Skip to main content
. 2019 Jul 23;2019(7):CD001871. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD001871.pub4
Study Reason for exclusion
Adab 2014 Not an RCT
Al‐Nakeeb 2007 Longitudinal cohort study ‐ no intervention
Alexander 2014 Not an RCT
Almas 2013 Not an RCT
Alves 2008 Intervention designed for the treatment of childhood obesity
Annesi 2015 Age/aim/duration/outcome
Anzman‐Frasca 2013 Age/aim/duration/outcome
Ara 2006 Longitudinal cohort study ‐ no intervention
Arbeit 1992 Aim of the trial was to prevent CVD
Ask 2006 Cluster allocation with < 6 groups
Ask 2010 Not an RCT
Bacardi‐Gascon 2012 Not an RCT
Balas‐Nakash 2010 Not an RCT
Baranowski 2012 Age/aim/duration/outcome
Beard 2012 Age/aim/duration/outcome
Bellows 2013b Not an RCT
Bergh 2012a Age/aim/duration/outcome
Bergh 2012b Age/aim/duration/outcome
Berry 2007 Parent‐targeted intervention designed specifically for the treatment of obesity
Berry 2011 Not an RCT
Berry 2014 Age/aim/duration/outcome
Bilic‐Kirin 2013 Not an RCT
Birch 2012 Age/aim/duration/outcome
Bjelland 2015 Age/aim/duration/outcome
Bollela 1999a Aim of the trial was to improve nutritional intake
Bollela 1999b Aim of the trial was to improve nutritional intake
Borys 2000 Aim was to improve dietary habits of families
Briganti 2014 Not an RCT
Bruss 2010 Not an RCT
Buchan 2010 Age/aim/duration/outcome
Burguera 2011 Age/aim/duration/outcome
Burke 1998 Aim was to improve PA
Buscemi 2015 Age/aim/duration/outcome
Cairella 1998 Aim was to improve nutritional intake
Cameron 2014 Age/aim/duration/outcome
Campbell 2014 Age/aim/duration/outcome
Carrel 2005 Intervention recruited only overweight or obese participants so considered treatment for the purposes of this review
Casazza 2006 Intervention was < 12 weeks
Centis 2012 Not an RCT
Chomitz 2003 Aim was to increase parent awareness of child weight status
Copeland 2010 Age/aim/duration/outcome
Cordova 2012 Not an RCT
Cruz 2014 Age/aim/duration/outcome
Cullen 1996 Aim of the trial was to prevent children's behaviour disorders
D'Agostino 1999 Aim of the trial was to improve nutritional intake
da Silva 2013 Age/aim/duration/outcome
Daley 2006 Intervention designed specifically for the treatment of obesity
Daniels 2014 Age/aim/duration/outcome
Danielzik 2005 Intervention was < 12 weeks
Davis 2011 Not an RCT
De Bock 2010 Age/aim/duration/outcome
De Ruyter 2013 Age/aim/duration/outcome
de Silva‐Sanigorski 2010a Not an RCT ‐ tier 2
de Silva‐Sanigorski 2010b Not an RCT ‐ tier 2
de Silva‐Sanigorski 2010c Not an RCT ‐ tier 2
de Silva‐Sanigorski 2012 Not an RCT ‐ tier 2
DeBar 2011 Age/aim/duration/outcome
Della 2013 Not an RCT
Dixon 2000 Aim of the trial was to improve nutritional intake
Donnelly 1996 Cluster allocation with < 6 groups
Donnelly 2011 Age/aim/duration/outcome
Donnelly 2013 Age/aim/duration/outcome
Dzewaltowski 2010 Age/aim/duration/outcome
Economos 2007 Cluster allocation with < 6 groups
Economos 2013 Not an RCT ‐ tier 2
Ehlert 2010 Age/aim/duration/outcome
Elinder 2012 Not an RCT
Eskicioglu 2014 Not an RCT
Evans 2012 Age/aim/duration/outcome
Fitzgibbon 2013 Not an RCT
Flattum 2011 Age/aim/duration/outcome
Flodmark 1993 Intervention designed specifically for the treatment of obesity
Florea 2005 Intervention designed specifically for the treatment of obesity
Flores 1995 Cluster allocation with < 6 groups
Fonseca 2007 Comparative study‐No intervention
Fotu 2011 Not an RCT ‐ tier 2
Francis 2010 Age/aim/duration/outcome
French 2012 Not an RCT
Frenn 2013 Not an RCT
Gabriele 2010 Age/aim/duration/outcome
Gao 2013 Age/aim/duration/outcome
Gately 2005 Intervention duration < 12 weeks
Gatti 2015 Not an RCT
Gatto 2015 Not an RCT
Gesell 2012 Age/aim/duration/outcome
Goldfield 2006 Intervention duration < 12 weeks
Goldfield 2007 Intervention duration was < 12 weeks
Graf 2011 Not an RCT
Greening 2011 Not an RCT
Hakanen 2010 Age/aim/duration/outcome
Hardy 2010 Age/aim/duration/outcome
Harrell 1998 Intervention < 12 weeks duration
Harrell 1999 Intervention < 12 weeks duration
Hartmann 2010 Age/aim/duration/outcome
Hatzis 2010 Not an RCT ‐ tier 2
Hauner 2012 Age/aim/duration/outcome
Hawthorne 2011 Age/aim/duration/outcome
He 2004 Intervention designed specifically for the treatment of obesity
Hernandez 2014 Age/aim/duration/outcome
Herrick 2012 Not an RCT
Hoelscher 2010 Not an RCT
Hoffman 2011 Not an RCT
Hollar 2010 Not an RCT
Hollar 2010a Not an RCT
Hollar 2010b Not an RCT
Hollywood 2013 Not an RCT
Hopper 1996 Aim of the trial was to prevent CVD
Horodynski 2004 Aim of the trial was to improve nutritional intake
Howard 1996 Aim of the trial was to prevent CVD
Huang 2012 Age/aim/duration/outcome
Huberty 2011 Age/aim/duration/outcome
Ildiko 2007 Intervention designed specifically for the treatment of obesity
Jago 2006 Intervention duration < 12 weeks
Jago 2011 Age/aim/duration/outcome
Jensen 2013a Age/aim/duration/outcome
Jensen 2013b Age/aim/duration/outcome
Jiang 2007 Cluster allocation with < 6 groups
Johnson 2012 Age/aim/duration/outcome
Johnston 2012 Age/aim/duration/outcome
Jurg 2006 Study did not report to be measuring any of the primary outcomes of the review
Karanja 2010 Not an RCT
Karanja 2012 Not an RCT ‐ tier 2
Karp 2014 Age/aim/duration/outcome
Katz 2010 Not an RCT
Katz 2011 Not an RCT
Kesztyus 2013 Age/aim/duration/outcome
Kilanowski 2010 Age/aim/duration/outcome
Kim 2014 Age/aim/duration/outcome
King 2014 Age/aim/duration/outcome
Klakk 2013 Not an RCT
Klish 2012 Not an RCT
Koblinsky 1992 Aim of the trial was to improve nutritional intake
Kremer 2011 Not an RCT ‐ tier 2
Krombholz 2012 Not an RCT
LaBresh 2014 Age/aim/duration/outcome
Lachausse 2012 Age/aim/duration/outcome
Lagstrom 1997 Aim of the trial was to improve nutritional intake
Lakes 2013 Not an RCT
Lambourne 2013 Age/aim/duration/outcome
Lazorick 2014 Age/aim/duration/outcome
LeMaster 2011 Age/aim/duration/outcome
Li 2010b Age/aim/duration/outcome
Lin 2012 Not an RCT
Lionis 1991 Aim of the trial was to assess the effects of a health education intervention aimed at reducing risk for CVD and cancer
Llaurado 2014 Not an RCT ‐ tier 2
Lloyd 2012 Not an RCT
Louzada 2012 Age/aim/duration/outcome
Lubans 2012b Age/aim/duration/outcome
Luepker 1996 Aim of the trial was to prevent CVD
Lumeng 2015 Age/aim/duration/outcome
Lynch 2012 Not an RCT ‐ tier 2
Lytle 2006 Aim of the trial was to improve nutritional intake
Maggiulli 2015 Not an RCT
Mailey 2012 Age/aim/duration/outcome
Manger 2012 Not an RCT
Manios 1998 Aim of the trial was to improve PA and fitness
Manios 1999 Aim of the trial was to improve nutritional intake
Martinez‐Andrade 2014 Age/aim/duration/outcome
Matvienko 2010 Not an RCT
McAuley 2010 Not an RCT ‐ tier 2
McCallum 2007 Intervention designed specifically for the treatment of obesity
McGarvey 2004 Intervention duration < 12 weeks
McMurray 2002 Intervention < 12 weeks duration
Melnyk 2007 Intervention was < 12 weeks
Millar 2011 Not an RCT ‐ tier 2
Mistry 2011 Not an RCT
Moodie 2010a Age/aim/duration/outcome
Moodie 2010b Age/aim/duration/outcome
Moodie 2013 Not an RCT ‐ tier 2
Morgan 2012 Age/aim/duration/outcome
Muckelbauer 2011 Age/aim/duration/outcome
Mustila 2012a Not an RCT
Mustila 2012b Not an RCT
Mustila 2012c Not an RCT
Mustila 2013 Not an RCT
Navarro 2013 Not an RCT ‐ tier 2
Nichols 2014 Age/aim/duration/outcome
Niinikoski 1997 Aim was to improve nutritional intake
Nogueira 2014 Age/aim/duration/outcome
Obarzanek 1997 Aim of the trial was to improve nutritional intake
Oehrig 2001 Aim of trial was to improve cardiovascular risk factors
Padilla 2012 Not an RCT
Pettman 2014 Not an RCT ‐ tier 2
Plachta‐Danielzik 2011 Age/aim/duration/outcome
Pope 2013 Age/aim/duration/outcome
Pratt 2013 Age/aim/duration/outcome
Prins 2012 Age/aim/duration/outcome
Puma 2013 Age/aim/duration/outcome
Quarles 2011 Age/aim/duration/outcome
Rask‐Nissila 2000 Aim of trial was to examine neurological development
Rawlins 2013 Age/aim/duration/outcome
Reed 2013 Age/aim/duration/outcome
Reinehr 2007 Intervention designed specifically for the treatment of obesity
Resaland 2014 Not an RCT
Resnicow 2005 Intervention designed specifically for the treatment of obesity
Richmond 2013 Not an RCT
Robinson 1999 Cluster allocation with < 6 groups
Ronsley 2013 Age/aim/duration/outcome
Roofe 2010 Not an RCT
Roofe 2011 Age/aim/duration/outcome
Rueda 2013 Age/aim/duration/outcome
Rush 2014 Age/aim/duration/outcome
Rush 2014a Age/aim/duration/outcome
Sadowsky 1999 Intervention duration < 12 weeks
Sanders 2014 Not an RCT ‐ tier 2
Schuna 2013 Age/aim/duration/outcome
Sherwood 2013a Age/aim/duration/outcome
Shofan 2011 Not an RCT
Sigmund 2012 Not an RCT
Sigmund 2013 Not an RCT
Simonetti 1986 This trial was conducted before 1990 and so was excluded from this review
Singhal 2010 Not an RCT
Singhal 2011 Age/aim/duration/outcome
Slusser 2013 Not an RCT
Smith 2012 Not an RCT ‐ tier 2
Spark 1998 Aim of the trial was to improve nutritional intake
Spencer 2012 Not an RCT
Spieker 2015 Age/aim/duration/outcome
Springer 2013 Age/aim/duration/outcome
Stenevi‐Lundgren 2009 Aim of the trial was to improve bone health outcomes
Stephens 1998 Aim of the trial was to improve fitness levels
Stewart 1995 Aim was to improve nutritional intake
Stice 2015 Age/aim/duration/outcome
Stock 2007 Cluster allocation with < 6 groups
Strauss 2011 Age/aim/duration/outcome
Swinburn 2011 Age/aim/duration/outcome
Talvia 2004 Aim of trial was to improve nutritional intake.
Tamir 1990 Aim of the trial was to prevent CVD
Tarro 2014a Not an RCT ‐ tier 2
Tarro 2014b Not an RCT ‐ tier 2
Taveras 2011 Not an RCT
Taylor 2005 Intervention duration < 12 weeks
Telford 2013a Age/aim/duration/outcome
Telford 2013b Age/aim/duration/outcome
Tershakovec 1998 Trial conducted in hypercholesterolaemic children
Toftager 2014 Age/aim/duration/outcome
Toruner 2010 Age/aim/duration/outcome
Toruner 2015 Not an RCT
Treuth 2007 Cross‐sectional study design. Not evaluating the intervention
Trudeau 2000 This was not an intervention study
Tucker 2011 Not an RCT
Utter 2011 Not an RCT ‐ tier 2
Van Ryzin 2013 Age/aim/duration/outcome
Vandongen 1995 Aim of the trial was to prevent CVD
Wake 2011 Age/aim/duration/outcome
Wallen 2010 Age/aim/duration/outcome
Wang 2011 Age/aim/duration/outcome
Weber 2014 Age/aim/duration/outcome
Willi 2012 Age/aim/duration/outcome
Williams 1998 Aim of the trial was to prevent CVD
Williams 2011 Age/aim/duration/outcome
Williamson 2006 Intervention recruited only overweight or obese participants so considered treatment for the purposes of this review
Williamson 2007 Cluster allocation with < 6 groups
Wilson 2010 Age/aim/duration/outcome
Winter 2011 Not an RCT
Wright 2012 Age/aim/duration/outcome
Wright 2014a Age/aim/duration/outcome
Wright 2014b Age/aim/duration/outcome
Yang 2014 Age/aim/duration/outcome
Yildirim 2013 Age/aim/duration/outcome
Yin 2012 Not an RCT
Zanirati 2011 Not an RCT
Zhou 2014 Not an RCT

CVD: cardiovascular disease; PA: physical activity; RCT: randomised controlled trial