Table 4.
Summary of the overall weight-of-evidence determinations for each health outcome.
Health Outcome Categories | Total Number of Studies | Health Outcomes | Reference | Number of Studies Per Certainty Rating | Weight of Evidence | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Positive Association | Null Association | |||||||||
High | Moderate | Low | Low | Moderate | High | |||||
Birth defects | 2 | Congenital heart defects | McKenzie [32] | 1 | Insufficient | |||||
Oral clefts | McKenzie [32] | 1 | Insufficient | |||||||
Neural tube defects | McKenzie [32] | 1 | Insufficient | |||||||
Birth defects prevalence | Ma [33] | 1 | Insufficient | |||||||
Birth outcomes | 8 | Decreased term birth weight or low birth weight | Casey [35]; Currie [36]; Hill [37]; McKenzie [32]; Stacy [38]; Whitworth [39] | 2 | 1 | 2 | 1 | Mixed | ||
Early infant mortality | Busby [34] | 1 | Insufficient | |||||||
Fetal death | Whitworth [39] | 1 | Insufficient | |||||||
Gestation period | Hill [37] | 1 | Insufficient | |||||||
Low infant health index | Currie [36] | 1 | Insufficient | |||||||
Low APGAR score a | Casey [35]; Hill [37] | 1 | 1 | Mixed | ||||||
Preterm/premature birth | Casey [35]; Hill [37]; McKenzie [32]; Stacy [38]; Whitworth [39,40] | 1 | 3 | 1 | 1 | Mixed | ||||
Small for gestational age | Casey [35]; Hill [37]; Stacy [38]; Whitworth [39] | 2 | 1 | 1 | Mixed | |||||
Cancer | 3 | Cancer incidence (childhood) | Fryzek [47] | 1 | Insufficient | |||||
Leukemia (childhood non-specific and acute lymphocytic leukemia) | Fryzek [47]; McKenzie [48] | 1 | 1 | Mixed | ||||||
Non-Hodgkin’s lymphoma (childhood) | McKenzie [48] | 1 | Insufficient | |||||||
CNS tumorsb(child) | Fryzek [47] | 1 | Insufficient | |||||||
Urinary bladder | Finkel [46] | 1 | Insufficient | |||||||
Thyroid | Finkel [46] | 1 | Insufficient | |||||||
Leukemia | Finkel [46] | 1 | Insufficient | |||||||
Cardiovascular | 3 | Hospitalizations | Jemielita [53]; Peng [54] | 1 | 1 | Mixed | ||||
Self-reported symptoms | Rabinowitz [55] | 1 | Insufficient | |||||||
Dermal | 2 | Self-reported symptoms | Elliott [52]; Rabinowitz [55] | 1 | 1 | Mixed | ||||
Gastrointestinal | 2 | Self-reported symptoms | Elliott [52]; Rabinowitz [55] | 2 | Limited- failing to show an association | |||||
Neurological | 4 | Hospitalizations | Jemielita [53] | 1 | Insufficient | |||||
Self-reported symptoms | Elliott [52]; Rabinowitz [55]; Tustin [57] | 3 | Limited- failing to show an association | |||||||
Psychological | 2 | Self-reported symptoms | Casey [36]; Tustin [57] | 1 | 1 | Mixed | ||||
Diagnosed sleep disturbances | Casey [36] | 1 | Insufficient | |||||||
Respiratory | 6 | Self-reported symptoms | Elliott [52]; Rabinowitz [55]; Tustin [57] | 1 | 2 | Mixed | ||||
Hospitalizations | Jemielita [53]; Peng [54] | 1 | 1 | Mixed | ||||||
Asthma exacerbation | Rasmussen [56] | 1 | Limited | |||||||
Other | 2 | Self-reported symptoms (multiple) | Elliott [52]; Tustin [57] | 2 | Limited | |||||
Hospitalizations (all) | Jemielita [53] | 1 | Insufficient |
a APGAR score: Appearance, Pulse, Grimace, Activity and Respiration score. b CNS: Central Nervous System.