Skip to main content
. 2019 Jul 5;14(7):e0214263. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0214263

Table 1. Doberman pinschers under study: Basic characteristics and serum activities of autoantibodies directed against the β1-adrenergic (β1-AAB) and muscarinic receptor 2 (M2-AAB).

Basic characteristics Autoantibody presence (n/%)
β1-AAB (n/%) M2-AAB (n/%) §
(+) (-) (+) (-)
Total study cohort (n) 118 78/66.1 40/33.9 7/5.9 111/94.1
Age (years; median/min/max 6/1/13
Male (n/%) 60/50.8
Female (n/%) 58/49.2
Lost to follow up 5/4.2
Survivors (n/%) 59/50.0 31/52.5 28/47.5 5/8.5 54/91.5
Non-survivors (n/%) 54/45.8 43/79.6** 11/20.4 2/3.7 52/96.3
Non-Survivors due to cardiac reason (n/%) 35/29.7 26/74.3* 9/25.7 0/0 35/100
Non-survivors due to non-cardiac reason (n/%) 19/16.1 17/89.5* 2/10.5 2/10.5 17/89.5
Doberman cardiomyopathy total (n/%) 87/73.7 59/67.8 28/32.2 5/5.7 83/94.3
Age (years; median/min/max 7/2/11
Male (n/%) 46/52.6
Female (n/%) 41/47.2
Lost to follow up (n/%) 2/2.3
Survivors (n/%) 43/49.4
Non-survivors (n/%) 42/48.3
Non-survivors due to cardiac reason (n/%) 30/34.5
Non-survivors due to non-cardiac reason (n/%) 12/13.8
Arrhythmia exclusively (n/%) Diagnostic criteria VPC/24h > 300 or twice 50–300 VPC/24h within one year 17/19.5 12/70.6 5/29.4 1/5.9 16/94.1
Age (years; median/min/max) 6/2/10
Male (n/%) 13/76.5
Female (n/%) 4/23.5
Medication (n/%)
No treatment 5/29.4
Beta-blocker 2/11.8
Antiarrhythmic drug 2/11.8
Antiarrhythmic drug/ACE inhibitor 8/47.0
Echocardiographic pathologies (n/%) Diagnostic criteria ESVI >55 ml/m2 or EDVI >95 ml/m2 27/31.0 15/56.6 12/44.4 0/0 27/100
Age (years; median/min/max) 8/3/11
Male (n/%) 8/29.6
Female (n/%) 19/70.4
Medication (n/%)
No treatment 2/7.5
Calcium sensitizer/PDE3 inhibitor 12/44.5
Calcium sensitizer/PDE3 inhibitor/ACE inhibitor 13/48.0
Arrhythmia + echocardiographic pathologies Diagnostic criteria VPC/24 >300 or twice 50–300 VPC/24h within one year ESVI >55 ml/m2 or EDVI >95 ml/m2 43/49.5 32/74.4 11/25.6 4/9.3 39/90.7
Age (years; median/min/max) 7/2/10
Male (n/%) 20/46.5
Female (n/%) 23/53.5
Medication (n/%)
No treatment 1/2.5
Calcium sensitizer/PDE3 inhibitor 1/2.5
Calcium sensitizer/PDE3 inhibitor/ACE inhibitor 16/37.2
Calcium sensitizer/PDE3 inhibitor/ACE inhibitor/beta-blocker 8/18.6
Calcium sensitizer/PDE3 inhibitor/ACE inhibitor/beta-blocker/antiarrhythmic drug 13/30.2
ACE inhibitor/antiarrhythmic drug 2/4.6
ACE inhibitor/beta-blocker 2/4.6
Control group (n/%) Diagnostic criteria VPC/24 <300 or <twice 50–300 VPC/24h within one year ESVI <55 ml/m2 or EDVI <95 ml/m2 31/26.3 19/61.3 12/38.7 2/6.5 29/93.5
Age (years; median/min/max) 6/1/13
Male (n/%) 17/54.8
Female (n/%) 14/45.2
Lost to follow up (n/%) 3/9.7
Survivors (n/%) 16/51.6
Non-survivors 12/38.7
Non-survivors due to cardiac reason (n/%) 5/16.1
Non-survivors due to non-cardiac reason (n/%) 7/22.6

§ all M2-AAB positive dogs were also positive for β1-AAB; β1-AAB (+) vs. (-)

* p<0.05;

** p<0.01.