Skip to main content
. 2019 Jul 30;10:1753. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2019.01753

TABLE 7.

Percentages of moral self-attribution and the educative cycle.

Shame
Guilt
Indifference
Pride
Total
n (%) ASR n (%) ASR n (%) ASR n (%) ASR n (%)
Exclusion 147 6.4∗∗ 40 –5.6∗∗ 78 –1.0 3 –1.1 268
First stage (54.9%) (14.9%) (29.1%) (1.1%) (100%)
Exclusion 100 –3.6∗∗ 112 3.2∗∗ 107 0.7 6 0.0 325
Second stage (30.8%) (34.5%) (32.9%) (1.8%) (100%)
Exclusion 126 −2.4* 117 2.0* 119 0.3 9 1.0 371
Third stage (34.0%) (31.5%) (32.1%) (2.4%) (100%)
Physical 149 5.5∗∗ 67 –5.2∗∗ 49 –0.1 3 –1.1 268
First stage (55.6%) (25.0%) (18.3%) (1.1%) (100%)
Physical 122 –1.8 136 1.7 62 0.3 5 –0.5 325
Second stage (37.5%) (41.8%) (19.1%) (1.5%) (100%)
Physical 130 –3.3∗∗ 164 3.1∗∗ 67 –0.3 10 1.5 371
Third stage (35.0%) (44.2%) (18.1%) (2.7%) (100%)
Indirect relational 180 6.6∗∗ 40 –3.7∗∗ 44 –3.7∗∗ 4 –1.1 268
First stage (67.2%) (14.9%) (16.4%) (1.5%) (100%)
Indirect relational 147 −2.1* 86 1.8 86 1.0 6 –0.8 325
Second stage (45.2%) (26.5%) (26.5%) (1.8%) (100%)
Indirect relational 155 –4.0∗∗ 96 1.7 107 2.4* 13 1.8 371
Third stage (41.8%) (25.9%) (28.8%) (3.5%) (100%)
Verbal 159 4.8∗∗ 57 −2.1* 52 −2.5* 0 –2.9∗∗ 268
First stage (59.3%) (21.3%) (19.4%) (0.0%) (100%)
Verbal 147 –0.7 93 1.3 80 –0.2 5 –1.0 325
Second stage (45.2%) (28.6%) (24.6%) (1.5%) (100%)
Verbal 145 –3.8∗∗ 101 0.7 109 2.5* 16 3.6∗∗ 371
Third stage (39.1%) (27.2%) (29.4%) (4.3%) (100%)

Adjusted standardized residuals ≥1.96. ∗∗Adjusted standardized residuals ≥2.58.