Skip to main content
. 2019 Jul 18;9(7):e024921. doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2018-024921

Table 2.

Risk of bias in included studies. With the Quality in Prognostic Studies tool studies were assessed on the overall risk of bias within each of the six domains and rated as low, moderate or high risk of bias

Study author year Design Study participation Study attrition Prognostic factor measurement Outcome measurement Study confounding Statistical analysis and presentation
Blauuw et al 201519 Prospective cohort Low Moderate Low Low Moderate Low
Brattberg 199320 Prospective cohort Moderate Moderate Low Low Moderate High
Brattberg 200421 Prospective cohort Low Moderate Low Low Low Low
El-Metwally et al 200422 Prospective cohort Low Low Low Low Low Low
El-Metwally et al 200549 Prospective cohort Low Low Low Low Low Low
Flatø et al 199723 Prospective cohort Low Low Low Low Low Low
Holley et al 201724 Prospective cohort Low Low Low Low Low Low
Jones and Macfarlane 200925 Prospective cohort Low Moderate Low Low Low Low
Jussila et al 201426 Prospective cohort Low Moderate Low Low Low Low
Laimi et al 200727 Prospective cohort Low Moderate Low Low Low Low
Lunde et al 201528 Prospective cohort Low Moderate Low Low Low Low
Mikkelsson et al 199729 Prospective cohort Low Low Low Low Moderate Moderate
Mikkelsson et al 199830 Prospective cohort Low Low Low Low Low Moderate
Mikkelsson et al 199931 Prospective cohort Low Low Low Low Low Low
Mikkonen et al 200832 Prospective cohort Low Moderate Low Low Low Low
Mikkonen et al 201233 Prospective cohort Moderate Low Low Low Low Low
Mikkonen et al 201334 Prospective cohort Low Moderate Low Low Low Low
Paananen et al 201035 Prospective cohort Low Moderate Low Low Low Low
Rathleff et al 20139 Prospective cohort and nested case–control Moderate Low Low Low Low Low
Rathleff et al 201636* Prospective cohort Low Low Low Low Low Low
Rathleff et al 201637 Prospective cohort Low Low Low Low Low Low
Sjölie and Ljunggren 200138 Prospective cohort study with a cross sectional part Low Low Low Low Low Low
Sperotto et al 201539 Prospective cohort Low Moderate Low Low High Moderate
Stanford et al 200817 Prospective cohort Low Moderate Low Low Low Low
Ståhl et al 200840 Prospective cohort Low Moderate Low Low Moderate Low
Uziel et al 201041 Prospective cohort Moderate Low Low Low High Moderate

*‘Is knee pain during adolescence a self-limiting condition?’