Table 6.
Meta regression BIAS [IQR] | ||||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Binary outcome | Continuous outcome | Survival outcome | ||||||||
Heterogeneity magnitude | Ecological Bias | Large subgroup effect | Medium subgroup effect | No sugroup effect | Large subgroup effect | Medium subgroup effect | No sugroup effect | Large subgroup effect | Medium subgroup effect | No sugroup effect |
No heterogeneity | No ecological bias | -0.026 [2.083] | 0.029 [1.973] | -0.06 [1.893] | -0.009 [0.958] | -0.052 [0.935] | -0.021 [0.911] | -0.085 [1.549] | -0.081 [1.644] | 0.027 [1.366] |
No heterogeneity | Favouring treatment ecological bias | 1.022 [1.872] | 0.5 [1.835] | -0.084 [1.784] | 0.516 [0.912] | 0.236 [0.892] | -0.509 [0.97] | -0.748 [1.71] | -0.399 [1.657] | -0.312 [1.356] |
No heterogeneity | Favouring placebo ecological bias | 2.984 [1.873] | 1.276 [1.73] | 0.076 [1.8] | 1.515 [0.921] | 0.742 [0.94] | 1.006 [0.93] | -2.045 [1.95] | -1.058 [1.689] | 0.701 [1.333] |
Medium heterogeneity | No ecological bias | 0.01 [2.234] | 0.051 [2.067] | -0.046 [1.976] | 0 [1.411] | -0.008 [1.483] | -0.026 [1.365] | -0.013 [1.945] | 0.007 [1.984] | -0.03 [1.749] |
Medium heterogeneity | Favouring treatment ecological bias | 1.008 [2.157] | 0.468 [2.037] | 0.019 [2.104] | 0.449 [1.339] | 0.235 [1.467] | -0.468 [1.437] | -0.689 [2.037] | -0.342 [2.019] | -0.363 [1.738] |
Medium heterogeneity | Favouring placebo ecological bias | 2.963 [2.133] | 1.296 [2.093] | -0.069 [2.014] | 1.525 [1.373] | 0.724 [1.43] | 0.998 [1.479] | -2.011 [2.185] | -1.002 [2.099] | 0.633 [1.72] |
Large heterogeneity | No ecological bias | -0.067 [2.839] | 0.024 [2.92] | 0.021 [2.55] | -0.063 [2.44] | -0.046 [2.295] | 0.101 [2.37] | 0.007 [2.614] | 0.023 [2.682] | -0.056 [2.577] |
Large heterogeneity | Favouring treatment ecological bias | 1.014 [2.737] | 0.516 [2.764] | 0.019 [2.81] | 0.536 [2.179] | 0.195 [2.22] | -0.404 [2.252] | -0.669 [2.633] | -0.298 [2.678] | -0.39 [2.521] |
Large heterogeneity | Favouring placebo ecological bias | 2.883 [2.701] | 1.34 [2.723] | 0.038 [2.721] | 1.426 [2.454] | 0.656 [2.562] | 1.033 [2.264] | -1.984 [2.784] | -0.984 [2.719] | 0.617 [2.491] |