Table 3.
Incorporating Clinical Outcome Assessment (COA) Measures in Clinical Trials: Impact of Patient-Reported Outcome (PRO) Measures on Study Findings and Implications (Examples)
| Study Authors, YearRef | Type of Cancer | Drug/Treatment/Intervention | PROs Endpoint | Impact on Objective Measure | Impact on COAs and Broader Aspects | Overall Effect | Conclusions/Implications |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Tannock et al, 199620 | Prostate cancer | Adjuvant mitoxantrone with prednisolone | PE | – | Improve in pain | + | FDA approval for advanced hormone-refractory prostate cancer |
| LATITUDE trial (Fizazi et al, 2017)22 |
Prostate cancer | Abiraterone acetate | EE | Increased OS | Improvement in HRQoL | + | FDA approval for high-risk castration- sensitive prostate cancer |
| Verstovsek et al, 201222 | Myelo-fibrosis | Ruxolitinib | SE | Reduction of spleen volume | Reduction in symptoms burden | + | Approval of ruxolitinib for treatment of myelofibrosis |
| Thornton et al, 200814 | Breast cancer | Taxanes in adjuvant chemotherapy regimen | PE | – | Worse mental health outcome and double emotional recovery time | – | Monitoring depression in patients receiving taxanes |
| RTOG 0525 substudy (Armstrong et al, 2013)15 | Brain tumor (GBM) | Dose-dense temozolomide treatment associated with radiotherapy | EE | No change in survival | Greater symptom burden | – | Standard dose of temozolomide |
| RTOG 0933 (Gondi et al, 2014)17 | Brain metastases | HA-WBRT | SEa | – | Memory preservation and improved QoL | + | Evidence supporting HA-WBRT |
| EORTC-NCIC trial (Stupp et al, 2009)23 | Brain tumor (GBM) | Adjuvant temozolomide with radiotherapy | SE | Increased survival | No change in QoL | + | Change in standard of care |
Abbreviations: EE, exploratory endpoint; EORTC-NCIC, European Organisation for Research and Treatment of Cancer-National Cancer Institute of Canada; GBM, glioblastoma; HA-WBRT, hippocampal-sparing whole-brain radiotherapy; HRQoL, health-related quality of life; PE, primary endpoint; QoL, quality of life; Ref, reference; SE, secondary endpoint; WBRT, whole-brain radiotherapy.
aWith performance outcome (PerfO: neurocognitive testing) as PE.