Table 1. Strategies of the two-stage intervention for reducing CS rates in Guangzhou, China, 2010–2016.
Intervention Elements | Stage 1 (October 1, 2010–September 30, 2014) | Stage 2 (October 1, 2014–December 31, 2016) | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
Plans and Strategies | Outputs | Plans and Strategies | Outputs | |
Health education | (1) Professional training | (1) 125 full-time health education professionals trained, covering all 12 districts | (1) Professional training | (1) 233 full-time health education professionals trained, covering all 12 districts |
● 1 full d/session, 4 sessions/person | ● Duration, frequency, and target skills: same as Stage 1 | |||
● Target skills: communication, presentation, community-level health education methodology | ● Training at least 1 professional from each maternity facility | |||
(2) Community lecturing | (2) 100 lectures delivered, covering all 12 districts | (2) Community lecturing | (2) 100 lectures delivered, covering all 12 districts | |
● Target subjects: pregnant women and their families | ● Target subjects, duration, coverage, and main topics: same as Stage 1 | |||
● 90 min/lecture | ● Additional topics: labor analgesia, maternal mental health | |||
● Main topics: pregnancy planning, advantages of vaginal delivery, maternal nutrition and exercise, postpartum care for vaginal and cesarean delivery | ||||
(3) Publicity platform building | (3) Leaflets and presenting posters disseminated in all communities and maternity facilities, videos played on approximately 40% of the buses across the city | (3) Publicity platform building | (3) Leaflets, posters, and videos: same as Stage 1; publicity videos played on local TV channels and outdoor LED screens across the city, educational articles posted on local newspapers and social media | |
● Cooperating with professional and designers | ● Production, approaches, and main topics: same as Stage 1 | |||
● Including leaflets, posters, videos | ● Additionally including multimedia approaches | |||
● Main topics: vaginal birth, routine prenatal care, maternal lifestyles during pregnancy, postpartum care | ||||
(4) “Toolbox” production | (4) A “toolbox” produced, containing 800+ collated and reorganized items of materials, with full access open to all health education professionals | |||
● For creating new health education materials | ||||
● Including a collection of relevant articles, leaflets, posters, videos | ||||
● Including raw materials (e.g., slide templates, pictures, footage, etc.) | ||||
● Covering main topics in (2) and (3) | ||||
Skills training | (1) Expert on-site instructions | (1) Experts assigned to 82 primary and secondary healthcare institutions, each expert working on site for 100 d | (1) Core skills training | (1) 100 obstetricians, 100 midwives, 100 pediatricians, and 100 pediatric nurses trained |
● Target subjects: obstetricians, anesthesiologists, and midwives from primary and secondary healthcare institutions | ● Target subjects: obstetricians, midwives, pediatricians, and pediatric nurses from primary and secondary healthcare institutions | |||
● Target skills: up-to-date clinical knowledge and skills | ● Target skills: the same core skillset for obstetrics and gynecology, pediatrics, maternal and child health at Stage 1 | |||
● Approaches: teaching, thematic training, discussion of challenging cases, and surgical demonstration | ● Off-the-job training for 2 mo in designated training centers with exit exams | |||
(2) Core skills training | (2) 200 obstetricians, 100 neonatologists, and 100 midwives trained | (2) Advanced skills training | (2) Training coverage of 100% in all maternity facilities | |
● Target subjects: backbones of obstetricians, neonatologists, and midwives from primary healthcare institutions | ● Target subjects and skills: same as Stage 1 | |||
● Target skills: core knowledge and skills in perinatal practice (e.g., analgesic vaginal delivery, labor process monitoring using partogram, etc., with the emphasis of reducing unnecessary clinical interventions) | ||||
● Off-the-job training for 3–6 mo in designated tertiary hospitals with exit exams | ||||
(3) Advanced skills training | (3) Training coverage of 100% in all primary and secondary healthcare institutions | |||
● Target subjects: obstetric, pediatric, midwifery, and anesthesiologic professionals from primary and secondary healthcare institutions | ||||
● Target skills: pediatric advanced life support | ||||
Equipment and technical support for primary and secondary maternity facilities | Not applicable | Not applicable | (1) Basic equipment support | (1) 68 primary and secondary maternity facilities supported, covering all 12 districts |
● Target departments: obstetric and pediatric outpatient, emergency, inpatient, ICU, and medical laboratory departments | ||||
(2) Specific technical support | (2) Experts assigned to 10 selected maternity facilities, each expert working on site for 3 mo | |||
● Expert in-site instructions on specific techniques | ||||
● Target institutions: selected secondary maternity facilities based on demands and existing resources | ||||
● Target techniques: vital sign monitoring, forceps delivery, and neonatal resuscitation | ||||
Capacity building for the maternal near-miss care system | (1) Capacity expansion for municipal-level maternal near-miss care centers | (1) 6 new municipal-level maternal near-miss care centers established for specific diseases | (1) Capacity building for district-level maternal near-miss care centers | (1) 8 new district-level maternal near-miss care centers established; a long-term municipal-district twinned support system set up |
● From “one for all” to “specialized maternity intensive care” | ● Increasing the number of centers based on the demand of district | |||
● Developing municipal-district twined support to enhance technical cooperation |
Information in this table was obtained from the proposals and annual reports of the Action Plan for Safe Motherhood and Infancy.
Abbreviations: CS, cesarean section; ICU, intensive care unit; LED, light emitting diode