Table 2. Penetration enhancing techniques for treating onychomycosis.
Category | Technique | Specifications | Procedure | Advantages | Disadvantages | Reference |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Mechanical | Nail avulsion | Complete separation of nail plate from other units, | Anesthesia followed by Surgical (physical removal) or chemical (application of urea ointment) | No side effects or long term complications. | Postoperative nail deformity, pain. | [24-26] |
Nail abrasion | Filing or debriment of nail plate so as to increase penetration of topical antifungal drug | Sanding of the nail plate with sandpaper number 150 or 180 attached to dermabrader device | Decreases the critical fungal mass and aids the penetration, better patient acceptability, no complications. | Better efficacy is obtained in combination with topical antifungal agents. Also requires expert help. | [27, 28] | |
Chemical | Addition of penetration enhancing chemical compounds | Keratolytic agents, enzymes, organic solvents, thiols, mercaptans, hydrophobins | These are added in the topical formulation as penetration enhancers | Enhanced nail permeation, non- invasive, convenient. | Itching, irritation at the site of application. | [28] |
Physical | Iontophoresis | Comprises of two electrodes and a power source | Application of small electric current (0.5 mA.cm-2) to enhance penetration | Does not affect nail structure, affordable, patient compliant. | Inappropriate intensity of current, cutaneous side effects. | [28-31] |
Laser therapy | Includes Nd:YAG short pulse and Q switch 1064 nm and the diode 870, 930, and 980 nm |
Avulsion/ abrasion of the nail plate followed by laser treatment at 5000W/cm2 power density or applying CO2 laser beam with daily topical antifungal drug | Bypasses systemic toxicity, non- invasive, no teratogenic risks, no photo- ablation. | Tissue damage, photoageing, too many parameters to be controlled for desired results, less specificity, less information, high cost. | [32-34] | |
Photodynamic | Employs a light source to excite the photo-sensitizer to create reactive oxygen species which destroys fungal structure | Delivered in combination with methyl-aminolevulinic acid (three sessions, with 15 days interval) or 5-aminolevulinic acid (once a week) | No relapses, no hepatotoxicity, no interactions with drugs. | Teratogenic risks, slight pain, restriction in exposure to direct sunlight or heat for at least 2 days, improper penetration (for which either urea is employed or microabrasion is done). | [35-38] | |
Ultrasound | Low frequency ultrasonic waves improve penetration by forming micropores in the nail structure | 400 and 600 kHz frequencies and duration of 120 seconds were found most efficient for application | Enhanced and controlled rate of penetration, no systemic side effects. | Complicated device, expert help necessary, costly. | [39-48] |