Skip to main content
. 2018 Dec;18(6):327–335. doi: 10.2174/1566523218666181109124538

Table 1. Comparison of the advantages and disadvantages of HSCT to future possible DNA- and RNA-based therapeutic approaches for DBA.

Present Therapeutic Strategies Advantages Disadvantages Refs.
Hematopoietic stem cell transplantation • One treatment is resolutive, if successful
• High rate of success for HLA-matched donors
• Feasible without knowing the causative mutation
• Risk of GvHD
• Adverse effects due to preconditioning
• Risk of unknown mutations in silent carriers
• Immunosuppressive therapy
[1, 30, 31]
Future therapeutic strategies Advantages Disadvantages Refs.
DNA-based Ex vivo gene addition in HSCs • One treatment is resolutive, if successful
• No need for a donor; no need for prolonged immunosuppressive therapy; no GvHD occurrence
• Reduced or absent preconditioning
• The causative mutation must be known
• Off targets effects
• Risk of insertional mutagenesis
[54, 57-59, 61]
Ex vivo gene addition in iPSCs • One treatment is resolutive, if successful
• No need for a donor; no need for prolonged immunosuppressive therapy; no GvHD occurrence
• Unlimited source of autologous cells
• Cell genome can be studied before reinfusion
• Reduced or absent preconditioning
• The causative mutation must be known
• Very low reprogramming efficiency
• Risks connected to reprogramming procedure
• Off targets effects
• Risk of insertional mutagenesis
• Risk of somatic mutations in the cells of origin
[64, 65, 68, 69]
In vivo gene addition • One treatment is resolutive, if successful
• No need for a donor; no need for prolonged immunosuppressive therapy; no GvHD occurrence
• No preconditioning
• The causative mutation must be known
• Off targets effects
• Risk of insertional mutagenesis
• Possible immune response against the vector
• Lack of data for the application of this technology to RP genes
[71-73]
Gene editing • One treatment is resolutive, if successful
• No need for a donor; no need for prolonged immunosuppressive therapy; no GvHD occurrence
• No preconditioning
• Gene expression is under the regulation of endogenous mechanisms
• The causative mutation must be known
• Off targets effects
• Lack of data for the application of this technology to RP genes
[74, 82]
RNA-based SMaRT
SINEUPs
saRNAs
• No need for a donor; no need for prolonged immunosuppressive therapy; no GvHD occurrence
• No preconditioning
• Theoretically very specific
• The expression of the deficient gene is increased to a physiological level
• Chronic administrations are needed
• The causative mutation must be known
• Off targets effects
• Lack of data for the application of these technologies to RP genes
[88, 90, 92-94, 96, 97]