Skip to main content
. 2019 Aug 5;9(8):e023080. doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2018-023080

Table 1.

General characteristics of included studies (N=26)

Characteristics Number, n Percentage
Publication year
 2000–2004 4 15.4
 2005–2009 4 15.4
 2010–2015 18 69.2
Location of the study
 Australia 5 19.2
 Canada 2 7.7
 Finland 1 3.8
 Iran 1 3.8
 Netherlands 1 3.8
 New Zealand 1 3.8
 Sweden 1 3.8
 Switzerland 1 3.8
 Taiwan 3 11.5
 UK 6 23.1
 USA 4 15.4
Study design
 Cross-sectional 11 42.3
 Randomised controlled trial 8 30.8
 Cohort 1 3.8
 Phenomenological 4 15.4
 Observational 1 3.8
 Mixed method 1 3.8
Elective surgery specialty*
 General surgery 10 37
 Ophthalmology 0 0
 Neurosurgery 0 0
 Orthopaedics 10 37
 ENT 1 3.7
 Urology 1 3.7
 Gynaecology 0 0
 Bariatric/cosmetic/plastic surgery 3 7.4
 Thoracic surgery 1 3.7
 Craniofacial surgery 0 0
 Cancer-related surgery 1 3.7

*There were no studies reporting ophthalmology, neurosurgery, gynaecology, thoracic surgery or craniofacial surgery. One study included urological and general surgery.

ENT, ear, neck and throat.