Skip to main content
. 2004 Apr 19;2004(2):CD004050. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD004050.pub2
Study Reason for exclusion
Beauchemin 1996 Allocation: randomized. 
 Participants: patients with non‐seasonal depression. 
 Interventions: bright (sunlight) vs dim rooms (in brightly lit rooms variability in intensity of light (both at different times of a day and on sunny/cloudy days).
Beauchemin 1997 Allocation: randomized. 
 Participants: patients with non‐seasonal depression. 
 Interventions: 10,000 lux vs 2,500 lux (also lower experimental level of light intensity is high and clearly active).
Benedetti 2001 Allocation: randomized. 
 Participants: patients with non‐seasonal depression. 
 Interventions: bright (sunlight) vs dim rooms (in brightly lit rooms variability in intensity of light (both at different times a day and on sunny/cloudy days).
Benloucif 2002 Allocation: not randomized.
Brown 2001 Allocation: randomized. 
 Participants: women with non‐seasonal depressive symptoms. 
 Interventions: Tri‐modal intervention (walk+outdoor light+vitamin) vs placebo vitamin.
Corral 2001 Allocation: randomized. 
 Participants: postpartum depressives, more than 20% of the patients with seasonal depression.
Dietzel 1986 Allocation: not randomized, case‐control design.
Gordijn 1998 Allocation: not randomized, case‐control, crossover design.
Heim 1988 Allocation: randomization not stated, crossover design. 
 Participants: patients with cyclothymic axial syndrome. 
 Intervention: bright light vs sleep deprivation.
Kasper 1989 Allocation: balanced randomized. 
 Participants: general population with seasonal difficulties of varying degrees.
Kripke 1981 Allocation: quasi‐randomized.
Köhler 1989 Allocation: randomization not stated. 
 Participants: patients with seasonal depression.
Leibenluft 1995 Allocation: non‐randomized, crossover, longitudinal comparison.
Martin 2001 Allocation: randomized. 
 Participants: nursing home patients, no clinical diagnosis of depression.
Neudorfer 1989 Allocation: randomized. 
 Participants: patients with non‐seasonal depression. 
 Interventions: light therapy for depressive patients with atypical symptoms vs for depressive patients with classical symptoms.
Oren 2002 Allocation: not randomized, open trial.
Pinchasov 2000 Allocation: randomized. 
 Participants: patients with seasonal or non‐seasonal depression. 
 Interventions: bright light vs exercise (both active treatments).
Prasko 1988a Allocation: randomization not stated. Authors contacted, no response as yet.
Prasko 1988b Allocation: randomization not stated. Authors contacted, no response as yet.
Reide 1994 Allocation: quasi‐randomized (alternation).
Stewart 1990 Allocation: randomization not stated. 
 Participants: More than 20% of the patients with seasonal depression. Contrast between patients with seasonal affective disorder and patients with atypical depression.
Stinson 1990 Allocation: not randomized, open trial.
Thalén 2001 Allocation: not randomized.
Wehr 1985 Allocation: randomized. 
 Participants: more than 20% of patients with seasonal depression.
Yerevanian 1986 Allocation: not randomized, open trial.