Skip to main content
. 2019 Jun;52:1–23. doi: 10.1016/j.dr.2019.02.001

Table 2.

Summary of characteristics of all studies included in the review (n = 18).

PICO variable Study characteristics
Population Age range: 4; 4–10 years. Mean x¯=7.8y
Status:
  • Typically developing children (n = 12)

  • Language impaired children (n = 1)

  • Children with reading difficulties (n = 1)

  • Children with identified WM difficulties (n = 1)

  • Children considered at risk of learning difficulties (n = 1)

  • Children with Down’s syndrome (n = 1)

  • Overweight children (n = 1)

Studies specifically targeting children from low socio-economic status (SES) (n = 0)
Intervention Intervention approach:
  • Adapting the environment (n = 1);

  • Direct WM training without strategy instruction (n = 3)

  • Direct WM training with strategy instruction (n = 5);

  • Training skills that indirectly impact on WM (n = 9).
    • physical activity (n = 5);
    • phonological awareness skills (n = 2);
    • fantastical play (n = 1);
    • inhibition (n = 1).
Where the intervention was delivered:
  • via Skype (n = 1)

  • school (n = 12)

  • preschool setting (n = 1)

  • gym (n = 1)

  • No detail given (n = 3)

Unit of delivery (grouping of participants):
  • Individual (n = 8)

  • Small group (n = 6)

  • Whole class (n = 2)

  • Combination of individual and small group (n = 2).

Dosage:
  • Total duration of intervention ranged from 10 days to 11 months

  • Average total intervention duration in weeks x¯=13

Comparison Study design:
  • Randomised controlled trials (n = 8)

  • Quasi-experimental designs (n = 9)

  • Case series (n = 1)

Control group conditions:
  • Active control groups (n = 2)

  • No intervention control groups (n = 14)

  • Own matched controls (n = 2)

Sampling:
  • Power analysis reported (n = 0)

  • Sample size range across all included studies (n = 4 to n = 256).

Average sample size x¯=74
Outcomes Measurement of WM:
  • Verbal STM (n = 11)

  • Visuospatial STM (n = 7)

  • Verbal ELWM (n = 14)

  • Visuospatial ELWM (n = 4)

  • Studies which measured more than one aspect of WM (n = 7)

  • Studies which implemented a standardised measure of WM (n = 5)

Measurement of transfer effects:
  • Near-transfer (n = 4)

  • Far-transfer (n = 7)

Durability over time (n = 4)