Table 1. Comparison of the advantages and disadvantages of HSCT to future possible DNA- and RNA-based therapeutic approaches for DBA.
Present Therapeutic Strategies | Advantages | Disadvantages | Refs. | |
---|---|---|---|---|
Hematopoietic stem cell transplantation | • One treatment is resolutive, if successful • High rate of success for HLA-matched donors • Feasible without knowing the causative mutation |
• Risk of GvHD • Adverse effects due to preconditioning • Risk of unknown mutations in silent carriers • Immunosuppressive therapy |
[1, 30, 31] | |
Future therapeutic strategies | Advantages | Disadvantages | Refs. | |
DNA-based | Ex vivo gene addition in HSCs | • One treatment is resolutive, if successful • No need for a donor; no need for prolonged immunosuppressive therapy; no GvHD occurrence • Reduced or absent preconditioning |
• The causative mutation must be known • Off targets effects • Risk of insertional mutagenesis |
[54, 57-59, 61] |
Ex vivo gene addition in iPSCs | • One treatment is resolutive, if successful • No need for a donor; no need for prolonged immunosuppressive therapy; no GvHD occurrence • Unlimited source of autologous cells • Cell genome can be studied before reinfusion • Reduced or absent preconditioning |
• The causative mutation must be known • Very low reprogramming efficiency • Risks connected to reprogramming procedure • Off targets effects • Risk of insertional mutagenesis • Risk of somatic mutations in the cells of origin |
[64, 65, 68, 69] | |
In vivo gene addition | • One treatment is resolutive, if successful • No need for a donor; no need for prolonged immunosuppressive therapy; no GvHD occurrence • No preconditioning |
• The causative mutation must be known • Off targets effects • Risk of insertional mutagenesis • Possible immune response against the vector • Lack of data for the application of this technology to RP genes |
[71-73] | |
Gene editing | • One treatment is resolutive, if successful • No need for a donor; no need for prolonged immunosuppressive therapy; no GvHD occurrence • No preconditioning • Gene expression is under the regulation of endogenous mechanisms |
• The causative mutation must be known • Off targets effects • Lack of data for the application of this technology to RP genes |
[74, 82] | |
RNA-based | SMaRT SINEUPs saRNAs |
• No need for a donor; no need for prolonged immunosuppressive therapy; no GvHD occurrence • No preconditioning • Theoretically very specific • The expression of the deficient gene is increased to a physiological level |
• Chronic administrations are needed • The causative mutation must be known • Off targets effects • Lack of data for the application of these technologies to RP genes |
[88, 90, 92-94, 96, 97] |