Study | Reason for exclusion |
---|---|
Calik‐Kutukcu 2016 | Investigation of the effects of music listening during exercise in people with CF. |
Chung 2011 | Not an intervention study, but a summary of complementary and alternative therapies for children with a respiratory condition. |
Frias 2018 | Intervention did not include singing, but listening to specially composed music during chest physiotherapy. |
Goldbeck 2014 | A Cochrane Review of psychological interventions for people with CF. |
Goldenberg 2012 | Not an RCT, but a collective case study on the effects of voice lessons on pulmonary function and quality of life in adults with CF. |
Goldenberg 2018 | Not an RCT ‐ a literature review on the benefits of singing. |
Grasso 2000 | Intervention is not singing, but using pre‐recorded music during daily chest percussion routine with toddlers. |
Grossoehme 2014 | Parents of children with CF included looking as using spirituality to deal with stress; singing was not explored. |
Irons 2014 | A qualitative study, exploring the benefits of singing for children and young people with CF |
Kaak 2011 | Intervention is not singing, but playing the didgeridoo. |
Kamioka 2014 | A systematic review of the effects of music therapy interventions. |
Kemper 2005 | Not an RCT; did not explore singing; did not include people with CF. |
Main 2005 | A Cochrane Review of physiotherapy for people with CF. |
Moola 2012 | Qualitative study; did not explore singing. |
Mrazova 2010 | A systematic review of music therapy for children; not singing. |
Reichardt 2011 | People with CF were not included; a observational study on Hustifex®‐Brummer® ‐ a singing method specially developed for people with COPD. |
Roux 2007 | Intervention is not singing, but listening to music; people with CF were not included. |
Whitehead 2018 | A review summary on singing as an adjunct therapy for children and adults with CF. |
CF: cystic fibrosis COPD: chronic obstructive pulmonary disorder RCT: randomised controlled trial