Skip to main content
. 2019 Jul 19;4(7):12385–12392. doi: 10.1021/acsomega.9b01566

Table 2. The Performance of the Fitted Empirical Scaling Factors for the Eight Methods in Table 1.

method R2a RMSDb RMSDc R2a RMSDb RMSDc
  SMD CPCM
1 0.9812 3.40 19.52 0.9813 3.38 19.41
2 0.9811 3.40 19.18 0.9812 3.40 19.07
3 0.9812 3.40 19.57 0.9813 3.39 19.45
4 0.9811 3.41 19.22 0.9812 3.40 19.11
5 0.9807 3.45 18.35 0.9803 3.48 18.32
5′d 0.9796 3.55 18.11 0.9818 3.34 18.49
6 0.9801 3.50 18.10 0.9800 3.50 17.99
7 0.9811 3.41 20.17 0.9815 3.37 20.06
7′d 0.9821 3.31 19.51 0.9832 3.21 19.45
8 0.9807 3.45 22.38 0.9808 3.44 22.30
a

R2 is the coefficient of determination for the linear regression.

b

RMSD for the predicted chemical shifts of the boron-containing molecules in the database (see Table S1 in the Supporting Information) with respect to their respective experimental values (in ppm) with linear regression.

c

RMSD for the predicted chemical shifts of the boron-containing molecules in the database (see Table S1 in the Supporting Information) with respect to their respective experimental values (in ppm) without linear regression (using BF3OEt2 as reference).

d

Implicit solvent models (CPCM or SMD) were included in the optimization step.