Skip to main content
. 2019 Jun 11;56(8):3732–3743. doi: 10.1007/s13197-019-03845-z

Table 2.

Analysis of variance (ANOVA) for the fitted models of the various responses

Source Yield Viscosity Lightness Acidity Reducing sugar TSS
SS p value SS p value SS p value SS p value SS p value SS p value
Model 1305.4309 < 0.0001** 22,568.72 < 0.0001** 295.3533 < 0.0001** 8.881777 < 0.0001** 51,428.16 < 0.0001** 10.93617 < 0.0001**
X1: Temperature 220.0387 < 0.0001** 12.04167 0.5438 ns 0.324338 0.5492 ns 0.002017 0.7861 ns 9427.581 < 0.0001** 2.666667 < 0.0001**
X2: Time 196.4820 < 0.0001** 5370.042 < 0.0001** 276.2852 < 0.0001** 0.546017 0.0004** 956.47 0.0007** 0.201667 0.0487*
X3: Cellulase 298.4265 < 0.0001** 1683.375 < 0.0001** 3.912338 0.0503* 0.100363 0.0702 ns 363.0926 0.0186* 0.026667 0.4475 ns
X4: Pectinase 153.2676 < 0.0001** 2583.375 < 0.0001** 0.161704 0.6714 ns 0.041667 0.2283 ns 2123.461 < 0.0001** 0.666667 0.0014**
X21 66.9732 0.0005** 10,285.36 < 0.0001** 2.079003 0.1417 ns 6.471855 < 0.0001** 12,373.94 < 0.0001** 0.4725 0.0050**
X22 0.9632 0.5998 ns 28.00298 0.3585 ns 0.672324 0.3916 ns 0.43373 0.0010** 8999.429 < 0.0001** 3.986786 < 0.0001**
X23 7.4494 0.1572 ns 11.0744 0.5602 ns 1.701453 0.1809 ns 1.275268 < 0.0001** 14,015.49 < 0.0001** 1.981071 < 0.0001**
X24 2.0166 0.4508 ns 140.1458 0.0512 ns 5.875074 0.0198* 0.101227 0.0691 ns 7223.834 < 0.0001** 0.026786 0.4465 ns
X1X2 294.7231 < 0.0001** 0.5625 0.8950 ns 2.197806 0.1316 ns 0.551306 0.0004** 491.8415 0.0077** 0.4225 0.0072**
X1X3 6.2625 0.1925 ns 264.0625 0.0108* 2.949806 0.0844 ns 0.275625 0.0056** 1905.541 < 0.0001** 0.0025 0.8145 ns
X1X4 23.4014 0.0186 ns 217.5625 0.0185* 0.345156 0.5369 ns 0.008556 0.5777 ns 2596.667 < 0.0001** 0 1.0000 ns
X2X3 12.2325 0.0754 ns 189.0625 0.0264* 0.247506 0.6003 ns 0.021025 0.3864 ns 30.94141 0.4529 ns 0.1225 0.1153 ns
X2X4 3.3581 0.3328 ns 264.0625 0.0108* 0.507656 0.4552 ns 0.142506 0.0347* 2019.379 < 0.0001** 0 1.0000 ns
X3X4 8.0231 0.1428 ns 540.5625 0.0008** 0.558756 0.4338 ns 0.0529 0.1774 ns 1360.688 0.0001** 0.25 0.0305*
Residual 50.2668 468.0833 12.95924 0.396158 781.4003 0.6575
Lack of fit 31.0149 0.6399 ns 217.25 0.8782 ns 8.353642 0.5832 ns 0.346074 0.0918 ns 699.5696 0.0612 ns 0.449167 0.4977 ns
Pure error 19.25188 250.8333 4.6056 0.050083 81.83075 0.208333
Cor. total 1355.698 23,036.8 308.3126 9.277935 52,209.56 11.59367
R2 0.962881 0.979681 0.957967 0.957301 0.985033 0.943288
Adjusted R2 0.928236 0.960717 0.918737 0.917449 0.971065 0.890357
Predicted R2 0.84755 0.930001 0.822424 0.777374 0.920563 0.750967
Adequacy Precision 23.22516 28.56515 20.64924 17.06782 24.41392 19.58893

SS sum of squares, ns non significant

**Significant at α = 0.01; *significant at α = 0.05