Study | Reason for exclusion |
---|---|
Adab 2014 | Not an RCT |
Al‐Nakeeb 2007 | Longitudinal cohort study ‐ no intervention |
Alexander 2014 | Not an RCT |
Almas 2013 | Not an RCT |
Alves 2008 | Intervention designed for the treatment of childhood obesity |
Annesi 2015 | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
Anzman‐Frasca 2013 | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
Ara 2006 | Longitudinal cohort study ‐ no intervention |
Arbeit 1992 | Aim of the trial was to prevent CVD |
Ask 2006 | Cluster allocation with < 6 groups |
Ask 2010 | Not an RCT |
Bacardi‐Gascon 2012 | Not an RCT |
Balas‐Nakash 2010 | Not an RCT |
Baranowski 2012 | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
Beard 2012 | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
Bellows 2013b | Not an RCT |
Bergh 2012a | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
Bergh 2012b | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
Berry 2007 | Parent‐targeted intervention designed specifically for the treatment of obesity |
Berry 2011 | Not an RCT |
Berry 2014 | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
Bilic‐Kirin 2013 | Not an RCT |
Birch 2012 | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
Bjelland 2015 | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
Bollela 1999a | Aim of the trial was to improve nutritional intake |
Bollela 1999b | Aim of the trial was to improve nutritional intake |
Borys 2000 | Aim was to improve dietary habits of families |
Briganti 2014 | Not an RCT |
Bruss 2010 | Not an RCT |
Buchan 2010 | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
Burguera 2011 | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
Burke 1998 | Aim was to improve PA |
Buscemi 2015 | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
Cairella 1998 | Aim was to improve nutritional intake |
Cameron 2014 | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
Campbell 2014 | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
Carrel 2005 | Intervention recruited only overweight or obese participants so considered treatment for the purposes of this review |
Casazza 2006 | Intervention was < 12 weeks |
Centis 2012 | Not an RCT |
Chomitz 2003 | Aim was to increase parent awareness of child weight status |
Copeland 2010 | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
Cordova 2012 | Not an RCT |
Cruz 2014 | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
Cullen 1996 | Aim of the trial was to prevent children's behaviour disorders |
D'Agostino 1999 | Aim of the trial was to improve nutritional intake |
da Silva 2013 | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
Daley 2006 | Intervention designed specifically for the treatment of obesity |
Daniels 2014 | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
Danielzik 2005 | Intervention was < 12 weeks |
Davis 2011 | Not an RCT |
De Bock 2010 | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
De Ruyter 2013 | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
de Silva‐Sanigorski 2010a | Not an RCT ‐ tier 2 |
de Silva‐Sanigorski 2010b | Not an RCT ‐ tier 2 |
de Silva‐Sanigorski 2010c | Not an RCT ‐ tier 2 |
de Silva‐Sanigorski 2012 | Not an RCT ‐ tier 2 |
DeBar 2011 | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
Della 2013 | Not an RCT |
Dixon 2000 | Aim of the trial was to improve nutritional intake |
Donnelly 1996 | Cluster allocation with < 6 groups |
Donnelly 2011 | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
Donnelly 2013 | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
Dzewaltowski 2010 | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
Economos 2007 | Cluster allocation with < 6 groups |
Economos 2013 | Not an RCT ‐ tier 2 |
Ehlert 2010 | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
Elinder 2012 | Not an RCT |
Eskicioglu 2014 | Not an RCT |
Evans 2012 | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
Fitzgibbon 2013 | Not an RCT |
Flattum 2011 | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
Flodmark 1993 | Intervention designed specifically for the treatment of obesity |
Florea 2005 | Intervention designed specifically for the treatment of obesity |
Flores 1995 | Cluster allocation with < 6 groups |
Fonseca 2007 | Comparative study‐No intervention |
Fotu 2011 | Not an RCT ‐ tier 2 |
Francis 2010 | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
French 2012 | Not an RCT |
Frenn 2013 | Not an RCT |
Gabriele 2010 | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
Gao 2013 | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
Gately 2005 | Intervention duration < 12 weeks |
Gatti 2015 | Not an RCT |
Gatto 2015 | Not an RCT |
Gesell 2012 | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
Goldfield 2006 | Intervention duration < 12 weeks |
Goldfield 2007 | Intervention duration was < 12 weeks |
Graf 2011 | Not an RCT |
Greening 2011 | Not an RCT |
Hakanen 2010 | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
Hardy 2010 | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
Harrell 1998 | Intervention < 12 weeks duration |
Harrell 1999 | Intervention < 12 weeks duration |
Hartmann 2010 | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
Hatzis 2010 | Not an RCT ‐ tier 2 |
Hauner 2012 | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
Hawthorne 2011 | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
He 2004 | Intervention designed specifically for the treatment of obesity |
Hernandez 2014 | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
Herrick 2012 | Not an RCT |
Hoelscher 2010 | Not an RCT |
Hoffman 2011 | Not an RCT |
Hollar 2010 | Not an RCT |
Hollar 2010a | Not an RCT |
Hollar 2010b | Not an RCT |
Hollywood 2013 | Not an RCT |
Hopper 1996 | Aim of the trial was to prevent CVD |
Horodynski 2004 | Aim of the trial was to improve nutritional intake |
Howard 1996 | Aim of the trial was to prevent CVD |
Huang 2012 | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
Huberty 2011 | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
Ildiko 2007 | Intervention designed specifically for the treatment of obesity |
Jago 2006 | Intervention duration < 12 weeks |
Jago 2011 | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
Jensen 2013a | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
Jensen 2013b | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
Jiang 2007 | Cluster allocation with < 6 groups |
Johnson 2012 | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
Johnston 2012 | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
Jurg 2006 | Study did not report to be measuring any of the primary outcomes of the review |
Karanja 2010 | Not an RCT |
Karanja 2012 | Not an RCT ‐ tier 2 |
Karp 2014 | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
Katz 2010 | Not an RCT |
Katz 2011 | Not an RCT |
Kesztyus 2013 | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
Kilanowski 2010 | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
Kim 2014 | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
King 2014 | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
Klakk 2013 | Not an RCT |
Klish 2012 | Not an RCT |
Koblinsky 1992 | Aim of the trial was to improve nutritional intake |
Kremer 2011 | Not an RCT ‐ tier 2 |
Krombholz 2012 | Not an RCT |
LaBresh 2014 | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
Lachausse 2012 | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
Lagstrom 1997 | Aim of the trial was to improve nutritional intake |
Lakes 2013 | Not an RCT |
Lambourne 2013 | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
Lazorick 2014 | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
LeMaster 2011 | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
Li 2010b | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
Lin 2012 | Not an RCT |
Lionis 1991 | Aim of the trial was to assess the effects of a health education intervention aimed at reducing risk for CVD and cancer |
Llaurado 2014 | Not an RCT ‐ tier 2 |
Lloyd 2012 | Not an RCT |
Louzada 2012 | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
Lubans 2012b | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
Luepker 1996 | Aim of the trial was to prevent CVD |
Lumeng 2015 | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
Lynch 2012 | Not an RCT ‐ tier 2 |
Lytle 2006 | Aim of the trial was to improve nutritional intake |
Maggiulli 2015 | Not an RCT |
Mailey 2012 | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
Manger 2012 | Not an RCT |
Manios 1998 | Aim of the trial was to improve PA and fitness |
Manios 1999 | Aim of the trial was to improve nutritional intake |
Martinez‐Andrade 2014 | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
Matvienko 2010 | Not an RCT |
McAuley 2010 | Not an RCT ‐ tier 2 |
McCallum 2007 | Intervention designed specifically for the treatment of obesity |
McGarvey 2004 | Intervention duration < 12 weeks |
McMurray 2002 | Intervention < 12 weeks duration |
Melnyk 2007 | Intervention was < 12 weeks |
Millar 2011 | Not an RCT ‐ tier 2 |
Mistry 2011 | Not an RCT |
Moodie 2010a | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
Moodie 2010b | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
Moodie 2013 | Not an RCT ‐ tier 2 |
Morgan 2012 | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
Muckelbauer 2011 | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
Mustila 2012a | Not an RCT |
Mustila 2012b | Not an RCT |
Mustila 2012c | Not an RCT |
Mustila 2013 | Not an RCT |
Navarro 2013 | Not an RCT ‐ tier 2 |
Nichols 2014 | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
Niinikoski 1997 | Aim was to improve nutritional intake |
Nogueira 2014 | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
Obarzanek 1997 | Aim of the trial was to improve nutritional intake |
Oehrig 2001 | Aim of trial was to improve cardiovascular risk factors |
Padilla 2012 | Not an RCT |
Pettman 2014 | Not an RCT ‐ tier 2 |
Plachta‐Danielzik 2011 | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
Pope 2013 | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
Pratt 2013 | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
Prins 2012 | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
Puma 2013 | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
Quarles 2011 | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
Rask‐Nissila 2000 | Aim of trial was to examine neurological development |
Rawlins 2013 | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
Reed 2013 | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
Reinehr 2007 | Intervention designed specifically for the treatment of obesity |
Resaland 2014 | Not an RCT |
Resnicow 2005 | Intervention designed specifically for the treatment of obesity |
Richmond 2013 | Not an RCT |
Robinson 1999 | Cluster allocation with < 6 groups |
Ronsley 2013 | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
Roofe 2010 | Not an RCT |
Roofe 2011 | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
Rueda 2013 | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
Rush 2014 | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
Rush 2014a | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
Sadowsky 1999 | Intervention duration < 12 weeks |
Sanders 2014 | Not an RCT ‐ tier 2 |
Schuna 2013 | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
Sherwood 2013a | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
Shofan 2011 | Not an RCT |
Sigmund 2012 | Not an RCT |
Sigmund 2013 | Not an RCT |
Simonetti 1986 | This trial was conducted before 1990 and so was excluded from this review |
Singhal 2010 | Not an RCT |
Singhal 2011 | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
Slusser 2013 | Not an RCT |
Smith 2012 | Not an RCT ‐ tier 2 |
Spark 1998 | Aim of the trial was to improve nutritional intake |
Spencer 2012 | Not an RCT |
Spieker 2015 | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
Springer 2013 | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
Stenevi‐Lundgren 2009 | Aim of the trial was to improve bone health outcomes |
Stephens 1998 | Aim of the trial was to improve fitness levels |
Stewart 1995 | Aim was to improve nutritional intake |
Stice 2015 | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
Stock 2007 | Cluster allocation with < 6 groups |
Strauss 2011 | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
Swinburn 2011 | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
Talvia 2004 | Aim of trial was to improve nutritional intake. |
Tamir 1990 | Aim of the trial was to prevent CVD |
Tarro 2014a | Not an RCT ‐ tier 2 |
Tarro 2014b | Not an RCT ‐ tier 2 |
Taveras 2011 | Not an RCT |
Taylor 2005 | Intervention duration < 12 weeks |
Telford 2013a | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
Telford 2013b | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
Tershakovec 1998 | Trial conducted in hypercholesterolaemic children |
Toftager 2014 | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
Toruner 2010 | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
Toruner 2015 | Not an RCT |
Treuth 2007 | Cross‐sectional study design. Not evaluating the intervention |
Trudeau 2000 | This was not an intervention study |
Tucker 2011 | Not an RCT |
Utter 2011 | Not an RCT ‐ tier 2 |
Van Ryzin 2013 | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
Vandongen 1995 | Aim of the trial was to prevent CVD |
Wake 2011 | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
Wallen 2010 | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
Wang 2011 | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
Weber 2014 | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
Willi 2012 | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
Williams 1998 | Aim of the trial was to prevent CVD |
Williams 2011 | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
Williamson 2006 | Intervention recruited only overweight or obese participants so considered treatment for the purposes of this review |
Williamson 2007 | Cluster allocation with < 6 groups |
Wilson 2010 | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
Winter 2011 | Not an RCT |
Wright 2012 | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
Wright 2014a | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
Wright 2014b | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
Yang 2014 | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
Yildirim 2013 | Age/aim/duration/outcome |
Yin 2012 | Not an RCT |
Zanirati 2011 | Not an RCT |
Zhou 2014 | Not an RCT |
CVD: cardiovascular disease; PA: physical activity; RCT: randomised controlled trial