Skip to main content
. 2019 Jul 12;10:653. doi: 10.3389/fgene.2019.00653

Table 1.

Taxonomic classification accuracies obtained using different pair-wise combinations of V-regions (both contiguous as well as non-contiguous) evaluated for mock microbiome datasets, each constituting of 10,000 randomly selected 16S rRNA genes from five different 16S gene pools.

Combination of V-region Classification accuracy (%) at species level averaged over five mock datasets from each 16S gene pool
Mock datasets from 16S gene pool 1 Mock datasets from 16S gene pool 2 Mock datasets from 16S gene pool 3 Mock datasets from 16S gene pool 4 Mock datasets from 16S gene pool 5 Average accuracy
V1+V4 77.29 79.47 72.79 75.90 80.48 77.19
V1+V3 74.69 78.16 77.52 74.76 80.08 77.04
V1+V8 76.03 77.96 73.24 75.72 79.32 76.46
V1+V7 77.20 78.33 70.37 77.34 78.60 76.37
V1+V6 72.46 77.34 69.73 78.25 76.90 74.94
V1+V5 70.89 74.24 69.16 73.37 76.40 72.81
V1+V9 71.74 71.41 71.33 73.95 75.57 72.80
V2+V4 69.07 75.07 72.76 70.99 73.55 72.29
V2+V8 68.26 74.60 73.33 70.66 73.27 72.02
V2+V6 66.84 74.54 72.60 72.19 72.67 71.77
V2+V7 68.34 72.76 72.73 71.17 71.30 71.26
V2V3* 61.53 71.52 72.03 66.31 73.92 69.06
V2+V9 65.03 68.85 71.60 66.32 71.81 68.72
V1V2* 64.20 70.29 66.81 65.44 72.40 67.83
V3+V8 68.47 61.80 69.66 66.59 67.82 66.87
V3+V7 68.41 61.60 71.05 66.80 65.93 66.76
V2+V5 61.38 68.19 68.42 65.36 69.34 66.54
V3+V6 63.26 59.91 68.53 67.04 65.15 64.78
V3+V9 63.63 55.85 67.20 65.94 63.83 63.29
V3+V5 60.94 56.74 65.79 62.91 62.49 61.77

Accuracy of taxonomic assignments has been evaluated at the species level considering the assignments obtained with full-length 16S sequences to be correct. Top 20 combinations in terms of average classification accuracy have been depicted. Combinations of contiguous V-regions have been marked with an asterisk (*).