Skip to main content
. 2019 Jul 24;10:864. doi: 10.3389/fphys.2019.00864

Table 3.

Characteristics of excluded studies investigating 1-vs. 3-sets.

References Design Status Sex N Age, y, mean ± SD or range Frequency Duration (wk) Sets Reps Strength outcomes The reasoning for exclusion from the current analysis
Kraemer, 1997 RAN T M 40 20± 2.3 3 12 1/3 8–12 1RM BP, 1RM LP Excluded due to differences between groups, single circuit group performed forced reps at the end, and multiple circuit group did no forced reps
Borst et al., 2001 CT U C 31 37± 7 3 25 1/3 8–12 Sum of 1RM for CP and LExt Excluded due to inadequate evidence of pre-and post-intervention training means and SDs to calculate an effect size
McBride et al., 2003 RCT U C 28 21.52± 1.3 2 12 1/3 6–15 1RM LP; 1RM BC Excluded due to amount of sets subjects were performing
Galvão and Taaffe, 2005 RAN U C 28 65–78 2 20 1/3 8 Maximum isokinetic and isometric KExt strength Excluded due to subjects age range
Munn et al., 2005 RCT U C 115 20.6 ± 6.1 3 6 1/3 6–8 1RM EFlex Excluded due to the primary aim, which was the effects of contraction speed with one or three-sets at fast or slow speeds
Rønnestad et al., 2007 RAN U M 21 26.6± 0.1 3 11 1/3 7–10 1RM lower body (LP, LExt, LC); 1RM upper body (CP, Row, LatP, BC, SP) Provided the subjects with nutritional supplementation (protein chocolate bar) and energy drinks during each exercise bout
Starkey et al., 1996 RCT U C 48 18–50 3 14 1/3 8–12 Maximal isometric KFlex; KExt Study data identified as an outlier when observed using the Galbraith plot

N, number; y, years; SD, standard deviation; wk, weeks; Reps, repetitions; RAN, randomly assigned trial; T, trained; M, male; 1RM, 1 repetition maximum; BP, bench press; LP, leg press; CT, control trial; U, untrained; C, male and female subjects combined; CP, chest press; LExt, leg extension; SD, standard deviation; RCT, randomized controlled trial; BC, bicep curl; KExt, knee extensor; EFlex, elbow flexor; LC, leg curl; Row, seated row; LatP, latissimus pull-down; SP, shoulder press; KFlex, knee flexion.