Table 1.
Spillover barriers and associated conventional and ecological interventions that target each barrier layer.
location | spillover barrier | conventional intervention | ecological intervention | examples of ecological interventions | status | intervention no. (figure) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
zoonotic reservoir | reservoir density or distribution | fences, culling | habitat modification | altered food distribution on elk feeding grounds to reduce brucellosis [3]. | demonstrated, with correlational/observational support | 1 |
natural enemies | maintenance of leopard populations to limit rabid feral dog populations [4]. See also [5]. | hypothesized | 2 | |||
pathogen prevalence (in reservoir) | chemotherapy, vaccination of reservoir, test and remove | dilution hosts | increased diversity of host community for Ixodes ticks (e.g. by increasing size of forest fragments) may increase abundance of incompetent hosts for Borrelia burgdorferi, reducing Lyme disease spillover [6]. | demonstrated, but generality of dilution effect of increased biodiversity is debated [7–9] | 3 | |
genetic management | reducing population size and stay-time of poultry in markets minimizes prevalence and genome reassortment of influenza viruses [10]. | demonstrated | 4 | |||
infection intensity or pathogen shedding | reservoir nutrition and susceptibility | supplementing key flowering tree food resources for flying foxes (via habitat conservation/restoration) to boost nutrition and immunity in bats and decrease viral shedding rates of Hendra by bats [11], or similarly preserving native prey communities for vampire bats (rabies) via habitat conservation/restoration, which also encourages bats to feed on wildlife rather than humans or livestock. See also [12]. | hypothesized | 5 | ||
environment | pathogen survival and spread | insecticides, disinfection | habitat modification | Anopheles (malaria) [13] and Culex (West Nile virus, Japanese encephalitis, St Louis encephalitis, also filariasis) mosquito reductions by fish additions to rice fields, while simultaneously increasing rice yields [14]. | hypothesized | 6 |
gene management | gene drive in Anopheles gambiae to control spread of Plasmodium spp. causing malaria [15]. | demonstrated | 7 | |||
natural enemies | maintaining the scavenger community (e.g. eagles and coyotes in the USA, vultures in India [16]) as an important consumer of carcasses that harbour Brucella, anthrax, and other pathogens. See also [17]. | demonstrated, with correlational/observational support | 8 | |||
spillover host | spillover host exposure | chemical repellents, biosecurity | human behaviour modification | bamboo skirts over date palm sap collection pots to reduce bat contamination of sap with Nipah virus in Bangladesh [18,19]. See also [20]. | demonstrated | 9 |
spillover host susceptibility and infection | chemotherapy, vaccination | managing coinfections or microbiome, genetic management | the use of faecal transplant procedures to treat Clostridium difficile with microbial competitors [21]. | demonstrated | no corresponding number in figure |