Skip to main content
. 2019 Jul 26;21(7):e14464. doi: 10.2196/14464

Table 1.

Summary of advantages and disadvantages of segmentation methods.

Methods Advantages Disadvantages
GTa Widely used as preprocessing step in image processing as these methods are easy to implement Not suitable for segmentation of ROIsb, as GT methods produce high false positive detections
Local thresholding Works well compared with GT, sometimes used to improve the GT results Widely used in literature as initialization step of other algorithms, but local thresholding fails to separate the pixels accurately into suitable regions
Region growing Uses pixel connectivity properties to grow iteratively and sum up the region having similar pixel properties Need initialization point, that is, a seed point to begin with and highly dependent on initial guess
Region clustering No seed point required to initialize; it can directly search the cluster regions. Total number of clusters need to be predefined at initial stage
Edge detection Highly suitable for detecting the object boundaries and contours of the suspected ROIs Requires some information about object properties
Template matching Needs ground truth and are easily implemented. Easy implementation; if the prototypes are suitably selected, it can produce good results. Need prior information about the region properties of the objects such as size, shape, and area.
Multiscale technique Do not require any prior knowledge about object properties Requires empirical evaluation to select the appropriate wavelet transform
Easily discriminate among the coefficients at different level and scale of decompositions Need to select scale of decompositions

aGT: Global thresholding.

bROI: region of interest.