Table 1.
Authors | Subjects | Study settings | Sampling type | Assessment tools | Methodology | Major findings |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
King and Bhugra, 1989 Yamuna Nagar[13] | 574 school girls aged between 14-23 years | Two schools and two colleges | Quota sampling | Hindi version of EAT-26 | Abnormal eating attitude and behavior was assessed by a score of more than 20 on EAT-26 | About 29% (n=167) had disordered eating or probable eating disorder |
Srinivasan et al., 1995 Chennai[14] | Medical students Step1: 602 Step 2: 210 | Medical college | Convenient sampling | EAT-40 BITE DSM-III criteria | Two step procedure Step 1: Screening of probable cases. They were defined as : Scoring >30 on 40-item EAT Scoring >10 on 33-item BITE Step 2: Clinical assessment and diagnosis of eating disorder as per DSM-III in all probable subjects as well as 1/3 of screen negative subjects selected by random sampling |
About 28 students had scored more than cut offs as per EAT or BITE in Step 1 None of the subjects had syndromal eating disorder diagnosis on clinical evaluation About 14.8% subjects (n=31) could be diagnosed with syndrome of EDS, subsyndromal eating disorder |
Srinivasan et al., 1998 Chennai[15] | Medical students Step1: 210 Step 2: 146 |
Medical college | Convenient sampling | SQ-EDSSQ - EDS) SRQ-20 | Step 1: 15 item SQ-EDS was made based on the study by Srinivasan et al., 1995 on 210 subjects | Among 210 subjects assessed individually, no criterion-based diagnosis of AN or BN could be made. About 14.8% of subjects were identified as having EDS which did not fit into any of the standard diagnostic criteria for major eating disorders |
Step 2: The questionnaire was validated in another set of 146 students against 20-item SRQ-20 | ||||||
In Step 2, none of the subjects could be diagnosed with AN, BN, or partial syndrome of AN or BN. | ||||||
About 11% of subjects were diagnosed with EDS | ||||||
Mammen et al., 2007 Vellore[16] | Medical charts of 3274 patients attending child and adolescent psychiatry unit | Hospital child guidance clinic | Consecutive sampling | ICD-10 | Retrospective chart review of patient records of consecutive children and adolescents availing. Child and Adolescent Psychiatry Unit services from 2000-2005. | After chart review, 41 cases were identified. About 1.25% had an eating disorder. 85.4% (35 cases) had psychogenic vomiting. 14.6% (6 cases) had AN psychogenic vomiting (F: M=2:1.5) and AN (F: M=5:1) was predominantly seen in females. |
The case records diagnosed with eating disorder (F 50.0-50.9) as per the ICD-10 were reviewed by a psychiatrist | ||||||
The mean age was around 11.2 (4.3) years. About 44% had psychiatric co-morbidity | ||||||
Kurpad et al., 2010 Bengaluru[17] | n=73 outpatients of psychosis (schizophrenia/psychosis NoS) on treatment | Hospital | Purposive sampling | Eating behavior questionnaire DSM-IV | Eating behavior questionnaire as well as DSM-IV criteria were used for diagnosing. | None of the patients had BED |
BED in patients of psychosis | ||||||
Balhara et al., 2012 New Delhi[18] | n=97 female nursing students | Government nursing college affiliated with tertiary care hospital | Quota sampling | EAT-26, BSQ | Disordered eating attitude and behavior was assessed by a score of more than 20 on | About 4% (n=3) had disordered eating or probable eating disorder. |
A significant correlation was obtained between EAT-26 and BSQ | ||||||
EAT-26. | ||||||
BSQ was used to assess attitude regarding body shape | ||||||
Chellappa and Karunanidhi, 2013 Chennai[19] | n=200 undergraduate female students | Five premier colleges affiliated to the University of Madras | Convenience sampling | EAT-26, State Trait Anxiety Inventory BDI | Abnormal eating attitudes were assessed by EAT-26. Anxiety and depression were assessed by the State Trait Anxiety Inventory and BDI, respectively | 30% of students had abnormal eating attitudes. |
Participants in the abnormal eating attitude category had exhibited higher scores on depression and anxiety when compared to those with normal eating attitudes | ||||||
Jugale et al., 2014 Bengaluru[20] | n=117 females aged between 20-25 years | Five professional college hostels | Convenience sampling | SCOFF | A score of 2 or more on the SCOFF questionnaire was used for diagnosing disordered eating. Score more than 2 on | About 42.7% (n=50) had suspected eating disorders. |
They had a significantly higher prevalence of periomylolysis, dental caries, and tooth sensitivity | ||||||
SCOFF signifies suspected eating disorder. | ||||||
Dental hygiene was assessed by dental professional | ||||||
Upadhyah et al., 2014 Meerut[21] | n=120 females aged between 13-17 years | School | Convenience sampling | EAT-26 | Disordered eating attitude and behavior was assessed by a score of 20 or more on EAT-26 | Nearly 26.67% (n=32) had disordered eating |
Ramaiah, 2015 Bellur[22] | n=172 medical students | Tertiary care rural medical college | Convenience sampling | EAT-26 BSQ | Disordered eating attitude and behavior was assessed by a score of 20 or more on EAT-26. BSQ was used to assess attitude regarding body shape |
About 16.9% (n=29) had disordered eating. A significant correlation was obtained between EAT-26 and BSQ |
Lal et al., 2015 New Delhi[4] | Indian patients of eating disorder=30 outpatient Australian patients of eating disorder (outpatients=30, inpatients=30) All patients were females of age range 1626 years | Private mental health clinics in India and Australia | Convenience sampling | QOL EDs questionnaire DSM-IV |
The diagnostic profiles and the quality of life was assessed by the QOL EDs questionnaire Eating disorder was diagnosed as per the DSM-IV |
No significant difference was noted in global ED-QOL score. Indians compared to Australian patients had: |
Higher beliefs that they overeat more frequently | ||||||
Similar frequency of restriction of food, vomiting, use of laxatives | ||||||
Lesser frequency of beliefs of fears of loss of control over intake of food and having preoccupations with the body or food intake | ||||||
Singh et al., 2016 Manipal[6] | n=550 students | Pre-university colleges | Convenience sampling | EAT-26 | The tendency to develop an eating disorder was assessed by a score of more than 20 on EAT-26 | Nearly 31.09% (n=171) had affinity to develop eating disorder |
Shashank et al., 2016 Mandya[23] | n=134 medical students | Tertiary care medical college and hospital | Convenience sampling | EAT-26 SCOFF | EAT-26 and SCOFF questionnaire was used to assess disordered eating attitude and behavior. | 29.2% and 17.2% of students had disordered eating behavior as per EAT-26 and SCOFF, respectively |
Disordered eating was determined by a cut-off of 20 and 2 on EAT-26 and SCOFF, respectively | ||||||
Gupta et al., 2017 Chandigarh[24] | n=250 medical students | Government Medical College | Convenience sampling | Hindi version of EAT-26 BSQ | Hindi version of 26 item EAT-26 BSQ was used to assess disordered eating attitudes and body shape attitude | Females scored significantly greater on dieting subscale of EAT-26 and BSQ. BSQ was found to be a significant predictor of eating disorder |
Vijayalakshmi et al., 2017 Bengaluru[25] | n=241 medical students n=213 nursing students | Medical college | Convenient sampling | EAT-26 SCOFF Patient health questionnaire | SCOFF questionnaire was used to assess disordered eating behaviors | Males (45.4%) scored higher on the cut-off for SCOFF questionnaire compared to female (31.1%). |
Score more than 2 signifies suspected eating disorder | Males (16.5%) scored higher on the cut-off for EAT-26 compared to female (8.7%) |
AN – Anorexia nervosa; BDI – Beck’s Depression Inventory; BED – Binge eating disorder; BITE – Bulimia investigatory test; BSQ – Body shape questionnaire; BN – Bulimia nervosa; DSM-IV – Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders Version IV; DSM-III – Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders Version III; EAT – Eating attitudes test; EDS – Eating distress syndrome; ICD-10 – International Classification of Diseases; QOL EDs – Quality-of-life for eating disorders questionnaire; SCOFF – Sick, Control, One-stone (14 lbs/6.5 kg), Fat, Food; SRQ – Self-report questionnaire; SQ-EDS – Screening questionnaire for eating distress syndrome