US Recommended Food Score | Australia; children and adolescents | Vegetables, fruit, protein foods (meat/flesh), protein foods (meat/flesh alternatives), grains, dairy, water, extras | 8 components, score based on frequency and servings, range 0–73 | Sociodemographic factors, BMI, nutrient intakes, nutrient reference values |
Li et al (2012)86 | Index of Diet Quality | Scientific literature and Australian recommendations | Australia; adolescents | Breads/cereals/rice/pasta/noodles, vegetables, fruit, milk/yoghurt/cheese, meat/fish/poultry/eggs/nuts/legumes, extra foods (soft drinks, chips etc.), vitamin C, vitamin A, dietary fiber, Fe, Ca, protein, total fat (%KJ), saturated fat (%KJ), n-6/n-3 FA ratio | 15 components, score based on amounts consumed and E%, range 20–150 | Sociodemographic factors |
Golley et al (2011)69 | Dietary Guideline Index for Children and Adolescents (DGI-CA) | Australian Dietary Guidelines 2003 for children and adolescents | Australia; children and adolescents | Fruit, vegetables, bread and cereals, whole-grain cereals, meat and alternatives, dairy foods, reduced-fat dairy, fluids, extra foods (nutrient poor and high in fat, salt, and added sugar), healthy fats/oils, diet variety | 11 components, score based on servings, range 0–100 | Sociodemographic factors, anthropometrics, food groups, nutrient intakes |
McNaughton et al (2008)94 | Dietary Guideline Index (DGI) | Australian Guide to Healthy Eating | Australia; adults | Vegetables/legumes, fruit, total cereals, meat and alternatives, total dairy, beverages, Na, saturated fat, alcoholic beverages, added sugars, whole-grain cereals, lean meat, reduced/low fat dairy, dietary variety, extra foods | 15 components, score based on servings, type or frequency, range 0–150 | Sociodemographic factors, anthropometrics, nutrient intakes, BP |
Wong et al (2017)115 | Healthy Dietary Habits Index (HDHI) | New Zealand Food and Nutrition Guidelines for Healthy Adults 2003 | New Zealand; adults | Red meat, chicken, fish/shellfish, milk, spread, low-fat foods, fries, bread, fruit, vegetables, soft drinks, breakfast, fast foods, added salt, low-salt foods. | 15 components, score based on frequencies, servings or type of product, range 0–60 | Sociodemographic factors, BMI, nutrient intakes, nutritional biomarkers |
Wong et al (2014)114 | Healthy Dietary Habits Score for Adolescents (HDHS-A) | Scientific literature and New Zealand Food and Nutrition Guidelines for Healthy Children and Young people | New Zealand; adolescents | Fat from meat/poultry/fish, other fats, fruit, vegetables and bread, sugar sources, meal habits | 17 components grouped in 5 clusters, score based on frequency and servings, range 0–68 | Sociodemographic factors, BMI, nutrient intakes, biomarker, expert review, reliability |
Wong et al (2013)116 | New Zealand Diet Quality Index for Adolescents (NZDQI-A) | New Zealand Food and Nutrition Guidelines for Healthy Adolescents | New Zealand; adolescents | Fruits, vegetables, bread and cereals, milk and milk products, meat and alternatives | 5 components, score based on servings and frequency, range 0–100 | Nutrient intakes, reproducibility, reliability, relative validity |
EUROPE | ||||||
Freisling et al (2009)66 | Food frequency index (FFI) | Austrian Food Based Dietary Guidelines | Austria; adults | Vegetables, fruits, whole-meal bread, pasta/rice, pulses, nuts, milk products, beef/pork, processed meats, poultry | 10 components, score based on frequency, range 0–70 | Sociodemographic factors, BMI, nutrient intakes, biomarker, cholesterol |
Vandevijvere et al (2010)110 | Dietary diversity, dietary adequacy, dietary moderation, and dietary balance scores | Food-based dietary guidelines (FBDG) | Belgium; adults | Water (including coffee, tea and broth), bread/cereals, grains and potatoes, vegetables, fruits, dairy products (including Ca-enriched soy products, excluding cheese), cheese, meat/fish/eggs/legumes/nuts/meat substitutes, spreadable fats, energy-dense nutrient-poor foods | 4 scores, based on servings | Sociodemographic factors, BMI, scores are compared among each other |
Huybrechts et al (2010)74 | Diet Quality Index (DQI) | Flemish Dietary gGidelines 2004 | Belgium; preschool children | Dietary diversity, dietary quality, dietary moderation, dietary adequacy, dietary equilibrium, meal index | 6 components, score based on amounts and recommendations, range 25%–100% | Nutrient intakes, reproducibility, relative validity |
Lazarou et al (2009)82 | E-KINDEX | Not mentioned | Cyprus; children | Bread, cereals, and grain foods (excluding bread), fruit and fruit juices, vegetables, legumes, milk, fish and seafood, meat, salted and smoked meat food, sweets and snack items, soft drinks, fried food, grilled food | 13 components, Score based on frequency, range 0–37 | BP |
Biltoft-Jensen et al (2008)60 | Simple Diet Quality Index (SDQI) | Danish Dietary Guidelines, NNR 2004 | Denmark; adults | Saturated fat, fiber | 2 components, score based recommended intake, range 0–100 | Sociodemographic factors, nutrient intakes, food groups, obesity, overweight |
Meinilä et al (2016)95 | Healthy Food Intake Index (HFII) | Nordic Nutrition Recommendations (NNR) | Finland; pregnant women | Vegetables, fruits/berries, high-fiber grains, fish, low-fat milk, low-fat cheese, cooking fat, fat spread, snacks, SSB, fast food | 11 components, frequencies, range 0–17 | Sociodemographic factors, BMI, nutrient intakes, reproducibility |
Roytio et al (2015)102 | Children’s Index of Diet Quality (CIDQ) | Nordic Nutrition Recommendations | Finland; children | Fiber, vegetables, fruits and berries, SFA, PUFA, saccharose, Ca | 6 components, score based on E% and gram intake, range 0–21 | BMI, nutrient intakes, biomarker, se/sp analysis |
Kanerva et al (2014)77 | Baltic Sea Diet Score (BSDS) | Baltic Sea Diet Pyramid | Finland; adults | Fruits and berries, vegetables, cereals, low-fat milk, fish, meat products, total fat, fat ratio (PUFA to SFA + trans fatty acids), alcohol. | 9 components, score based on quartiles, range 0–25; or score based on median, range 0–9 | Sociodemographic factors, BMI, nutrient intakes |
Leppala et al (2010)85 | Index of Diet Quality (IDQ) | Nordic Nutrition Recommendations and Finish Nutrition Recommendations | Finland; adults | Whole-grain products, fat-containing foods, dairy products, vegetables/ fruits/berries, sugar, meal pattern | 6 components, score based on frequency, range 0–15 | Nutrient intakes, se/sp analysis, BMI |
Estaquio et al (2008)64 | French Score of Indicators of the PNNS Objectives (FSIPO) | Program Nutritional Nutrition Santé | France; adults | Fruits/vegetables, Ca, total fat, saturated fat, carbohydrate consumption, complex carbohydrates, simple sugars, fiber, alcohol, cholesterol level, SBP, BMI, physical activity | 13 components, score based on servings or RDA or %E intake, range 0–17.5 | Sociodemographic factors, nutrient intakes, biomarkers, NCDs |
Kleiser et al (2009)78 | Healthy Nutrition Score for Kids and Youth (HuSKY) | OMD recommendations | Germany; children and adolescents | Beverages, vegetables, fruit, fish, bread/ cereals, pasta/rice/potatoes, milk/dairy products, eggs, fats, meat/ sausages, sweets/fatty snacks/soft drinks | 11 components, score based on the proportion to recommended intake, range 0–100 | Sociodemographic factors, biomarkers |
Manios et al (2015)91 | Revised Healthy Lifestyle-Diet Index (R-HLD-Index) | USDA’s Choose My Plate recommendations | Greece; children and adolescents | Fruits, vegetables, grains, milk/dairy products, meat/meat products, fish/seafood, legumes, eggs, soft drinks, sweets, physical activity status, time spend on moderate to vigorous physical activity | 12 components, score based on servings and time spent on activity, range 0–48 | overweight, obesity, iron deficiency |
Manios et al (2010)90 | Healthy Lifestyle-Diet Index (HLD-Index) | MyPyramid, American Academy of Pediatrics | Greece; children | Fruits, vegetables, grains, dairy products, meat, fish/seafood, soft drinks, sweets, physical activity, screen time | 10 components, score based on servings and time spent on activity, range 0–40 | Nutrient intakes, insulin resistance, estimated average requirements |
Manios et al (2010)89 | Preschoolers Diet-Lifestyle Index (PDL-Index) | USDA food guide pyramid, Canada’s Food Guide, American Heart Association, American Academy of Pediatrics | Greece; preschool children | Fruits, vegetables, total grains, dairy products, red meat, white meat/ legumes, fish/seafood, unsaturated fats, sweets, physical activity, screen time | 11 components, score based on servings and time spent on activity, range 0–44 | Nutrient intakes, food groups, estimated average requirements, obesity, overweight |
Kourlaba et al (2009)80 | Elderly Dietary Index (EDI) | Modified MyPyramid for Older Adults and features of the Mediterranean diet | Greece; elderly | Meat, fish, fruits, vegetables, cereals, legumes, olive oil, alcohol, type of bread, dairy products | 10 components, score based on frequency, range 10–40 | Sociodemographic factors, food groups, obesity, hypertension, hypercholesterolemia, diabetes |
Kosti et al (2009)79 | Diet-Lifestyle Index | Scientific literature | Greece; adolescents | Vegetables, fruits, whole grains, sweets/added sugars, breakfast cereals, dairy products, sports activities, sedentary behavior, consumption of breakfast, eating away from home, number of eating episodes a day, visible fat consumption, obesity status of parents | 13 components, score based on servings, type or behavior, range 11–57 | Sociodemographic factors, obesity, overweight |
Perry et al (2015)98 | Diet Quality Score (DQS) | Irish guidelines | Ireland; children | Fruit, fruit juice, meat/chicken/fish, eggs, cooked vegetables, raw vegetables, meat pie/hamburger/hot dog/sausage, hot chips or french fries, crisps/savory snacks, bread, potatoes/pasta/rice, cereals, biscuits/doughnut/cake/pie/chocolate, cheese/yoghurt/fromage frais, low fat cheese/low fat yogurt, water, soft drinks (not diet), soft drinks (diet), full-cream milk and products, skimmed milk and products | 20 components, score based on frequency, range 12–28 | Sociodemographic factors, food groups, obesity/ overweight |
Looman et al (2017)88 | Dutch Healthy Diet Index 2015 (DHD15-Index) | Dutch Dietary Guidelines 2015 | The Netherlands; adults | Vegetables, fruit, whole-grain products, legumes, nuts, dairy, fish, tea, fats and oils, coffee, red meat, processed meat, SSsB and fruit juices, alcohol, salt | 15 components, grams per day, range 0–150 | Sociodemographic factors, nutrient intakes, relative validity |
Lee et al (2012)83 | Dutch Healthy Diet Index (DHD-Index) | Dutch Guidelines for a Healthy Diet 2006 | The Netherlands; adults | Physical activity, vegetables, fruit / fruit juices, fiber, fish, SFA, TFA, acid drinks and foods, Na, alcohol | 10 components, score based on activities, grams or E%, range 0–100 | Sociodemographic factors, BMI, food groups, nutrient intakes |
Voortman et al (2015)113 | Diet Quality Score (DQS) | National and international guidelines and scientific literature | The Netherlands; toddlers | Vegetables, fruit, bread/cereals, rice/ pasta/potatoes/ legumes, dairy, meat/ eggs, fish, oils/fats, candy/snacks, SSBs | 10 components, score based on intake in grams and adjusted for energy intake, range 0–10 | Sociodemographic factors, anthropometrics, BMI (NS), nutrient intakes |
Jonge et al (2015)76 | Bone Mineral Density (BMD) diet score | Scientific literature | The Netherlands; elderly | Vegetables, fruits, dairy products, whole grain products, fish/seafood, legumes/ beans, meat, confectionary | 8 components, score based on quartiles, range 8–24 | Sociodemographic factors, biomarker, anthropometrics, NCDs, bone mineral density, other DQ score (HDI) |
Jonge et al (2015)76 | Healthy Diet Indicator (HDI) (adapted from Jankovic et al119) | WHO dietary guidelines 2003 | The Netherlands; elderly | SFA, mono- and disaccharides, cholesterol, trans fat, Na, PUFA, protein, total fat, n-6 PUFA, n-3 PUFA, dietary fiber, fruits/vegetables | 12 components, score based on grams intake, range 0–120 | Bone Mineral Density |
Hillesund et al (2014)73 | New Nordic Diet (NND) Score | Guidelines of the NND | Norway; women (mothers) | Meal pattern, Nordic fruit consumption, root vegetables, cabbages, potatoes, whole grain breads, oatmeal porridge, food from the wild countryside, milk, water | 10 components, score based on frequency and type, range 0–10 | Sociodemographic factors, food groups, nutrient intakes, BMI, pregnancy outcomes |
Rodríguez-Martin et al (2017)100 | EVIDENT diet quality index | Scientific literature | Spain; adults | Adequacy: Low-fat dairy, poultry, rabbit, fish, dark-yellow vegetables, green leafy vegetables, cruciferous vegetables, other vegetables, gazpacho, potatoes, fruits, fresh fruit juice, beans/lentils/chickpeas, whole-grain bread/rice/cereal/pasta, olive oil, green/black tea, red wine, beer | 36 components, frequency per week/day, range 0–100 | Sociodemographic and lifestyle factors, nutrient intake, food groups, Mediterranean diet, CVD risk, BP, anthropometrics, pulse wave velocity |
Limiting: whole-fat dairy, ice cream, red meat, processed meat, pizza, fried potatoes, salty snack foods, added fats/ oils, butter, sweet breads, desserts, added sweets, precooked meals, sauce (ketchup, mayonnaise), honey, jam, soda, bottled juices | ||||||
Mariscal-Arcas et al (2009)92 | Mediterranean Diet Index for pregnant women (MDS-P) | Mediterranean diet and specific needs during pregnancy based on scientific literature | Spain; pregnant women | Vegetables, fruits/nuts, pulses, cereals, fish, MUFA/SFA ratio, meat, dairy products, Fe, Ca, folic acid | 11 components, scored based on RDI, range 0–11 | Anthropometrics, nutrient intakes, food groups, pregnancy outcomes |
Drake et al (2011)63 | Diet Quality Index–Swedish Nutrition Recommendations (DQI-SNR) | Swedish Nutrition Recommendations (SNR) and the Swedish Dietary Guidelines (SDG) | Sweden; adults | SFA, PUFA, fish and shellfish, dietary fiber, fruit and vegetables, sucrose | 6 components, score based on intake in weights and E%, range 0–6 | Sociodemographic factors, anthropometrics, food groups, nutrient intakes, BP and NCDs |
Cleghorn et al (2016)61 | Dietary quality score (DQS) | WHO/FAO expert consultation group 2003 | UK; adults | Fruit, vegetable, oily fish, nonmilk extrinsic sugar, fat | 5 components, servings or gram per day, range 0–15 | Relative validity, foods |
Verger et al (2015)112 | Probability of Adequate Nutrient Intake (PANDiet) score (updated) | United Kingdom nutritional recommendations | UK; young children | Protein, total carbohydrates, non-milk extrinsic sugars, total fat, SFA, PUFA, thiamin, riboflavin, niacin, folate, vitamin A, vitamin B6, vitamin B12, vitamin C, vitamin D, Ca, magnesium, zinc, phosphorus, potassium, Fe, copper, selenium, iodine, Na | 25 nutrients, scored based on adequacy probability, range 0–100 | Sociodemographic factors, food groups, consumption of infant formula/foods |
Pot et al (2014)99 | Eating Choices Index (ECI) | Based on NSHD consumption data and discussion with researchers | UK; adults | Consumption of breakfast, consumption of 2 portions of fruit per day, type of milk consumed, type of bread consumed | 4 components, score based on frequency and type, range 4–20 | Sociodemographic factors, nutrient intakes, overweight, obesity |
Golley et al (2012)70 | Complementary Feeding Utility Index (CFUI) | Complementary feeding guidelines of Australia, New Zealand, USA, and UK | UK; infants | Breastfeeding duration, feeding on demand, timing of introduction to solids, exposure to Fe-rich cereals, fruit, vegetables, protein foods variety, exposure to sugary drinks, exposure to confectionary, cakes, savory snacks, cow milk introduction, exposure to tea, timing of lumpy food intro, exposure to commercial infant foods, daily meal/snack frequency. | 14 components, score based on probability function, range 0–1 | Sociodemographic factors, BMI, food group, nutrient intake, feeding behavior |
Crombie et al (2009)62 | Diet quality score | Caroline Walker Trust, Eat Well plate | UK; women (mothers) | Bread/other cereals/potatoes, fruit/ vegetables, dairy products, meat/ fish/ alternatives, high-fat/ high-sugar snacks | 5 components, score based on daily portions, range 0–5 | Maternal knowledge and views |
Oliveira et al (2015)97 | Healthy Plate Variety Score | Modified version of food variety index for toddlers | Portugal, UK, France; children | Starchy foods (including potatoes), fruits, vegetables, meat/fish/alternatives, dairy foods | 5 components, score based on servings, range 0–5 | Children’s eating behavior |
Vereecken et al (2008)111 | Fruit and vegetable index, fiber index, calcium index, variety index, excess index, short excess index | Not mentioned | Belgium and Italy; children | Fruit and vegetable index, fiber index (FV and brown bread), Ca index (whole-fat milk, semi-skimmed milk, cheese, and other milk products), variety index (combination of fiber index and Ca index), excess index (carbonated sugared soft drinks, sweets, chips, crisps), short excess index (soft drinks, sweets) | Not specified | Nutrient intakes, reproducibility, relative validity |
Abbreviations: BMI, body mass index; BP, blood pressure; Ca, calcium; CHD, coronary heart disease; CVD, cardiovascular disease; DASH, Dietary Approaches to Stop Hypertension; DQ, diet quality; EVIDENT, Estilos de vida y disfunción endotelial; E%, percentage of energy; FA, fatty acid; FAO, Food and Agricultural Organization of the United Nations; Fe, iron; FV, food variety; HEI, Healthy Eating Index; K, potassium; %KJ, percentage of kilojoule; MUFA, monounsaturated fatty acid; Na, sodium; NCD, noncommunicable disease; NS, not significant; NSHD, The Medical Research Council National Survey of Health and Development; OMD, optimized mixed diet; PNNS, Program Nutritional Nutrition Santé; PUFA, polyunsaturated fatty acid; RDA, Recommended Dietary Allowance; RDI, Recommended Dietary Intake; SBP, systolic blood pressure; se/sp analysis, sensitivity/specificity analysis; SFA, saturated fatty acids; SSB, sugar-sweetened beverage; TFA, total fatty acid; USDA, United States Agency for International Development; WHO, World Health Organization of the United Nations.
Some diet quality indices are more extensively evaluated and described in additional publications; however, our review search was not specifically set up for such validation studies, and thus articles describing such validation studies are not included in our review.