Table 1. Summary of characteristics of different biomarkers used in liquid biopsy.
Biomarker | Material available | Isolation technique | Clinical applications | Disadvantage |
---|---|---|---|---|
Circulating cfDNA/ctDNA | Cell free fragments of DNA released from tumor cells directly into the bloodstream | EpCAM-based and EpCAM-independent assays available | Represents the entire genome of the primary tumor; can provide diagnosis and prognosis; allows molecular profiling for targeted therapy (i.e., EGFR mutations); used as a real-time monitor of treatment (i.e., with TKI); high sensitivity to correlate with disease burden (metastasis) | Tumor ctDNA is not stable in circulation; ctDNA has a very short half-life; requires very sensitive methods to be able to separate ctDNA from normal cells cfDNA |
ctDNA methylation | DNA fragments released from tumor cells directly into the bloodstream; methylation of certain gene promoter regions in cell DNA regulate the expression of genes involve in carcinogenesis, particularly methylation in tumor suppressor genes | MSP; real-time quantitative MSP; multiplex-nested MSP; Methyl-BEAMing | DNA methylation in cancer makes the circulating DNA more stable; identification of cancer-specific methylation sites can allow early-stage lung cancer detection. Has a very high sensitivity (one of the highest) for detection of early lung cancer; presence of certain methylated genes correlates to poor prognosis | Requires very sensitive methods to be able to separate ctDNA from normal cells cfDNA |
CTC CellSearch™ (Veridex LLC) is the only FDA-approved method now (for breast, colon and prostate cancer) | Circulating tumor cells that originate from detachment from the primary lung cancer; requires a complex process to reach bloodstream and invade other tissues (EMT and MET) | Initial enrichment step that increases concentration of CTC in sample, with isolation of cells based on biological and physical properties (surface proteins/markers, cellular size); CellSearch™ utilizes ferroparticles and antibodies directed to epithelial targets (EpCAM) | Provide all cellular material, including RNAs, DNA and proteins; source of tissue for diagnosis and profiling of cancer; CTC count can correlate to cancer burden (metastasis and progression); monitoring of treatment; detection of residual disease after treatment; CTC level correlates to early recurrence | CTC are very rare compared to normal circulating cells, its isolation is challenging; EMT down-regulates epithelial properties of tumor cells (expression of tumor makers); Low sensitivity and difficult reproducibility; current FDA-approved technology is EpCAM-based isolation |
TEP | Platelets that were in contact with primary tumor and underwent transference of cancer-associated biomolecules | Platelets isolation with extraction of tumor biomolecules and nucleic acids (RNAs) | More abundant than CTC; also contain a large amount of genetic material (RNA and DNA); diagnosis of lung cancer; monitoring of treatment | Technologies to obtain TEP are still in development |
Exosomes | Small vesicles of endocytic origin; exosomes are released by a variety of cells, including lung cancer cells and are captured by other neighboring or distant targets | Isolation based on physical or biological properties of exosomes; MACS; immune-mediated isolation; sucrose gradient method; ultra-centrifugation; after isolation, PCR can be used to separate the RNA and proteins inside the exosomes | Can provide early diagnosis; provide important information about tumor’s biologic profile, growth rate, metastatic capacity and drug resistance; can predict response to treatment; its transport capacity has potential to be a vehicle for therapies | Isolation can be time consuming; physical isolation methods can alter exosome structure; there might be co-isolation of proteins and other contaminants; small sample volumes decrease exosome yield |
cfDNA, cell free DNA; ctDNA, circulating tumor DNA; EpCAM, epithelial cell adhesion molecule; EGFR, epidermal growth factor receptor; CTC, circulating tumor cells; TEP, tumor educated platelets; MACS, magnetic activated cell sorting; PCR, polymerase chain reaction; FDA, Food and Drug Administration; EMT, epithelial-mesenchymal transition; MET, mesenchymal to epithelial transition; MSP, Methylation-specific PCR; TKI, tyrosine kinase inhibitor.