Table 1. Summary tables of prospective/retrospective series in nccRCC.
Study name or first author | Drug/s | N | Line of treatment | Type of study | ORR | PFS | OS |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
ASPEN | Everolimus vs. Sunitinib | 108 | First | Prospective | Everolimus =8%; Sunitinib =18% | Everolimus =5.6 months (5.5–60); Sunitinib =8.3 (5.8–11.4) | Everolimus =13.2 (9.7–37.9); Sunitinib =31.5 (14.8–NA) |
ESPN | Everolimus vs. Sunitinib | 68 | First/Second | Prospective | Everolimus =3%; Sunitinib =11% | Everolimus =4.1 months (2.7–10.5); Sunitinib =6.1 (4.2–9.4) | Everolimus =14.9 (8.0–23.4); Sunitinib =16.2 (14.2–NA) |
RECORD 3 | Everolimus vs. Sunitinib | 66 | First/Second | Prospective | NR | Everolimus =5.1 months (2.6–7.9); Sunitinib =7.2 (5.4–13.8) | NR |
NCT00726323 | Foretinib | 74 | First/Second | Prospective | 13.5% | 9.3 months (6.9–12.9) | Not reached |
NCT02127710 | Savolitinib | 109 | First | Prospective | 18% (in MET +) | MET+ =6.2 months (4.1–7.0) | NR |
ARCC NCT00065468 | INF vs. Temsirolimus | 73 | First | Prospective | INF =12%; Temsirolimus =12% | INF=1.8 (1.6–2.1); Temsirolimus=7.0 (3.9–8.9) | INF =4.3 (3.2–7.3); Temsirolimus =11.6 (8.9–13) |
RAPTOR | Everolimus | 88 | First | Prospective | 1% | pRCC type I =7.9 (2.1–11); pRCC type II =5.1 (3.3–5.5) | pRCC type I =28.0 (7.6–NA); pRCC type II =24.2 (15.8–32.8) |
SUPAP | Sunitinib | 61 | First | Prospective | NR | pRCC type I =6.6 (2.8–14.8); pRCC type II =5.5 (3.8–7.1) | pRCC type I =17.8 (5.7–26.1); pRCC type II =12.4 (8.4–14.3) |
NCT01798446 | Axitinib | 40 | Second/Third | Prospective | 37.5% | 7.4 months (5.2–9.5) | 12.1 months (6.4–17.7) |
Martínez Chanzá N | Cabozantinib | 112 | All | Retrospective | 27% | Time to treatment failure: 6.7 months (5.5–8.6) | 12 months OS 51% (39–62%) |
Pisciandaro M | Cabozantinib | 17 | All | Retrospective | 35% | 7.83 months (0.4–13.4) | 12 months OS: 60% |
Matthew T. Campbell | Cabozantinib | 30 | All | Retrospective | 14.3% | 8.6 months (6.1–14.7) | 25.4 months (11.4–28.8) |
De Giorgi U. | Nivolumab | 35 | All | Retrospective | 19.3% | NR | NR |
Koshkin Vadim S | Nivolumab | 41 | All | Retrospective | 20% | 3.5 months | Not reached |
NR, not reported; OS, overall survival; PFS, progression free survival; ORR, objective response rate; N, number of patients.