Skip to main content
. 2019 Jul 7;9(4):331–335. doi: 10.1016/j.jobcr.2019.07.001

Table 1.

Mean, difference of means, random error (Dahlberg) and Intraclass correlation (ICC) for intra-method analysis of the face measurements in the direct technique (caliper) and 3D scanner.


Direct measurement (caliper)
3D Scanner

Mean



Mean



Variables
W/out
With
Difference X1-X2
Random error
ICC p-value
W/out
With
Difference X3-X4
Random error
ICC p-value
point
point
point
point
(mm) X1 X2 mm (%) mm (%) X3 X4 mm (%) mm (%)
N–Sn 53,64 53,15 0,49 0,92 1,23 2.30 0,88*** 51,62 53,73 −2,11 −4,01 1,89 3.59 0,73**
N–Me 117,74 115,34 2,4 2,06 2,47 2.12 0,86*** 114,88 116,53 −1,65 −1,43 2,01 1.74 0,91***
Sn–Me 64,74 63,71 1,03 1,60 1,71 2.66 0,87*** 64,99 64,28 0,71 1,10 1,76 2.72 0,87***
ExR-ExL 98,96 98,17 0,79 0,60 1,77 1.35 0,94*** 97,14 99,18 −2,04 −2,08 1,87 1.91 0,93***
ChR-ChL 50,97 51,15 −0,18 −0,35 0,99 1.94 0,89*** 50,87 52,03 −1,16 −2,.25 1,41 2.74 0,86***
Pg-TR 141,96 143,86 −1,9 −1,33 2,01 1.41 0,92*** 144,13 146,54 −2,41 −1.66 2,06 1.42 0,93***
Pg-TL 141,52 143,08 −1,56 −1,10 1,88 1.32 0,93*** 142,88 144,73 −1,85 −1.29 2,08 1.45 0,93***
Pg-GoR 101,27 97,60 3,67 3,69 4,42 4.45 0,45* 99,69 99,02 0,67 0.67 3,27 3.29 0,74**
Pg-GoL 101,40 96,47 4,93 4,98 4,28 4.33 0,47* 98,98 97,65 1,33 1.35 3,27 3.33 0,75**
Sn-Ls 13,56 13,66 −0,1 −0,73 1,20 8.82 0,83*** 14,95 14,31 0,64 4.37 0,82 5.60 0,89***
Me–Li 34,11 33,36 0,75 2,22 1,25 3.71 0,84*** 34,05 33,74 0,31 0.91 1,73 5.10 0,71*

*p < 0,05 **p < 0,001 ***p < 0,0001.

Realibility: ICC< 0,4 (Poor) 0,4 ≤ ICC < 0,75 (medium to good) ICC ≥ 0,75 (excellent).