[59] |
Commercial |
Paid |
Comparison with ground truth not provided. One paper reports the reproducibility: 2.65% max SD |
Yes |
Yes |
[71] |
Commercial |
Paid |
Comparison with ground truth not provided. One paper reports the reproducibility: 1.57% max SD |
Yes |
Yes |
[49] |
Research |
data and code for demo available at http://bit.do/eTTai
|
tracking performance not reported, behavioral classification of 12 traits reported to be max at 71% |
Tracking real time, classification offline |
yes |
[51] |
Research |
not available |
tracking: SD of only 0.034% when compared with ground truth, Max SD of 1.71 degrees in estimating joint angle |
real time legs and joints tracking |
yes, invasive |
[52] |
Research |
not available |
tracking performance not reported explicitly |
real time whisker tracking |
yes, semi-invasive |
[53] |
Research |
available on request |
whisker tracking performance not reported explicitly |
real time single whisker tracking |
yes, semi-invasive |
[54] |
Research |
not available |
head motion tracked correctly with a max false positive of 13% |
real time head and snout tracking |
yes, semi-invasive |
[55] |
Research |
not available |
head motion tracked continuously with a reported SD of only 0.5 mm |
real time head and snout tracking |
yes, semi-invasive |
[57] |
Research |
not available |
head motion tracked with an accuracy of 96.3% and the tracking can be reproduced over multiple studies with a correlation coefficient of 0.78 |
real time head tracking |
yes, semi-invasive |
[89] |
Research |
code and demo data available at https://goo.gl/vYaYPy
|
they reported a correlation between whisking amplitude and velocity as a measure of reliability, R = 0.89 |
Offline head and whisker tracking |
no, invasive |
[90] |
Research |
not available |
Tracking and gait prediction with confidence of 95%, deviation between human annotator and computer at 8% |
Offline |
yes, semi-invasive |
[93] |
Research |
not available |
Paw tracked with an accuracy of 88.5 on transparent floor and 83.2% on opaque floor |
Offline |
yes, semi-invasive |
[95] |
Research |
code available at https://goo.gl/58DQij
|
tail and paws tracked with an accuracy >90% |
Real time |
yes, semi-invasive |
[97] |
Research |
not available |
5 class behavioral classification problem, accuracy in bright condition is 95.34 and in dark conditions is 89.4% |
offline |
yes, non-invasive |
[100] |
Research |
not available |
6 behavioral class accuracy: 66.9%, 4 behavioral class accuracy: 76.3% |
offline |
yes, non-invasive |
[98] |
Research |
code available at https://goo.gl/eY2Yza
|
whisker detection rate: 76.9%, peak spatial error in whisker detection: 10 pixels |
offline |
yes, non-invasive |
[101] |
Research |
not available |
Peak deviation between human annotator and automated annotation: 0.5 mm with a camera of 6 pixel/mm resolution |
offline |
yes, non-invasive |
[92] |
Research |
not available |
Tracking accuracy >90% after the algorithm was assisted by human users in 3–5% of the frames |
offline |
yes, semi-invasive |
[105] |
Research |
code available at https://goo.gl/Gny89o
|
A max deviation of 17.7% between human and automated whisker annotation |
offline |
yes, non-invasive |
[107] |
Research |
not available |
Maximum paw detection error: 5.9%, minimum error : 0.4% |
offline |
no, non-invasive |
[110] |
Research |
Source code at https://goo.gl/zesyez, demo data at https://goo.gl/dn2L3y
|
Behavioral classification: 1% false positive rate |
offline |
no, semi-invasive |
[108] |
Research |
Source code available at https://goo.gl/JCv3AV
|
Whisker tracing accuracy: max error of 0.45 pixels |
offline |
no, non-invasive |
[116] |
Research |
not available |
Correlation with annotated data; for whiskers r = 0.78, for limbs r = 0.85 |
real time |
no, non-invasive |
[109] |
Research |
code available at https://goo.gl/V54mpL
|
Velocity calculated by AGATHA was off from manually calculated velocity by 1.5% |
real time |
no, non-invasive |
[117] |
Research |
code available at http://bit.ly/2vgJUbr
|
Detected pose matched ground truth with an accuracy of pixels |
real time on GPUs |
no, non-invasive |
[119] |
Research |
code available at https://bit.ly/2XuJmPv
|
No performance metric reported |
offline |
no, non-invasive |