Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2019 Jul 24.
Published in final edited form as: Proceedings (IEEE Int Conf Bioinformatics Biomed). 2019 Jan 24;2018:1209–1214. doi: 10.1109/BIBM.2018.8621107

Table II:

comparison of AUC scores between DGCs and the corresponding baselines on ChestX-ray14 dataset. The better results based on the same encoder are bolded. The best results among all the models are colored red.

Diseases AN G-AN RN50 G-RN50 DN201 G-DN201 DN121 G-DN121 DN161 G-DN161 VN16 G-VN16
Atelectasis 0.7327 0.7359 0.7407 0.7418 0.7426 0.7415 0.7391 0.7378 0.7433 0.7421 0.7488 0.7495
Cardiomegaly 0.8681 0.8699 0.8553 0.8623 0.8541 0.8606 0.8483 0.8517 0.8662 0.8653 0.8700 0.8687
Effusion 0.7874 0.7896 0.7984 0.7991 0.7987 0.7997 0.7982 0.7976 0.8026 0.8052 0.8075 0.8096
Infiltration 0.6725 0.6771 0.6798 0.6773 0.6756 0.6790 0.6775 0.6792 0.6751 0.6773 0.6894 0.6869
Mass 0.7340 0.7374 0.7480 0.7502 0.7567 0.7614 0.7495 0.7538 0.7628 0.7652 0.7756 0.7820
Nodule 0.6778 0.6795 0.6962 0.6934 0.7107 0.7118 0.7032 0.7029 0.7142 0.7188 0.7248 0.7255
Pneumonia 0.6632 0.6744 0.6877 0.6868 0.6861 0.6917 0.6878 0.6858 0.6939 0.7020 0.6943 0.6954
Pneumothorax 0.8149 0.8195 0.8364 0.8405 0.8371 0.8396 0.8356 0.8405 0.8437 0.8497 0.8441 0.8451
Consolidation 0.7088 0.7105 0.7112 0.7136 0.7129 0.7177 0.7124 0.7167 0.7174 0.7190 0.7259 0.7283
Edema 0.8280 0.8311 0.8273 0.8311 0.8294 0.8302 0.8287 0.8280 0.8355 0.8368 0.8363 0.8340
Emphysema 0.7991 0.8059 0.8659 0.8724 0.8704 0.8668 0.8579 0.8590 0.8793 0.8823 0.8707 0.8699
Fibrosis 0.7956 0.7977 0.7939 0.7885 0.7982 0.8036 0.7873 0.7905 0.7972 0.8103 0.7979 0.7978
PT* 0.7356 0.7373 0.7379 0.7424 0.7424 0.7432 0.7465 0.7457 0.7451 0.7510 0.7554 0.7581
Hernia 0.8485 0.8498 0.8879 0.8816 0.8974 0.9113 0.8951 0.8898 0.9097 0.9015 0.8837 0.8776
Average 0.7619 0.7654 0.7762 0.7772 0.7794 0.7827 0.7762 0.7771 0.7847 0.7876 0.7875 0.7877
*

PT — Pleural Thickening; AN — AlexNet; VN16 — VGGNet16; RN50 — ResNet50; DN121 — DenseNet121; DN161 — DenseNet161; DN201— DenseNet201; G-AN — DGC-AlexNet; G-VN16 — DGC-VGGNet16; G-RN50 — DGC-ResNet50; G-DN121 — DGC-DenseNet121; G-DN161 — DGC-DenseNet161; G-DN201 — DGC-DenseNet201.