Skip to main content
. 2019 May 20;10(28):6748–6769. doi: 10.1039/c9sc01184f

Table 1. Photovoltaic performance of the perovskite devices employed with the best performing doped small molecule-based HTMs sorted by PCE of the champion device.

ID J sc (mA cm–2) V oc (V) FF PCE (%) Ref. PCE a (%) Lit. ref.
KR216 22.3 1.023 0.77 17.8 18.4 108
V950 22.5 1.07 0.74 17.8 18.6 120
LD29 22.02 1.11 0.75 18.04 18.25 129
PPyra-TXA d 20.6 1.10 0.797 18.06 16.15 99
TTPA-DBQT 22.23 1.09 0.744 18.08 17.96 148
TTPA-BDT 23.0 1.07 0.736 18.1 17.7 145
ATT-OMe 21.75 1.07 0.781 18.13 17.80 146
H16 23.28 1.108 0.704 18.16 18.27 131
BTT-5 22.50 1.10 0.733 18.17 18.9 143
BTF-1 21.31 1.106 0.772 18.2 18.0 144
BTT-3 21.9 1.065 0.767 18.2 18.1 142
dly-2 23.24 1.039 0.755 18.23 19.59 115
V1050 d 22.0 1.05 0.795 18.3 18.9 119
KR131 20.7 1.145 0.77 18.3 17.9 122
CZ-TA d 21.66 1.044 0.81 18.32 18.28 125
HL-2 21.30 1.09 0.79 18.34 18.77 126
V885 22.09 1.107 0.757 18.45 18.79 118
Dispiro-OBuTAD d 22.79 1.08 0.75 18.46 17.82 104
F33 d 21.01 1.11 0.79 18.48 16.26 114
EH44 e 21.71 1.091 0.779 18.5 19.6 128
BTSe-1 21.88 1.065 0.795 18.5 18.0 144
JY6 d 21.39 1.066 0.81 18.54 16.24 113
Spiro-I 24.67 1.06 0.71 18.57 19.17 102
V1056 22.1 1.07 0.79 18.7 20.2 121
TTA3 22.18 1.153 0.733 18.76 18.77 147
NDT d 23.47 1.11 0.74 18.78 18.05 130
CuPc 22.6 1.07 0.775 18.8 20.5 141
PZn-2FTPA d 22.21 1.125 0.754 18.85 19.23 139
V911 22.4 1.103 0.763 18.86 18.79 118
SGT-405 22.93 1.046 0.786 18.87 17.71 111
X36 23.7 1.06 0.76 18.9 18.34 100
V885 22.43 1.104 0.764 18.92 18.79 118
BTT-4 23.04 1.090 0.753 18.97 18.9 143
Si-OMeTPA b 23.08 1.07 0.771 19.06 17.47 107
Z30 23.53 1.114 0.73 19.17 19.66 134
KR374 23.15 1.092 0.762 19.26 19.54 110
Py-OMe 22.82 1.11 0.761 19.28 18.57 116
POZ10 23.1 1.1 0.762 19.4 19.7 136
AZ2 22.94 1.14 0.746 19.4 19.1 132
DDOF 22.37 1.101 0.79 19.4 18.8 105
WT3 22.6 1.095 0.785 19.44 18.62 140
V859 23.3 1.120 0.75 19.47 18.25 137
HTM-FX d 19.5 20.4 94
XPP c , d 23.18 1.12 0.75 19.5 16.5 97
P1 23.184 1.118 0.761 19.8 19.9 138
H11 24.2 1.150 0.71 19.8 18.9 109
X59 23.4 1.13 0.73 19.8 20.8 96
IDIDF 23.6 1.06 0.792 19.8 16.8 124
X60 24.2 1.14 0.71 19.84 93
V862 22.5 1.139 0.77 19.96 18.25 137
Z26 23.59 1.132 0.75 20.1 20.6 133
SCZF-5 d 24.40 1.11 0.74 20.1 19.11 103
V1091 d 22.5 1.11 0.81 20.2 20.2 121
FDT 22.7 1.148 0.76 20.2 19.7 98
G2 d 23.52 1.13 0.76 20.2 19.25 106
X26 24.3 1.11 0.75 20.2 18.34 100
EDOT-Amide-TPA d 22.7 1.16 0.77 20.3 19.7 135
TAT-tBuSty d 22.1 1.15 0.8 20.3 20.3 123
OMe-TATPyr d 23.3 1.10 0.806 20.6 18.4 117
HTM-FX' d 20.8 20.4 94
X55 23.4 1.15 0.77 20.8 18.8 101
DM 24.91 1.144 0.812 23.2 21.3 95

aSpiro-OMeTAD or PTAA was used as the reference in most of the cases.

bp–i–n device architecture.

c tBP-free composition.

dPlanar device architecture.

eLiTFSI-free composition.