Clinical Populations (n = 15) | |||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Author(s) | Study Design | Sample | Instrument Assessing MiL | SB-Related Variables | |||||
Population | Size (N) | Psychiatric Diagnosis | SI | SA | Completed Suicide | Other SB-Related Variables and Main Commentaries | |||
Moore, 1997 [42] | Qualitative | Elderly | 11 | Depression | Hermeneutic analysis | ↓ | − | − | MiL descriptions were always tied to relational contexts: meaninglessness relative to missing (or perceived to be missing) connectedness |
Heisel and Flett, 2004 [43] | Cross-sectional | Adults | 49 | Various | PIL | ↓ | − | − | MiL accounted for significant variance in SI—also, a mediation model between satisfaction in life and SI and a moderation model between depression and SI |
van Orden et al., 2012 [44] | Longitudinal prospective | Elderly | 65 | Depression, anxiety | GSIS Perceived MiL subscale | − | − | − | “Perceived burdensomeness” might contribute to suicide morbidity and mortality by eroding MiL |
Holm et al., 2014 [45] | Qualitative | Elderly | 9 | Mood disorder | Hermeneutic analysis | ↓ | − | − | MiL in the experience of SI was associated with existential aloneness: “Being alone without MiL” |
García-Alandete et al., 2014 [46] | Cross-sectional | 16–60 yr old | 80 | Borderline personality disorder | PIL-10 | − | − | − | ↓ Suicide risk (measured accounting for general suicide risk factors), ↓ depression,↓ hopelessness |
van Orden et al., 2015 [47] | Qualitative | Elderly | 101 | Various | Semi-structured interviews | − | − | “Thwarted belongingness” was associated with more lethal methods and increased re-attempts | |
Braden et al., 2015 [48] | Cross-sectional | Veterans | 110 | Depressive disorder | LRI Framework subscale | ↓ | − | − | The relationship between MiL and SI remained significant after accounting for depressive symptoms, past SA, prior inpatient psychiatric hospitalization, and poor physical health |
Marco et al., 2016 [19] | Cross-sectional | 13–68 yr old | 224 | Various | PIL-10 | − | − | − | Moderation model: MiL buffered associations between suicide risk factors and hopelessness |
Marco et al., 2017a (study 2) [20] | Cross-sectional | 13–70 yr old | 80 | Borderline personality disorder | PIL-10 | − | ↓ | − | MiL was also negatively correlated with other behavioral symptoms of borderline personality disorders, including suicidal threats, high-risk behaviors, drug overdoses, and aggressive behavior |
Marco et al., 2017b [49] | Cross-sectional | 13–56 yr old | 124 | Borderline personality disorder | PIL-10 | − | − | Moderation model: MiL buffered associations between suicide risk factors and hopelessness | |
Marco et al., 2017c [50] | Cross-sectional case-control | 12–60 yr old | 474 | Eating disorder | PIL | ↓ | − | − | Patients with eating disorders had lower MiLs and greater SI than the controls; MiL predicts greater levels of both eating disorder psychopathologies and SI |
Pérez Rodriguez et al., 2017a [51] | Cross-sectional | 18–60 yr old | 150 | Various | PIL-10 | − | NS | − | Hopelessness (specifically its affective component) differentiated between patients with non-suicidal self-injuries and those with SA but not MiL, which underlies the continuum of self-harm |
Pérez Rodriguez et al., 2017b [52] | Cross-sectional | 12–60 yr old | 348 | Various (mainly eating disorder) | PIL-10 | − | ↓ | − | Lower levels of MiL and higher levels of hopelessness, borderline symptoms, and non-suicidal self-injuries were associated with SA in the previous year |
Lamis et al., 2018 [53] | Cross-sectional | 19–65 yr old | 112 | Bipolar disorder | SWBS (EWB + RWB) | ↓ | − | − | Existential MiL but not religious well-being acted as a protective factor against SI among bipolar disorder patients and those who experienced childhood sexual abuse |
Florez et al., 2018 [54] | Longitudinal prospective | Disadvantaged African American female survivors of a recent SA | 113 | PTSD | SWBS (EWB + RWB) | ↓ | − | − | Mediation model: existential MiL, but not religious well-being, mediated the relationship between PTSD severity and both hopelessness and SI level |
Note: MiL = Meaning in Life; SB = suicidal behavior; SI = suicidal ideation; SA = suicide attempt; PIL = Purpose in Life test; LRI = Life Regard Index; GSIS = Geriatric Suicide Ideation Scale; n.sp. = not specified; MLQ = Meaning in Life Questionnaire; 3-item MLQ = 3-item shortened version of the MLQ; EMIL = Experienced Meaning in Life instrument; PIL-10 = 10-item shortened version of the PIL; MLM = Meaningful Life Measure; yr = years; NS = not significant; SWBS = Spiritual Well-Being Scale; EWB = Existential Well-Being subscale; RWB = Religious Well-Being subscale.