Skip to main content
. 2019 Jul 24;19:150. doi: 10.1186/s12862-019-1483-3

Table 2.

Ranking and statistical analyses of reference genes in oral and pharyngeal jaws across all of the haplochromine species from three East African lakes

Oral jaw Pharyngeal jaw
BestKeeper geNorm NormFinder BestKeeper geNorm NormFinder
Ranks SD Ranks M Ranks SV Ranks SD Ranks M Ranks SV
1 rpl18 0.581 ssrp1 0.605 rpl18 0.272 rpl18 0.654 abcf1 0.619 rpl18 0.321
2 tmem59 0.639 rpl18 0.615 ube2l3 0.324 tmem59 0.813 rpl18 0.631 ube2l3 0.322
3 pdia6 0.640 abcf1 0.632 abcf1 0.376 actb1 0.984 ube2l3 0.633 ssrp1 0.331
4 ube2l3 0.649 pdia6 0.678 pdia6 0.398 twf1 1.016 actb1 0.672 actb1 0.412
5 actb1 0.663 twf1 0.683 twf1 0.424 rps18 1.026 pdia6 0.710 pdia6 0.442
6 twf1 0.688 rps18 0.687 actb1 0.448 pdia6 1.101 rps18 0.717 abce1 0.472
7 ssrp1 0.695 actb1 0.691 rps18 0.467 ssrp1 1.106 twf1 0.755 twf1 0.477
8 rps18 0.700 abce1 0.767 ssrp1 0.478 abcf1 1.106 ssrp1 0.764 abcf1 0.480
9 abcf1 0.717 ube2l3 0.773 abce1 0.513 ube2l3 1.150 abce1 0.769 rps18 0.517
10 abce1 0.720 tmem59 0.806 tmem59 0.587 abce1 1.151 tmem59 0.785 tmem59 0.577
11 tbp 1.031 tbp 0.900 tbp 0.639 tbp 1.328 tbp 0.896 tbp 0.665
12 elf1a 1.717 elf1a 1.579 elf1a 1.324 elf1a 2.162 elf1a 1.558 elf1a 1.257

SD indicates a ranking calculation based on standard deviation generated by BestKeeper, whereas SV, stability value, and M, mean expression stability value, are calculated by geNorm and NormFinder, respectively. In all of the ranking methods lower values represent more stably expressed reference genes