Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2020 Aug 1.
Published in final edited form as: J Trauma Acute Care Surg. 2019 Aug;87(2):440–450. doi: 10.1097/TA.0000000000002370

Table 1.

Summary of screens available for PTSD and/or Depression in hospitalized trauma patients

Sensitivity/Specificity* Benefits Limitations
In-person screens
Symptom screens
 PTSD Checklist for DSM-5 (PCL5)

20 items; Likert scale (0 - 4)
Not documented in this population
  • Well established measure that examines specific symptoms of PTSD

  • Previous iterations of the screen are well validated across multiple populations

  • Diagnostic tool not designed to predict PTSD

  • Not predictive of depression

  • No validation study for a cut-off in the hospitalized injured population

 Posttraumatic Adjustment Screen (PAS)

10 items; Likert scale (0 - 4)
12 months post injury:
 PTSD = .82/.84
 Depression = .72/.75
  • Created for and normed on the traumatic injury population

  • Cross validated via subsample

  • Non-U.S. sample with minimal assaultive trauma

  • Likert scale more cumbersome

Peritraumatic Distress Inventory (PDI)

13 items; Likert scale (0 - 4)
1 month post injury:
 PTSD = .71/.73
 Depression = .70/.69
  • Available in multiple languages

  • Recent analysis with the traumatic injury population

  • Cut-scores for depression and PTSD

  • Administered 1 month after injury to predict 1 month distress

  • Likert scale more cumbersome

Risk factor screens
 Predictive screening tool for depression and PTSD after injury

8 items; Yes/No response
Not documented
  • Simple Yes/No response format

  • Created for and normed on Emergency Department population

  • No known validation study

 Inured Trauma Survivor Screen (ITSS)

9 items (5 for PTSD risk, 5 for depression risk, with 1 overlapping item); Yes/No response
One-month post injury:
 PTSD = .75/.94 (≥2)
 Depression = .75/.95 (≥2)
Six-month post injury
 PTSD = .85/.67 (≥2)
 Depression = .73/.70 (≥2)
  • Created for and normed on the traumatic injury population

  • Simple Yes/No response format

  • No known validation study+

Automated screens
Automated EMR screen

10 items collected from electronic medical record
One-month post injury:
 PTSD = .70/.40 (>3)
Six months post injury:
 PTSD = .81/.38 (>3)
12 months post injury:
 PTSD = .84/.36 (>3)
  • Created for and normed on the traumatic injury population

  • Cross validated via validation sample

  • Optimizes population level impact

  • Information may not be available in EMR

  • Not predictive of depression

Note.

*

Refers to the sensitivity and specificity of the measure in the traumatic service population;

+

AAST multi-institutional validation study underway.